In post 1, Armageddon wrote:
26) Do not admit to not having read The Rules. The rules are here for a reason. Read them, follow them, know them.
In post 23, Apricity wrote:VOTE: Diego
I don't get the point of his reaction test, nor why he picked itle in particular.
Random's entry post also confuses me.
In post 46, duppin wrote:Why not? What if it was the doctor?
In post 65, My Other Head Is Scum wrote:Okay, this is the town head speaking.
random seems town.
Jester is town
Diego I'm thinking town.
Not too much for the first 3 pages going on apart from people being petty.
@itlepip - Talk to me about DiamondSentinel. You think that this is scummy?
I wouldn't consider that self meta. It's just someone ducking the RVS stage (null tell).
-Vedith
In post 19, Diego1487 wrote:VOTE: lillith
For not realizing that I misspelled the name before I pointed it out.
In post 78, Not_Mafia wrote:
In post 25, Diego1487 wrote:He placed a vote and gave what looked like a reason for the vote in the same post. I wanted to know if the reason was sarcasm, and therefore RSV, or an actual reason that I was going to analyze.In post 23, Apricity wrote:VOTE: Diego
I don't get the point of his reaction test, nor why he picked itle in particular.
Random's entry post also confuses me.
In post 28, Diego1487 wrote:In post 27, Apricity wrote:In post 25, Diego1487 wrote:He placed a vote and gave what looked like a reason for the vote in the same post. I wanted to know if the reason was sarcasm, and therefore RSV, or an actual reason that I was going to analyze.
It was literally the 3rd post of the game. Did you really expect him to have a serious reason?
No that was why I would have had an issue with it had he said it was serious.
VOTE: Diego1487
In post 72, lilith2013 wrote:In post 54, lilith2013 wrote:I don't think I've played with Fire before
Fire has no way of scumreading me. If the hydra were voting me seriously this early, it would probably come from Vedith because I have played with him before. Also, from what I know, Fire and Vedith have similar playstyles (e.g, unserious/trolling). Therefore, I doubt Fire's vote on me was serious or had any reasonable basis. --> trolling
It had nothing to do with him not sharing reasons.
In post 94, lilith2013 wrote:
In my view, trolling = not serious. Not necessarily a bad thing. I do think you both are not always serious and use a lot of sarcasm, which is trolling to me. In terms of being able to scumread me, I seriously doubt Fire would be able to say right off the bat, while I was obviously RVSing, whether I was scum. Because we haven't played together before.
In post 102, lilith2013 wrote:I believe I've read through one or two of his games, which gave me a general idea of how he behaves and his posting style. As I only have one finished game onsite, I doubt anyone would know enough about me to know my playstyle.
What kind of play would lead you to form a legitimate reason to vote someone you'd never played with before?
In post 23, Apricity wrote:VOTE: Diego
I don't get the point of his reaction test, nor why he picked itle in particular.
Random's entry post also confuses me.
In post 15, Diego1487 wrote:Ok. That's what the intent behind the question.In post 13, itlepip wrote:its RVS dude...
In post 23, Apricity wrote:VOTE: Diego
I don't get the point of his reaction test, nor why he picked itle in particular.
Random's entry post also confuses me.
In post 81, Sharky5x wrote:diego may have possibly just done something stupid rather than scumslipped or anything, would like to move on from it. so many people jumped on him its kinda odd
In post 965, Koggz wrote:In post 65, My Other Head Is Scum wrote:Okay, this is the town head speaking.
random seems town.
Jester is town
Diego I'm thinking town.
Not too much for the first 3 pages going on apart from people being petty.
@itlepip - Talk to me about DiamondSentinel. You think that this is scummy?
I wouldn't consider that self meta. It's just someone ducking the RVS stage (null tell).
-Vedith
town 3 yes
In post 86, My Other Head Is Scum wrote:78 - Man of many words. This also makes me think Diego is town more. I think that the votes are in the wrong place.
