MeMeMeet Mafia (Game Over!)

[Anonymities]

I'm going to trust Atticus and stay. I'm not even sending a pm. What I said earlier was a theory, nothing more.

Also ditto to Ibaesha's question directed at Dirge.

[olio]

These games are fun and all but we need to get down to the business of finding scum. Vote: Olio

Why do you think voting me will help us find scum?

[mith]

Vote Count:

7 to lynch.

Fritzler: 1 (Quagmire)
olio: 1 (Dirge)

Deadline:

For Round 2 of Prisoner's Dilemma is approximately 7.5 hours from this post.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

vote Quag

die evil upgrader die!

[Atticus]

I have a random paranoia....

Attack mith-mod with Pepperoni bread.

I'm just... interested.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

This town clearly needs a sense of direction, we can't afford to have another scramble at the deadline, and my sense of guilt is starting to annoy me about not helping the matter.

Being incredibly awesome I'm going to try to provide that you with the person that I believe should be today's lynch.

That person is Fishbulb.

The Case

PBPA:

Post 1-3: Mild Bantering, Oneliners and what not

Post 4: Mentions he'd rather not lynch me, would rather lynch Spork, doesn't state reasons. Seems to want to get on my good side and push for the easier lynch target(spork).

Post 5-10: Harps on the point that we

need

to get a lynch without actually contributing to finding a good lynch, attacks Atticus for not having a better alternative while not really giving any valid reason for lynching any particular person, switches position on lynching Pooky at Post 9 without actually stating any reason then promptly jumps onto Fletcher's wagon also without stating any reason on Post 10.

Day TWO

Post 11-14: States why he thinks MOS is suspicious, doesn't actually vote on MOS tho, basically says that it's not enough to vote on, when I see some1 unwilling to put down vote after laying groundwork, I think scum with cold feet, what made day1 Sporkwagon with no reasoning worthy of vote by day2 MOS unworthy of vote even tho you laid out reasoning? It smells very much like someone who doesn't believe a word of what he's posted, just making the effort to look like he is hunting for scum when he's not.

Post 15: Asks Atticus what the reasoning about voting Pooky was, funny how he didn't ask back in Day 1 on post 9 when he stated he was happy with a Pooky vote.

Also another interesting part, in Post 15 he states:

I don't think Atticus is scum. I'm not sure what the deal is with Dirge, I think it is just MoS trying to get to someone. And I got nothing on Fritzler.

I'd be willing to vote anyone except spork76 at this point.

Basically is unwilling to commit to anything on Dirge, continues to press MOS without voting, admits he's got nothing on Fritz but the most interesting thing here I seqe qis that he qstates he THINKS atticus isn't scum, but he STATES that he is willing to vote for a group of people that INCLUDES atticus. Why would he be willing to vote for some1 he thinks ain't guilty? I don't think he was actually thinking when he wrote this, just putting up words to make it look like he was contributing, thus the slip.

Post 16: Honestly this is one of those posts that just doesn't make much sense, it looks like he really wasn't even thinking when he wrote it, I don't even know if he's trying to push for lynching Thesp or not with this post, it's like he's trying to figure out whether his scumteam would be hurt by the lynch of the Jester or if it would just be a wasted lynch by the town.

Post 17: Votes me with pretty much no reasoning other than that I'm the only choice at this point unless we want to be stuck with NL, basically tunnelvisioning the day, making the issue NOT whether Pooky is guilty scumbag or not, but whether we want a lynch or don't want a lynch. This is an alternate version false dilemnaing, instead of stating X or Y is scum and we MUST lynch one of them, he states that either we get a lynch and it's X or we don't get a lynch at all, since getting a lynch is better than not getting one, we should lynch X!(this honestly avoid the question of whether X is scum or not, which SHOULD factor into whether or not you lynch X, he's trying to REMOVE whether X is scum or not from the decision of whether or not you lynch X by stating that it is STRICTLY superior to NL). This is a craplogic move often used when the scum can't dig up any dirt to attack X with.

Post 18-25: honestly I can't really find much contribution to the thread or any hard opinions on anything, he seems content with staying with the tide and trying to make it appear as if he is contributing without actually contributing.

