Scummies 2014 - Nomination Thread!

[saulres]

Huh, I don't know that we've ever had a Marathon game nominated.

For Best Setup? Both my Meme Mafias were last year.

Don't ask me why I read "Marathon" as "Micro". I have no idea. No idea at all.

[ZZZX]

Nominate Micro 368 for most memorial moment

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 7#p6051037


I cant really describe it but now that I remember it I just cant forget it :>

Basically can someone help me phrase it. (or is it not nomination worthy?)

[Antihero]

or is it not nomination worthy?

there are some questions that answer themselves, zzzx.

this is one of them.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

Nominate this for Most Memorable Moment

It was HILARIOUS when it happened, and it comes to mind all the time as one of the funniest things I've read in a game. In this particular game, PV is scum who has semi-counterclaimed beastcharizard, who then townread him for it. Antihero (town) subsequently loses his mind.

[Marquis]

2nd

totally forgot about that, I laughed so hard /nosarcasm

[Prof Fridays]

That's hilarious.

3rd

[beastcharizard]

Is it weird I completely forgot that happened because the only thing I think about when I see that game is me getting a guilty and town riding it to victory?

It is funny to read though.

[Porochaz]

I will

second Bookie

for most enjoyable player. As scum with her in Oldy Mafia 2, she really kept me going and the morale high in the scumteam at times and I think I would have lost hope without her optimism.

[reinoe]

I would like to nominate bjc for Best Mafia Catcher.

Here's just one example of him leading town in catching scum...By shooting them. At the time the scum in question had made only three posts, and one of those was RVS. It's not the first time bjc has gunned down scum as a vig either. But bjc doesn't need a gun to catch scum. I think his ability to find scum is a bit frightening and I would appreciate it if his skills were recognized.

[reinoe]

I would also like to nominate zMuffinman for best replacement. He prolificly replaces into games. It's uncanny.

[Voidedmafia]

I would also like to nominate zMuffinman for best replacer. He prolificly replaces into games. It's uncanny.

Just replacing into a lot of games doesn't get you that award. You have to show proficiency and ability while replacing in to enhance the game.

Also it's best

replacement

.

[Cabd]

I would also like to nominate zMuffinman for best replacer. He prolificly replaces into games. It's uncanny.

Just replacing into a lot of games doesn't get you that award. You have to show proficiency and ability while replacing in to enhance the game.

Also it's best

replacement

.

Speaking as the current holder of this title, that sounds incorrect. I won primarily due to my WILLINGNESS to replace into tight spots. Not my ability or lack thereof to turn around games.

[F-16_Fighting_Falcon]

I would like to nominate bjc for Best Mafia Catcher.

Here's just one example of him leading town in catching scum...By shooting them. At the time the scum in question had made only three posts, and one of those was RVS. It's not the first time bjc has gunned down scum as a vig either. But bjc doesn't need a gun to catch scum. I think his ability to find scum is a bit frightening and I would appreciate it if his skills were recognized.

The dayvig was a shot in the dark. Also, best Mafia catcher is a body of work award so you should probably give more examples.

[reinoe]

I would like to nominate bjc for Best Mafia Catcher.

Here's just one example of him leading town in catching scum...By shooting them. At the time the scum in question had made only three posts, and one of those was RVS. It's not the first time bjc has gunned down scum as a vig either. But bjc doesn't need a gun to catch scum. I think his ability to find scum is a bit frightening and I would appreciate it if his skills were recognized.

The dayvig was a shot in the dark. Also, best Mafia catcher is a body of work award so you should probably give more examples.

Ok, but you sound like a hater because that was not a shot in the dark...

bjc lynches scum and then guns down the other two in this game...

[SleepyKrew]

The shot in Aronis's game was pure luck. xfda is that scummy regardless of alignment. Can't speak for the other example, and won't speak anymore at all because I'll get yelled at.

[Voidedmafia]

Speaking as the current holder of this title, that sounds incorrect. I won primarily due to my WILLINGNESS to replace into tight spots. Not my ability or lack thereof to turn around games.

That too, yes, but I meant that it's not the only thing.

[Bulbazak]

I've played with Bjc a few times. Unless he's stepped up his game, I haven't been impressed.

[T S O]

My experience of him, as far as I remember, was getting caught as scum d1 with me as his partner. He was useful in twilight though.

[Bins]

This is not for being scum, this is for being town.

[T S O]

This is a general assessment of my knowledge of his play.

[T S O]

But I have no vendetta against bjc, and I don't think he's in any way a bad player, so I'll refrain from commenting further.

[BROseidon]

So apparently nobody ever seconded Attack on Titan for game of the year, so I'm going to do that.

Second Attack on Titan for game of the year or whatever that award is called

[AngryPidgeon]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=58544

Nominate Zoraster's Fortnight 2 for Best Mutation.

[Titus]

New Category Suggestions

Best Town Performance in a Loss
Best Scum Performance in a Loss

Nom: SKOT, Best Performance in Town Loss- Game Ikarga Mafia (Large Theme)

Second AJ as Cunning Manipulator

[Titus]

I would also like to nominate zMuffinman for best replacer. He prolificly replaces into games. It's uncanny.

Just replacing into a lot of games doesn't get you that award. You have to show proficiency and ability while replacing in to enhance the game.

Also it's best

replacement

.

This. I think I am the most prolific replacer on site but it's quality over quantity.