In post 86, My Other Head Is Scum wrote:In post 81, Sharky5x wrote:I overuse wording like "make a case" srry
diego may have possibly just done something stupid rather than scumslipped or anything, would like to move on from it. so many people jumped on him its kinda odd
Why are you apologising? It's normally a sign of scum trying to get town onside for me.
I like the rest of the post though.
In post 86, My Other Head Is Scum wrote:In post 84, DiamondSentinel wrote:If someone is at L-1 and gives me a decent reason for voting, then I will vote. Otherwise, I will not be voting anytime soon.
No.
UNVOTE: Whoever
VOTE: Diamond
Still on page 4. This is going to be a fantastic game.
Jester - Where's the spam?
-Vedith
In post 88, Sharky5x wrote:while I think he could equally be a misguided townie as weak scum, I can understand voting him, as the question was not useful in any way and could be contrived as scum wanting to appear like he's scumhunting. I do think scum on his wagon is a possibility, but I'm not going to bank on that just yetIn post 83, The_Jester wrote:Sharky, do you think there's scum on Diego's wagon?
In post 88, Sharky5x wrote:why?! is the first day so pointless we shouldn't gather any information on it whatsoever?In post 84, DiamondSentinel wrote:If someone is at L-1 and gives me a decent reason for voting, then I will vote. Otherwise, I will not be voting anytime soon.
how bout we put you at l-1 for "no participation"
decent reason enough?
In post 91, Sharky5x wrote:I checked the one other full game he played on this site. he was active, just took him hella long to vote anyone. I still disagree with his view and I want to see his response to my postIn post 89, The_Jester wrote:@Sharky why don't you vote him then?
In post 90, My Other Head Is Scum wrote:
If Deigo is town, like I believe, then I expect that there's a scum on there.
-Vedith
In post 82, Armageddon wrote:
DiamondSentinel- 1 - duppin - (L-6)
Diego1487- 3 - Apricity, The_Jester, Not_Mafia - (L-4)
lilith2013- 1 - Sharky5x - (L-6)
Not_Mafia- 1 - randomidget - (L-6)
randomidget- 3 - Diego1487, lilith2013, A Simple Plan - (L-4)
Sharky5x- 1 - itlepip - (L-6)
Players not voting: DiamondSentinel, Lalendra, My Other Head Is Scum
In post 92, duppin wrote:I actually don't like the Diego train. While I didn't agree with what he said, I don't find it scummy at all.
In post 92, duppin wrote:There are a couple of players I'd like to look at actually, but at the moment I am going to keep my vote on Diamond. I don't mind you avoiding RVS, but we aren't in RVS anymore so I'd like to hear from you now. No thoughts on the game?
In post 61, duppin wrote:VOTE: Unvote
VOTE: Vote: DiamondSentinel
no no why you here
is for easy you intent or no
Alright, get us out of RVS then.
In post 62, duppin wrote:Erh, apparently I typed vote as well in the previous post. Just to be sure:
VOTE: DiamondSentinel
In post 36, duppin wrote:In post 28, Diego1487 wrote:In post 27, Apricity wrote:In post 25, Diego1487 wrote:He placed a vote and gave what looked like a reason for the vote in the same post. I wanted to know if the reason was sarcasm, and therefore RSV, or an actual reason that I was going to analyze.
It was literally the 3rd post of the game. Did you really expect him to have a serious reason?
No that was why I would have had an issue with it had he said it was serious.
Why? Do you think it would've been a scumtell if he was serious?
In post 46, duppin wrote:Why not? What if it was the doctor?
In post 99, My Other Head Is Scum wrote:In post 94, lilith2013 wrote:In my view, trolling = not serious. Not necessarily a bad thing. I do think you both are not always serious and use a lot of sarcasm, which is trolling to me. In terms of being able to scumread me, I seriously doubt Fire would be able to say right off the bat, while I was obviously RVSing, whether I was scum. Because we haven't played together before.
Who on Diego's wagon do you think is scum?
