Worst Survivor Twist/Challenge Ideas

CuddlyCaucasian · Post Post #0 (isolation #0) » Sun Feb 16, 2014 6:57 pm

The game is simple. Each poster comes up with an idea for an MS Survivor twist or challenge that is downright cruel, broken, or most of all just hilarious, and then

they will be implemented in a future game of mine

we can all laugh and such together.

I'll start: 24 players, 4 tribes of 6. The first TC, every tribe votes someone off, and those 4 go to Redemption Island. The loser of the Redemption Island duel goes to a second Redemption Island, where they must wait for the next person to lose a duel at Redemption Island 1 and come to face them at Redemption Island 2. At merge, whoever is on RI 1 goes back to the game, and whoever was on RI 2 goes back to RI 1. Everyone knows about the first redemption island BUT no one knows about the second Redemption Island until they get there, and once F2 has been reached, whoever is at RI 2 is entered into FTC!

CuddlyCaucasian · Post Post #7 (isolation #1) » Mon Feb 17, 2014 7:16 am

I think someone suggested that as an actual good idea on Sucks at some point. *shudders*

CuddlyCaucasian · Post Post #24 (isolation #2) » Mon Feb 17, 2014 3:54 pm

In post 22, Tony PF wrote:
In post 17, Snakes wrote:Instead of a game with 23 normal players and one player controlled by a mod and spectator that has access to confessionals, there are 23 mod-controlled players and one poor sap who thinks it's a real game.
Do it! Sign up for the queue! Like, right now!

But now everyone knows! Delete the post before Ani sees it!

CuddlyCaucasian · Post Post #33 (isolation #3) » Sun Mar 16, 2014 4:25 pm

Hmmm, I think to make a game with constant tribal swaps, the best way would be to have a One World-like setup with everyone in one camp, but after each TC, new tribes are randomly decided. It'd be the hardest to make plans and prepare for, but that's definitely the most effective way to reward a strong social game.

CuddlyCaucasian · Post Post #35 (isolation #4) » Tue Mar 18, 2014 4:18 pm

10/10 would play

CuddlyCaucasian · Post Post #38 (isolation #5) » Mon Mar 24, 2014 1:31 pm

Arkham Asylum did have a couple Mafia Tribal Councils where private communication was cut off and all votes were public and could change anytime, but it'd be cool to see a game alternate each round.

CuddlyCaucasian · Post Post #40 (isolation #6) » Sat Apr 05, 2014 7:52 pm

Survivor: 1 vs. 100! Two tribes, one of 1 player and one of 100 players. If the tribe of 1 player loses a challenge, he is eliminated and the other tribe votes for a player to take his spot in the 1-player tribe. If the 100-player tribe loses a challenge, they vote a player from their tribe out of the game. Merge at 12.

CuddlyCaucasian · Post Post #41 (isolation #7) » Sat Apr 12, 2014 7:49 am

Okay this is a serious idea I'm considering.

Letter Survivor: 26-player anon game where every player is playing as a randomly assigned letter of the alphabet. A player cannot use whatever letter he is in any posts or PMs, and doing so 5 times results in immediate elimination. For example, Q cannot use any words containing the letter Q. In addition, at any point in the game, no players may use any of the 5 most previously voted out letters in any posts or PMs, and doing so goes towards a separate 5-strike count.

CuddlyCaucasian · Post Post #44 (isolation #8) » Sat Apr 12, 2014 2:34 pm

0r 1 c0u1d ju5t m4k3 th4t i113g4l

CuddlyCaucasian · Post Post #49 (isolation #9) » Thu May 08, 2014 1:17 pm

[8:11:28 PM] Will Seamon: I'm gonna run an anon game where each player is secretly controlling two players, but they're only aware of the one player they're logged in as
[8:11:35 PM] Will Seamon: So there are 10 players on each tribe
[8:11:43 PM] Will Seamon: But only 5 real people on each tribe
[8:11:59 PM] xof: xD
[8:12:15 PM] Will Seamon: But if real xof sends a PM to fake JDGA on her tribe, then fake xof sends that exact same PM to real JDGA on the other tribe
[8:13:53 PM] xof: oooo
[8:13:56 PM] xof: that's really neat
[8:14:15 PM] Will Seamon: i feel like it'd actually be really cool omg
[8:14:25 PM] xof: it really would be
[8:14:32 PM] xof: make it a smaller game though
[8:14:40 PM] xof: er you already said that
[8:14:41 PM] xof: nevermind >.>
[8:14:44 PM] xof: <.<
[8:15:01 PM] Will Seamon: well everyone THINKS it's 20 players!
[8:15:04 PM] xof: true
[8:15:20 PM] Will Seamon:

[8:15:28 PM] Will Seamon: I'm too lazy for all that work though
[8:15:35 PM] xof: do both real and fake die at the same time?
[8:15:46 PM] Will Seamon: nope!
[8:15:49 PM] xof: ooo
[8:16:15 PM] Will Seamon: I haven't thought this through very well, but at merge at 10 something happens??? idek
[8:16:17 PM] xof: you should put this in the worst survivor ideas thread

CuddlyCaucasian · Post Post #55 (isolation #10) » Fri Mar 18, 2016 4:09 pm

In post 16, Klick wrote:
In post 14, Blackberry wrote:TIME TRAVEL MOLE (or SURVIVOR). Game takes place out of order. For example, the first challenge could be the Final Immunity Challenge. Players won't know how they did (or maybe they do all get told how everyone did) until it's actually time. Or maybe they go to a TC that takes place in the future (and provide a ranked list incase their target is no longer in the game), or have the option to change votes that occurred in the past (and thus resulting in a revived player!). My original idea of a Time Travel Mole was Dr. Who themed and not too complicated. For example, they take the first quiz, the executed player is not revealed, then they have a challenge where players can win exemption for the first Round. Then the Execution is revealed . And they take quizzes and challenge in the future (they actually had a Mole in Dutch where they were given a Quiz and the challenge for the Quiz took place AFTER the Quiz, so the players attempted to manipulate others' actions to coordinate with their test answers).

Calling dibs on this.

Good times