Okay, here goes a catchup.
In post 19, YuniChikako wrote:I almost voted Slandaar for being so dang impatient, and because I have nothing to do at the moment, but I'll shut up for now.
This post is insanely easy to vote for. In reality, it really shows nothing but a flair of playstyle (this could be new town or bad scum play, it says nothing about the alignment). Though Slandaar's start off vote was town in tone, that also doesn't show anything about his alignment.
In post 23, Garmr wrote:oh we have started i'll start with a serious vote. RVS denied
In post 19, YuniChikako wrote:I almost voted Slandaar for being so dang impatient, and because I have nothing to do at the moment, but I'll shut up for now.
VOTE: Yunichikwowwow
I don't like this response from Yuni. I don't understand the reason why she didn't place the vote down. If it was because of the pregame thing why did she respond to it and why did she show intent to vote.
ehh...
In post 24, Maxous wrote:Garmr's town.
I think Slandaar is too.
vote: ArcAngel9
What took you so long to get in here?
I understand Slandaar, but why Garmr?
In post 38, Maxous wrote:I think desperado is town.
Aptil, maybe not (his post was a bit weak)
I'm serious about being suspect of Arc Angel for taking so long to confirm and start the game btw
Actually, you know what, never mind, you're probably scum because you don't attempt to explain many of these reads
On page 2, a bunch of votes on Yuni happens. Slandaar (who, for some gut reason I find is less likely to be scum), Desperado, Bulb, Dry-fit. I believe scum is within {Desperado, Bulbazak, Dry-fit}.
Not reading anything that mastin has to say until he gets to the point. He's also near impossible to read anyway.
In post 53, Garmr wrote:
Lol Just got the reason why you refereed to him as ice I'm slow. Don't think that's valid but lol.
@electricsavage you made a spelling mistake it's Yunichikawowwow not YuniChikako.
...yuck
In post 54, JKLM wrote:VOTE: Bulba
Based on vote placement.
WHY MATIAS WHY WHY WHY
I love you again because you are town (specifically, you see what I see)
In post 59, JKLM wrote:4th vote on a ten vote required wagon is scummiest spot as it signifies the start of a wagon.
Not really, but in this case I absolutely believe that Yuni's post was extremely votable by EVERYONE and scum could see a golden opportunity (and probably did). So, Bulbazak out of the three above seems most likely (not to mention I find it always super hard to vote Desperado by playstyle alone, and Dry-fit is relatively quiet)
In post 68, YuniChikako wrote:Actually,
UNVOTE: Slandaar
VOTE: Bulbazak
I have a bad feeling about him. Seems to be a good when talking, a good player, but just the thought of him being inno forms a pit in my stomach. Plus, why in the world is he voting Arc, of all people?
In post 31, Desperado wrote:Yuni was kind enough to eliminate the RVS stage this game by scumclaiming their first post. You should oblige and vote them.
Thank you.
Garmr wrote:@Yunichikawowwow
Quick summary of your reads go.
Get dangit.
Maxous: Well, at the beginning he was just getting into the RVS spirit, gotta choose somebody, but then continued on about how he was serious about Arc. I really see him being scum, though. I have a feeling he's town.
Slandaar: Makes sense he would vote me, and though I can see him just, as you put, Garmr, getting the ball rolling, I still have a bad feeling about him. I'll leave it at that.
Matias: Hasn't done much except vote, not sure what to say about him.
Desparado: Kinda shaky. Feeling he's town, but at the same time... I don't know, I'll have to see.
Aptin: Once again, can't say.
Toomai: I'll might be able to say something once he stops/finishes his dbz marathon and talks more.
Bulbazak: Stated my reasons already.
Mastin: IIIIIII... so far I am not fond of him. Though, is that a soft/hard claim, depending on perspective, that I see? If not, you must be way overconfident or just really good at town-telling.
JKLM: Thinking town, at the moment.
Garmr: Could see him being town, something of a leader, but I could just as easily see him as being misleading scum. Eeeeh, he's probably town, but if he starts being scummy, I'm gonna notice.
Everyone else: Stop eating tacos and play.
Now, I need to go before my friend slaps me for taking so long writing this.
Holy shit, we have a major playstyle issue here. Anyone voting Yuni for her first post is super opportunistic (alignment being a different story)
In post 74, Garmr wrote:Also I don't like the bulb wagon that much or some of the people on it. Looking at JKLM/Yunichikawowwow
Of course.
no....
well at least Toomai is town by responding that way to your post, and you're town (probably?) after your follow up.
In post 79, JKLM wrote:VOTE: yuni
Sorry but you're def scum now with that post containing your crappy reads list and she melds self counterwagoning which is partially my fault for building. Let's lych you tidy shall we?
You still seem town but this is a bad vote
Seriously, a bunch of you guys voting Yuni for playstyle issues, and it's so easy to tell who is town and who is scum doing it. Like, Peregrine's probably town. That early wagon was so bad.
In post 116, Dry-fit wrote:Yuni's response to her wagon looked townish.
Unvote.
About mastin's townslip: I see it, but it's not the kind of thing I put a ton of stock in. Calling a townslip on yourself is always questionable as well.
Maxous seems town to me based on the last game I played with him but not a super strong read.
No one looks particularly scummy at the moment but I can see Toomai as scum.
Vote: Toomai.
You didn't explain the hop off of Yuni that well.
In post 117, mastin2 wrote:Dry-fit just took a triple-hit to his chances of being town.
...AT LEAST a triple-hit, actually.
When not pressed for time, I'll explain.
Okay, mastin is town. Read list is formulating very nicely.
In post 123, Garmr wrote:@Maxous
In post 94, Maxous wrote:unvote, vote: Toomai
Clearly I was sleepy this morning.
Garmr's right, wtf was that comment.
The reason I said look at it in none alignment way was I was trying to get you to think. I didn't want to shove Ideas into your head so what I wanted you to see and figure out for yourself was the effect he wanted from his post. Which was distance.
Since we have two scum team distance is going to play a big part in scum hunting since scum will be legit hunting. The next step I was going to ask you to do was think this was this town trying to distance themselves from potential buddying or scum trying to stop a scum slip.
Holy jesus.
In post 128, Garmr wrote:-facepalms- I didn't get that joke. You explained you pretty much stood against all my questioning then and that slip wasn't a slip. Through I didn't like the way you talked about me
In post 68, YuniChikako wrote:Garmr: Could see him being town, something of a leader, but I could just as easily see him as being misleading scum. Eeeeh, he's probably town, but if he starts being scummy, I'm gonna notice.
But at the time being that isn't enough evidence to label you as scum and the other things you stood up well against.
UNVOTE: Yunichikwowwow
and even through I am suspicious of toonami I will vote Yiley
VOTE: Yiley
He seems like his dodging Bulbs question by not explaining fully or not answering post 81(Didn't anwser fully) post 93 doesn't even mention it. There's other reasons as well but I want to see who's thinking
my god
Okay this is what I have so far
Town as shit:
mastin
Peregrine
JKLM
Scummy as fuck:
Garmr
Maxous
Bulbazak
Probably town but I can't really tell definitively right now:
Yuni
Desperado
Slandaar
aptil
Yiley
Toomai
Probably scum but I'm less sure:
Dry-fit
Like, I just don't really know about you guys, man:
TSO
Lawrencelot
EPM
OhGodMyLife
ArcAngel
This is what I've got so far.
Vote: Garmr
I dare any of you to give me 3 good reasons why this guy is town. Secondary sights on Maxous.