As I said, anyone can suspect anyone in a game... I've read 2 or 3 posts of people before and thought that I knew their align. Is it probably wrong? Good chance, but it's still there.
If I haven't played with someone, there's certain things I look out for as a general play to help me decide.
However, what concerns me here with you is this.
In post 72, lilith2013 wrote:Also, from what I know, Fire and Vedith have similar playstyles
In post 94, lilith2013 wrote:I seriously doubt Fire would be able to say right off the bat, while I was obviously RVSing, whether I was scum. Because we haven't played together before.
So you are saying that you can have an opinion on him even though you have never played with him, but his opinion on you would be false?
-Vedith
In post 962, Koggz wrote:In post 1, Armageddon wrote:
26) Do not admit to not having read The Rules. The rules are here for a reason. Read them, follow them, know them.
yes
a simple plan ice notmafia fire diamondsentinel doctor diego1487 wanderer randommidget vanilla townie
yes
In post 137, A Simple Plan wrote:84 is terrible, but the reaction in 86 is opportunistic AF. And this is a lot more early game content from Vedith than I'm used to. Almost like he's trying too hard to lead.
VOTE: My Other Head is Scum
I'm liking Random for scum too. Re 41: "Can (I) not" what? Any other thoughts on the game so far?
Duppin's approach toward Diamond is rather town-minded, see 98.
P-Edit: Oh, FML, you guys are speeding things up on me, huh?
In post 162, itlepip wrote:In post 161, DiamondSentinel wrote:Holy shit, you guys are comedy gold! Maybe I should just stick to theme games. I'm already sucking at first non-theme. Anyways, how about you guys not lynch me and do some actual scumhunting. That'd be nice, please and thank you.
VOTE: Diamond
VOTE: Diamond
VOTE: Diamond
VOTE: Diamond
"Hey guys, please don't vote me. Thanks! I know you have some questions for me, but I think it is better to just ask to be townread then actually address any of you, Byeee"
In post 180, lilith2013 wrote:What is this post even.. Is this supposed to be a crumb or something?
In post 227, DiamondSentinel wrote:You guys are dumb, but at least not a hopeless case. Thank God people unvoted me. Anyways, how about you NOT lynch me today, and then deal with me tomorrow as you will.
In post 228, lilith2013 wrote:I don't know if I can make this any clearer:
I'll take my vote off you when you actually start doing something other than say "gaiz plz don't lynch me"
In post 235, itlepip wrote:If somehow Diamond is genuine about this: Diamond, here is the problem, everyone here was a noob at some point, I still probably qualify since I have only been here a few months. You are not adapting to the meta or the way the game works here at all. Saying, don't lynch me cause I don't want to analyze things d1 is going to cause this exact wagon every game. The reason for it is not physically possible to win a forum game of mafia if you only look at actions and not words. Honestly everyone can analyze actions, but to say that you have nothing to contribute d1, and outside of a few remarks d2 on the night actions have nothing else to contribute means that you are effectively already lynched if you are town.
PEDIT: Yep.
In post 235, itlepip wrote:You are not adapting to the meta or the way the game works here at all. Saying, don't lynch me cause I don't want to analyze things d1 is going to cause this exact wagon every game.
In post 244, My Other Head Is Scum wrote:DS is likely town I feel like. Seems very open and transparent. Pretty easy to read imo.
-Fire
In post 257, duppin wrote:Oh and:
UNVOTE:
Diamond's play is a bit weird, but I do not find it that scummy.
In post 269, itlepip wrote:In post 267, DiamondSentinel wrote:In post 265, Sharky5x wrote:i almost wish i hammered diamond while i couldve, this is ridiculous
If that statement isn't scummy, I don't know what is...
Yay a post I agree with
VOTE: Sharky I can ride this wagon.
In post 273, itlepip wrote:In post 272, Sharky5x wrote:yes because as scum if i get voted one time i immediately give up and shitpost
itepip is scum
diamond is either really newbie scum "Yeah, might as well", or newbie town trying to actually play and fit in
by the way you gotta spell my name right for it to count i believe
lol omgus. Why wouldn't I vote for you there, I have always been scum reading you.
