Micro 438: Greatest Idea Mafia - Game Over

[Micc]

VoteCount 2.06

Espeonage (3)

: MrTrow, Alchemist21, guille2015

MrTrow (1)

: Espeonage

Not Voting (3)

: eyestott

With 5 players alive, it takes 3 votes to Lynch or No Lynch.

A lynch has been achieved.

[Micc]

Espeonage was lynched Day 2.

He was a

Town One-Shot Paranoid Gun Owner

.

It is now Night 2.

The deadline for Night 2 is in (expired on 2015-01-26 17:30:00).

Unless otherwise specified, please send any actions to me via PM.

[Micc]

eyestott was killed Night 2.

He was a

Town Cop

.

MrTrow has been treestumped Night 2.

He is a

Mafia One-Shot Governor

, turned

Mafia Treestump

.

The Town has achieved its win condition!

guille2015

, a

Town Bloodsucker

, survives and wins.

Alchemist21

, a

Town One-Shot Dayvig

, survives and wins.

Espeonage

,

Diego1487

,

eyestott

, and

GuyInFreezer

all win posthumously.

[Micc]

Mod Thread
Dead Thread

Spoiler: Setup and Night Actions

Players:

Espeonage -

Town One-Shot Paranoid Gun Owner

guille2015 -

Town Bloodsucker

This Christmas -

Werewolf One-Shot Governor

Alchemist21 -

Town One-Shot Dayvig

Diego1487 -

Town Cop

MrTrow -

Mafia One-Shot Governor

eyestott -

Town Cop

theslimer3 -

Lyncher (eyestott) Retired Marine

GuyInFreezer -

Town Mason Doctor

Day 1:

Diego1487 is lynched.

Night 1:

GuyInFreezer protects ... Espeonage - Espeonage is protected, GuyInFreezer is shot by PGO
MrTrow kills ... GuyInFreezer - GuyInFreezer is killed
This Christmas kills ... Espeonage - Fails due to doctor, This Christmas is shot by PGO
Eyestott investigates ... guille2015 - receives 'Not Maia'
guille2015 bloodsucks ... no one

Day 2:

Alchemist21 shoots theslimer3 - theslimer3 is killed
Espeonage is lynched

Night 2

:
MrTrow kills eyestott - eyestott is killed
Eyestott investigates MrTrow - receives nothing due to death
guille2015 bloodsucks MrTrow - MrTrow becomes a Mafia Treestump

Spoiler: Card Choices

I feel like this is guaranteed to have too much scum

Player Name	Alignment Card	Role/Ability Card	Resulting Role
Espeonage	Vanilla Townie	One-Shot Paranoid Gun Owner	Town One-Shot Paranoid Gun Owner
guille2015	Supersaint	Alien Bloodsucker	Town Bloodsucker
This Christmas	Werewolf	Mafia One-Shot Governor	Werewolf One-Shot Governor
Alchemist21	Lover	One-Shot Dayvig	Town One-Shot Dayvig
Diego1487	Mason	Cop	Town Cop
MrTrow	Mafia Cupid	One-Shot Governor	Mafia One-Shot Governor
eyestott	Town Retired Werewolf Hunter	Cop	Town Cop
theslimer3	Lyncher	Retired Marine	Lyncher Retired Marine
GuyInFreezer	Nymphomaniac	Mason Doctor	Town Mason Doctor

Player Name	Discard
Espeonage	Hirsute Goon
guille2015	Vanilla Cop
This Christmas	Vanilla Townie
Alchemist21	Alien Vanillaiser
Diego1487	Evangelistic Townie
MrTrow	Lynchbait
eyestott	Vanilla Townie
theslimer3	Vanilla Townie
GuyInFreezer	Alien Silencer

Spoiler: Card Choices for Invalid Setup

Player Name	Alignment Card	Ability Card	Resulting Role
Espeonage	Serial Killer (werewolf kill immune)	One-Shot Dayvig	Serial Killer One-Shot Dayvig
guille2015	Mason Lover	Cop Lover	Town Cop Lover
This Christmas	Alien Psychotrooper	Retired Marine	Alien Retired Marine
Alchemist21	Werewolf	Werewolf One-Shot Bulletproof	Werewolf One-Shot Bulletproff
Diego1487	Alien Prober	Alien One-Shot Unlynchable	Alien One-Shot Unlynchable
MrTrow	Tracker	Doctor	Town Doctor
eyestott	Werewolf Godfather	Enabler	Werewolf Enabler
theslimer3	One-Shot Commuter	Cop-of-all-Trades	Town Cop-of-all-Trades
GuyInFreezer	Watcher	Werewolf	Vanilla Townie

Player Name	Discard
Espeonage	Black Goo
guille2015	Vanilla Townie
This Christmas	Vanilla Townie
Alchemist21	Cult One-Shot Goomaker
Diego1487	Compulsive Childkiller
MrTrow	Vanilla Townie
eyestott	Conspiracy Theorist
theslimer3	Nurse
GuyInFreezer	Mafia Goon

The thread is now open for post game discussion.

[eyestott]

I KNEW IT

[MrTrow]

trust me.
You don't.

