Should a vig who shoots N1 be Modkilled?

[Leafsnail]

Of course, also you should modkill every town player involved in a mislynch

[Leafsnail]

Vig is better than cop if and only if you can identify scum perfectly without inspections (you should be winning the game anyway then).

[Leafsnail]

Having 1 cop-confirmed innocent in 4 player Mlyo is actually better then a 3 man lylo without a cop confirmed innocent, though. The cop still comes out ahead here, I think.

If the vig survives he could claim the kill though. That way he either clears himself or bulletproof/gambiting scum counterclaims and he clears the other townie, assuming there's no possibility of SKs in the game.

[Leafsnail]

My theory is that's because vigs take too many hero shots and miss

That sounds about right. If vig falls into the hands of a poor player it may actually have a worse than random hit rate because they'll go after their incorrect suspicions that the town doesn't agree with them on.

[Leafsnail]

If all the randomly dying players in setup B were bad players/ players agreed to be scummy then setup B.