Open 530 "WSoB" (Stack the Deck): GAME OVER

[Alduskkel]

VA vote makes no sense anymore.

What made a vote on VA make sense to you?

VA was a lurking lurker who lurked. But apparently it was for IRL reasons, not scummy reasons.

ITT Hiraki gives excuses for not scumhunting.

Thanks for confirming my vote and dodging the questions.

I'll look at the rest of the group later. When I'm not busy (because apparently that seriously needed to be said too)

You want me to respond to the post point by point? I didn't want to clutter the thread, but okay:

At least give some hard scum reads.

Meanwhile, I already said this game was hard to read. Do you think I'm just going to come out and say "AH-HA SCUM FOUND!111!1!"

Also, I didn't call you scummy for not explaining yourself. You're scummy because you don't post jack.

Lurking=Scummy. GJ

But 4 of your 5 most recent posts are promising to do stuff later, and I don't see that stuff yet.

Yet. It's been a few days now and I have time.

That being said, I'm really liking Aduskelscum.

1. You have yet to call anyone scum (recently) other than me, and that just seems reactionary.
2. Active lurking is definitely scummy. You're posting enough to maintain a decent presence in the game, yet failing to produce any real content.
3. Still waiting then... I'll be impressed if you come up with anything other than "Alduskkel is scum."

[yabbaguy]

Vote Count 1.9

12 alive, 7 to lynch

Sakura Hana (2): pieguyn, EspeciallyTheLies
DoctorEagle (1): Sakura Hana
Alduskkel (1): Brian Skies
JacobSavage (1): Ankamius
Hiraki (1): Alduskkel

Not Voting: JacobSavage, Bert, InflatablePie, thenewearth, Hiraki, DoctorEagle

Prodding: thenewearth
V/LA: Sakura Hana (9/29)

Deadline: September 28, 3 PM EDT (GMT-4) ((expired on 2013-09-28 15:00:00)). No Lynch occurs if this elapses!

[InflatablePie]

only skimmed up to page 8 so far, but I'm getting scumvibes from pieguy

mostly because of this:

And suddenly a venrob wagon starts. This is quite interesting.

HoS: Sakura

just pointing out what's going on and calling it "interesting" instead of analyzing it or posting their opinion on it

while avoiding the venrob wagon discussion, and then this:

calls a wagon stupid which, in the end, regardless of how it started, ended up giving town information. you know, your opposing faction

talking to Sakura, and then he immediately votes the same person Sakura is voting. wha


Venrob is probtown actually, and Brian is also a townread

[Bert]

Yesterday, I skimmed and got scum vibes from Pieguyn, but then I looked and saw he/she had no votes

I'm working on this game too

[/b]Vote: pieguyn[/b]

[Bert]

VOTE: Pieguyn

[InflatablePie]

ETL reminded me further down the page to comment on something earlier:

A self-vote means that you're voting for the only person you know is confirmed town (if you're town) hence holds no info,

the "if you're town" part I really don't like. really don't. on the other hand, I'm not sure how to feel about her flailing-esque actions (calling herself out for "screwing up" etc) once she starts gathering votes.

also getting mad scumvibes off ETL but I probably shouldn't be because her posts have logic and reason, wat

eagle can be town I guess, thenewearth gives me scumvibes as well.

and jacob can be town for his pieguy scumread reasoning, I like it.

up to page 10ish, gonna go do laundry and either finish skimming or play some kingdom hearts 1.5, not sure yet.

[Bert]

Inflatable we are on the same page

I was thinking Id just sheep the biggest wagon if I can't catch up, and then I skimmed ETL's iso and something didnt feel right.

I'm mostly reliant on gut so don't take too much stock in what I say

I'm also still not fully caught up with the events yet either

[Brian Skies]

Whoa, I'm liking the different perspective thus far. I'm going to do a re-read and get back to you guys later today. (I'm in a bunch of games, it's a balancing act)

[pieguyn]

only skimmed up to page 8 so far, but I'm getting scumvibes from pieguy

mostly because of this:

And suddenly a venrob wagon starts. This is quite interesting.

HoS: Sakura

just pointing out what's going on and calling it "interesting" instead of analyzing it or posting their opinion on it

while avoiding the venrob wagon discussion

in fact, I hadn't even read the part of the thread with the Venrob wagon when I voted her :> so I couldn't really offer an opinion on it. the fact she was just sitting there watching without doing anything was suspicious enough for me

and then this:

calls a wagon stupid which, in the end, regardless of how it started, ended up giving town information. you know, your opposing faction

talking to Sakura, and then he immediately votes the same person Sakura is voting. wha

cause I had a read on him and I wanted to pressure him more. can you explain what the fact that Sakura was also voting him implies?

[pieguyn]

ooops, almost forgot

he just asked you to explain your reads more.

I would believe this if he cited my early posts and finding contradictions from earlier reads.

first off, can you explain why it's necessary for a contradiction to exist in order to question someone's reads?

second, can you quote exactly what makes you believe there's an ulterior motive behind his actions plz.

[Brian Skies]

@Bert: I would like your thoughts on Pieguy, TNE, and DE, specifically. Reads on other people are nice too.

[DoctorEagle]

So close to the deadline already?

VOTE: SakuraHana

Why BE moved his vote to Venrob is beyond me.

I'll catch up after my history exam tomorrow.

[Alduskkel]

I think Sakura is probably town, because things seem to be drifting towards her being the easy/compromise lynch that flips town but no one gets blamed for because hey, it was that or no lynch, right?

[yabbaguy]

Prodding JacobSavage.

Day 1 of our Baccarat Bash ends soon, not planning on extending deadline. Go go go!

[InflatablePie]

quickly skimmed the rest of the pages before work

I'm okay with TNE or pieguy wagons, indifferent about Sakura.

vote pieguy

gonna be stretched for time this weekend but I should be able to make at least one or two more posts before deadline

[Bert]

I'm not going to be able to get through this game before the deadline - lots of stuff going on, and going back and skimming while having to get to know everyone's names is too much for me until tests today end, etc., etc.. I'm sorry. But I stand by my strong gut feeling that pieguy is scum.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

I need to know why "pieguy is scum". There are now at least 4 people I can think of off the top of my head who are scum reading him and yet I can't find a single case or even a reason.... Now, all of them cant be scum so can someone please put some effort into it? I have iso'd pieguy and I dont know what I'm missing..

[Sakura Hana]

I need to know why "pieguy is scum".

I would like to know this as well. I'm townreading pieguy.

[Ankamius]

I'm more confused why everyone is ignoring JacobSavage. iPie's reasoning checks out, but I don't feel it's a very strong case at all.

I still much prefer a JS lynch.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Jacob is one of them. And I am rather irritated I've asked him at least twice now for an explanation of his reads and he has not given them.

[Sakura Hana]

Yeah I guess my vote is being kinda useless atm anyway.

I can buy jacob scum case

Unvote
Vote: JacobSavage

[JacobSavage]

I already explain them silly ETL.

[Brian Skies]

Well, I'm not buying that JS is scum, so I'm not going to vote him. I'm also not going to vote Ank, IP, or Bert today.

I think IP is town (pretty good entrance). And I'm liking his TNE and Pieguy call-outs. I actually think TNE is scummy though (the iso feels like scum), and would prefer that wagon. Thoughts?

VOTE: TNE

[DoctorEagle]

Uh, DP completely ignored my FoS on JS earlier, so I need to talk to him and ask about his read on JS. For me, he's scum.

[pieguyn]

I'm fine with lynching Sakura, JS, or Hiraki. though at this point I'm willing to lynch anyone if the only alternative is NL

@IP: answer my question plz