I was trying to hold off on this until more people posted content because spotlighting behaviours tends to have an effect on them one way or the other. At this point, though, I'm feeling better and I want to discuss these things before deadline looms, so here it is.
I read the
Mafiascum Fantasy Camp 2 game Reck hooked me up with. It had four players from this game in it in three slots; SleepyKrew replaced Nobody Special in it. Here's what I learned from MFC2:
I've played with UT in a game where I was scum and he was town. He was scum in MFC2 and was WAY more proactive and aggressive than I saw in Oldy 2. I was already reading UT as town based on his postings here compared with Oldy, but I'm even more confident now based on the contrast between his laid-back style there and his activity and attitude in MFC2.
Reck is always cowboy shooting-from-the-hip regardless of his alignment imo. I read him as strong town here (he was town in MFC2, as well) because he's reading people much the same way I am and I can see why he would want to policy lynch Nobody Special based on MFC2. I do not like policy lynches but I do not think they are alignment indicative. I like Reck for town.
Nobody Special offered nothing of use in MFC2; however, one notable difference is that he put votes on people that sorta kinda made sense at the time. His reads were generally wrong, but he was actually indicating what they were. He questioned people for acting like they didn't remember him, too.
I also got the sense that NS was trying to keep up with the MFC2 game. This does contrast somewhat with his play here. NS is either trying to 1) taunt farside into voting him or 2) legitimately doesn't know why she's sniping at me, which argues he's not bothering to keep up with this thread. His sheep onto the SK wagon looks either opportunistic or an attempt to blend in with farside (others too, but she is the one I'm interested in here) which is definitely dissonant with the first explanation of taunting. The same-alignment nonsense is baffling as well.
Now to SleepyKrew. I'm pretty sure this slot is town given interactions with other people I'm reading as town and the general IDGAF attitude he's displaying. This corresponds almost perfectly to his play upon replace in to MFC2. Contrast this with his play in
Cave Story Mafia where he was focused, intense, and flipped scum night one. This doesn't look like SK's scum game to me.
Questions, comments, contradictions welcome.
"Oh, you can't help that," said the Cat: "we're all mad here. I'm mad. You're mad."
"How do you know I'm mad?" said Alice.
"You must be," said the Cat, "or you wouldn't have come here."
