NY 178: MASQUERADE -- GAME OVER

[Pine]

Wtf

No kill?

[Pine]

Well, Boon is Town

Only way no kill happens is if both shot him

Between Slandaar flipping Wolf and Boon being Town, I need to re-evaluate

Thor still can't be Mafia. Boon can't be Mafia. That leaves {TSO, Nero Cain}

Boon can't be Wolf, still don't think TSO can be due to behavior early D5 {Thor, Nero Cain}

Don't want to jump to a conclusion, because a mislynch here is a problem

On the other hand, a scumlynch guarantees us a fighting chance

[Nero Cain]

hrmmmm.....gut still says Boon/Pine.

[Thor665]

No kill, huh?










TROLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL!

Hey, guys - guys....guess what.
Thor may have lied about something in his claim.

[Nero Cain]

[Pine]

The Town part? Yeah, that part

Nero, I don't see a way Boon can possibly be scum, unless one side elected not to shoot

[Pine]

Unless Thor is claiming BP Townie, that throws Boon back into the possible Wolf mix

[Thor665]

Claim: Jailkept Pine last night

I do think it's fairly obvious Pine is scum, natch. I suppose on a theoretical concept that maybe scum shot Pine thinking he was scum, and then other scum shot Boon thinking the same - but I prefer to believe that scum shot Pine and Pine shot someone. I also think his reaction shows that he shot at Boon, natch.

@Pine - would you care to help town out by telling us who you think Mafia is? Because I think you're pretty clearly busted Wolf at this stage and, really, you *are* going to be lynched today and I would like to suggest that town has been playing better than Mafia. Wanna help us out with any theories from your Wolf buds now passed or yourself? Heck, if you're Mafia and not Wolf, that alone would be worth heaaring just to help us scumhunt today.

Also, in unrelated news - I am confirmed town - shock.
I also stand by the theory that neither Boon nor TSO look like likely Wolves. I mean, *maybe*...but, man, that was some nasty Wolf bussing action if they were. I bet looking over Slandaar would only help solidify that in my head, honestly.

Nero is still a sad sack for me.
Game balance wise I'm conflicted on Boon - hell, playstyle wise I'm conflicted there.
I think I'm still of a mind to say Boon as Mafia.

I'd like to hear some people talk about Nero v. Boon as last scum. I think it's Pine plus one of them.
Thoughts?

[Thor665]

Unless Thor is claiming BP Townie, that throws Boon back into the possible Wolf mix

If I was claiming that I would have been voting Boon solid for days on end by now - and also calling you all lackwits...and also would have counterclaimed on Day 1.

[Thor665]

Don't be sad.

Why are you not Mafia?

[Pine]

I am NOT "busted wolf"

Jailkeeper is a protective role too, jackass. Clearly, Mafia shot at me, Wolf shot Boon, no kill

I think Thor is our Wolf, who jailkept his Mafia suspect, but ended up protecting me from the actual Mafia. Jailkeeper doesn't fit on Mafia side

[Nero Cain]

its not Nero. I am 100% positive on this.

p-edit I'm not sad. I'm not mafia 'cause just lead a mafia lynch on Flubber.

[Thor665]

@Pine - Okay - so I'm Wolf...who bussed my buddy...and then jailkept you instead of shooting at you because I thought you were the Mafia...and then shot no one or opted to jailkeep instead of shoot?
Riiiiiight.

Dude, seriously, you're just going to be ignored if you keep up the pretense.


@Nero - please go and quote you "leading" the lynch and show me who you got on the lynch. I agree that you voted him - but that is different from "leading".

[Pine]

Hmm

Jailing me and shooting Boon

doesn't

make sense, but you're off your rocker with the assertion that I'm "definitely" Wolf. There were two people protected last night, it's far more likely that both scum sides shot at me and Boon

That makes it TSO and NC, Mafia and Wolf respectively l think

[Nero Cain]

I wouldn't call your sitting on Pine all day and sitting there and going "oh I much rather lynch flubber" leading either. I started the flubber wagon

[T S O]

I'm trying to think if there's any way for Pine to be town here - I really do not think so.

[Pine]

No, NC, he's Town. He can't be Mafia, Jailkeeper+Roleblock+Rolecop is OP. He can't be Wolf, he wouldn't have jailkept me and shot elsewhere

You, on the other hand, are suddenly looking very Wolf

[Pine]

I'm trying to think if there's any way for Pine to be town here - I really do not think so.

Believe it

So how pissed were you when Flubber got flashwagoned?

[Nero Cain]

I like this 180 you've pulled on me. Tell me more!

[T S O]

I'm trying to think if there's any way for Pine to be town here - I really do not think so.

Believe it

So how pissed were you when Flubber got flashwagoned?

really, really pissed

so utterly pissed I voted him instead of you

I almost came from the sadism I was inflicting upon myself

[T S O]

but like that was a horrendous response, Pine, you are scum.

[Pine]

I like this 180 you've pulled on me. Tell me more!

You played an awesome game. Suspecting you is 100% PoE. I can't see anyone else being Wolf except you and Boon

PE I'm really not

[Pine]

I mean, seriously. I probably absorbed at least one, maybe both of the shots from N5

[Nero Cain]

like obviously Scripten didn't get lynched but I was p much calling him scum since the start and then I lead a lynch on Slandaar. I know Pine is mafia but he should get some credit for trying.

[T S O]

are we calling Pine mafia? I think he's more likely ww