I mean I guess you can say that about a lot of the players who are playing that they are just kind of going along with the tide and not really contributing much, but FB is one who's also shown up for the games and the lynches so it's not like he's entirely not paying attention, just choosing not to really hunt after scum while participating in the activities that result in the most gain for him.

Also on a sidenote, I'd like to point out that going into Night 2, the 2 Point Leaders were Fishbulb and Kristocker, Kris turned up dead on Day 3(allbeit mafia but we're pretty sure from MeMe's death they're not the only baddies out there) I can't really find anything from Kris's posts to suggest a reason why she would've been killed for any reason gameplay related, so I'd believe that the kill was motivated possibly by her Point standing as the scum were lacking better motivation to make the nightkill with, a move that put Fishbulb into sole possession of first place in the point standings.

unvote

vote Fishbulb

[Quagmire]

unvote, vote Pooky

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

well you certainly are consistent with your level of contribution quag.

[mith]

Game 6: Prisoner's Dilemma - Round 2

Anonymities Stays, Atticus Stays
Quagmire Stays, PookyTheMagicalBear Upgrades
Dirge Stays, Mr_Gnome_It_All Stays
olio Upgrades, mlaker Upgrades
ibaesha Stays, MrBuddyLee Stays
Fritzler Stays, Fishbulb Upgrades

MeMeMeet Points:

Fishbulb, MrBuddyLee, PookyTheMagicalBear: 15
Anonymities, Atticus, Dirge, Mr_Gnome_It_All: 10
Quagmire: 0
Fritzler: -5
mlaker, olio: -10
ibaesha: -20

Total:

Fishbulb: 51
Atticus: 48
MrBuddyLee: 43
PookyTheMagicalBear: 36
Fritzler: 34
Mr_Gnome_It_All: 33
Quagmire: 30
Dirge, kristocker: 29
Mastermind of Sin: 18
Anonymities, Thesp: 16
mlaker, Yoko Kurama: 10
MeMe, Yosarian2: 8
Fletcher: 2
olio: -7
ibaesha: -12

[Quagmire]

mith, I PMed you to upgrade...

[Atticus]

Yay anonny!

Pooky has very good reasoning. And seeing as I'm not voting for anybody and because I see no reason not to...

I'm making lame excuses for making this vote.

I'll just make a vote.

Vote: Fishbulb.

[ibaesha]

Wait, mith how did I lose 10 points if MBL stayed?

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

too bad ur PM to mith got zapped by my heatray vision sucka

[Atticus]

No, no, no, no. It was spork who had heatray vision.

[ibaesha]

Pooky made a good case. I'm interested to see where it goes.

vote: Fishbulb

I think Atticus just insists on being scummy. I'm wondering about Dirge and I think Quag voting Fritz for 4 days straight then switching to Pooky without other comment is weird. Especially the timing of it.

[Fishbulb]

Unfortunately, I can't respond to, or even fully read, Pooky's post right now. I am in the middle of a gaming convention here and I won't be back around a computer until Sunday evening. Sorry, everyone.

[mith]

Mod Note:

I have no internet at home this weekend (but hopefully *just* for this weekend), so attack resolution for Game 5 will be delayed. Feel free to keep attacking once your 48 hours have passed, though.

Quag, I only received a PM from you round 1.

ibae, that's a typo, MBL Upgraded.

[MrBuddyLee]

ps. *huggles*

[ibaesha]

No huggles for you!

You have the better couch!

Punk.

[MrBuddyLee]

Attack Pooky with an OSU Buckeyes mascot

[Atticus]

...
I think Atticus just insists on being scummy.
...

Everyone says this about me, well most people do, I kinda want a little more explanation.

[ibaesha]

Making lame excuses for a vote is scummy. It's what bothered me about your behavior on day 1. Now, you're just admitting to it, which I suppose is you making light of your earlier behavior. I just continually find you scummy, but I'm not so sure you're scum.

[Quagmire]

mith, I sent you a PM on October 2nd:

"I'll be going onto the couch, also known as "upgrading"."

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

quit whining quag

sheesh u seem to be more concerned about your mememeet points than actually catching scum.

[Fritzler]

ATTACK FISHBULB WITH A JOHN WILX BOOTH

UNVOTE, VOTE: FISHBULB