I'm willing to by you knew the 2 'confirmed by role' were indeed town.
But what is to be revealed in the setup information, yeah nope.

before i reveal too much:

slimer: why did you fight my eyestott-case? (really nice setup for your fakeclaim btw)

diego: seriously, (especially given the few moments you had to work with, but even without that disclaimer) well played, i hope to see you again (i do recommend a newbie-game before that time, but still: don't give up on this game)

[theslimer3]

I DONT KNOW. I SUCK AT SCUM T.T

[Micc]

Edited in setup information.

I hope everybody enjoyed the game! Special thanks to everybody for playing the whole game with no replacements.

Fun Fact: The three non-town players in this game made a grand total of two posts in Day 1.

[eyestott]

HA.

[guille2015]

its a good thing I didn't noticed that Trow claimed the same thing Christmas flipped.

Weird game. 2 cops and 2 governors.

[Espeonage]

Thoroughly enjoyed the game.

My plan that didn't work actually worked and killed a scum.

[Espeonage]

its a good thing I didn't noticed that Trow claimed the same thing Christmas flipped.

Weird game. 2 cops and 2 governors.

Actually had no bearing on aligment because the alignment could have been picked up from elsewhere.

[guille2015]

Night 1 was not what I expected.

[guille2015]

its a good thing I didn't noticed that Trow claimed the same thing Christmas flipped.

Weird game. 2 cops and 2 governors.

Actually had no bearing on aligment because the alignment could have been picked up from elsewhere.

When I saw it last night, I incorrectly thought it was a botched claim.

[MrTrow]

I really REALLY hate to admit it, but it killed 2.
There was no way i bought not 1 but 2 players targeting a practically claimed PGO.
As such i was sold on 'there must be a SK' because 'aliens tend to be more interesting as role than alignment and wouldn't have used the (required for endgame) kill'
With SK wins 2p endgame, my only chance was 'kill the sk(most likely eye, though dayvig is one of the roles to consider dumping vannilaizer for) and hope eye kills guille (as there was no way he would deviate from his order to stump me(after all he asked for the direction) )

@guille, how was that a good thing?
p-edit: so what would you have done if you read it?

[Espeonage]

I'm assuming that guille would have not shot and you still would have lost that lylo.

[Espeonage]

To be fair, the setup ended up way townsided.

[MrTrow]

that lylo.. correct i wouldn't have stood a chance in that one (the last one giving him orders was lynched, but... sufficient other differences)
my last D2 post was never intended to convince guille to target eye and admittedly getting potential 'scum-eye' to consider the possibility guille did chance his mind was only a bonus.
The goal of that post was to generate the possibility the latter had happened, watch scum-esp flip, kill guille and lylo off against eye


now that alignment is no longer a factor.
care to explain why you pretty much lied about what you did and didn't read, basically every other post?
and refused to explain any read?

[guille2015]

@guille, how was that a good thing?
p-edit: so what would you have done if you read it?

I would have advocated for your Lynch rather than Esp. You'd govern yourself and I would have targeted ESP during the night.

[Alchemist21]

@guille, how was that a good thing?
p-edit: so what would you have done if you read it?

I would have advocated for your Lynch rather than Esp. You'd govern yourself and I would have targeted ESP during the night.

I would have voted Trow first to avoid his being lynch immune today, but I PM'd the mod and got conformation that gov. Could not self target.

[Espeonage]

So glad I correctly cleared Alch.

[MrTrow]

@slimer:
i was completely sold on your roleblock claim.
The 'i don't think he's a cop but i do think he's town' opening before any serious claim-requests (sorry eye, but seriously? i just claimed for no reason and we have a dead groupscum so starting with my innocent: claim now)

Had i not been scum i would have taken your side in that dipole, but as 'esp=obv-scum' i couldn't risk a roleblocker marked for bloodloss, deciding to gambit and block me.
no nightkill, lylo vs 2 practically confirmed town AND the roleblocker (now flipped town) who's the most logical reason for the lack of a nightkill able to confirm target.
You had to go

@guille: nope i wouldn't have governed myself. I couldn't
but indeed i basically told you to force(ask would have sufficed) me to use my ability. (alch, did you miss the 'just ask will suffice' part too?)

but yeah the 'i couldn't' was quite frustrating:
after a 'reroll because too much scum', picking scum,(1 shot)twilight-silent auto-nolynch (usually able to self-target if x-shot) and getting:
1-shot day-unlynchable-maker, without buddies and unable to self-target

@espeonage:
otherwise i would have, one thing that stood out was how you didn't do the same for guille's 'blocks own nightkill'-vig or came back on the alch-clear after the dayvig-claim, which i assume fell in your 'better 2%', it sure fell in mine

b.t.w should i take that as a no?

[Alchemist21]

I missed the just ask part. Where was that?

[Diego1487]

I'm just glad that my poor play didn't lose it for the team! For a game that I played less than 24 hours, I truly learned a lot about the game. Especially what not to do!! I've been thinking about it. Should I have even claimed anything before the lynch? I know never to lie as town, but I feel that the claim was actually the last straw.

[eyestott]

It was just chance, and my fault. I erroneously thought you were scum, as I was a cop.