In post 13, itlepip wrote:its RVS dude...
In post 281, Sharky5x wrote:I don't really see you as scum, i didnt even know what your reason for voting me was prior to this post. itlepip gave up on me (with a "I still think sharky is scum") for an easy mislynch in diamond. that is until you voted me and diamond calls something I said scummy, then he hops on the opportunity. not to mention how terrible diamonds reasoning was, i dont see town!itlepips thought process hereIn post 279, itlepip wrote:In post 278, Sharky5x wrote:not to mention that wasnt even a point, that was making fun of how you came to the conclusion that my post is scummy. youre doing a great job on the scumhunting thing, amirite?
He found scum, so he is doing that part right at least. Your entire gamehasbeen just shitposting, so what Diamond says isn't too much of an insight, but if you don't want to be the lynch today you'd better actually explain your thoughts instead of just 'lol, I'm town, people who think I'm scum are scum. How can you guyz not see how super towny I am lol'
In post 291, itlepip wrote:In post 290, Sharky5x wrote:In post 285, itlepip wrote:In post 284, Sharky5x wrote:Notice how he kept the gamestate in a place that seemed like I just gave up as scum? :I If I get lynched for that dumb mistake and yall dont lynch itlepip after that ima be pissed
I'm fine with you getting lynched and then crossing that bridge when we get there.
sounds good
watch as he plays it off tomorrow by talking about how terrible i am and how it really was just because im so anti-town
Yeah, you do know what the expression crossing the bridge when we get there means? Cause lynching scummy people isn't scummy.
In post 305, Sharky5x wrote:
My problem with itlepip is how he voted me. He set me aside early on to go for the easy lynch on you, then came back as soon as you remarked my shitpost was scummy.
In post 431, Randomnamechange wrote:Probably duppin or itlepip. They were thr people who jumped off when it started to fall apart and did it in a way that would allow rhem to jump back on.
In post 445, lilith2013 wrote:
Even if diamond is town, I would be okay lynching him at some point, if not today, because I wouldn't want town!him to face lylo if this is his playstyle. And I think scum would want someone who is mislynch bait to survive so if we don't lynch him he might survive to lylo.
In post 544, itlepip wrote:I will move to Diego if and only if it means a lynch for today. He's been middling for me and I would prefer Sharky, Diamond or Random, but a lynch today is better than no lynch.
In post 569, Armageddon wrote:
After much discussion, the town comes to an agreement with the day quickly slipping away, and Diego1487 is brought to be executed, but to the towns chagrin, they find that Diego1487 was not made of fire, nor ice.
Diego1487 was aVanilla Townie
Now the day draws to a close, and as the sun begins to set, the town fears that fire may burn and ice may freeze.
The deadline for night one will be frozen until 24 hours after a replacement for Apricity is found, or 48 hours after this post; whichever is later.
In post 575, DiamondSentinel wrote:Interesting. So Doctor knows the Ice Mafia kill.
In post 674, itlepip wrote:In post 673, DiamondSentinel wrote:That exactly what I'm not saying. I'm saying leave that as a null read and atop mentioning it. I'm not asking to be town-read. I'm asking to not be shittly scum-read.
Can everyone jump on this wagon please...
In post 678, SnarkySnowman wrote:Popping in quickly, still trying to be really
I'm getting the feeling that Diamond is town and flailing pretty hard because everyone is just kinda on him for not a whole lot. I don't like itlepip on this one.
Also VOTE: Not_mafia
Not quite satisfied with NM lynch yet but I think my vote belongs here for now. I think, mainly, he needs to talk a lot more.
In post 681, SnarkySnowman wrote:It's certainly cringeworthy, but I think on the whole his play reads town to me. I'm not saying he's 100% confirmed town but it feels town and not scum to me. I don't feel good about it but I don't feel it's scum.
In post 713, itlepip wrote:Sharky, first off I am pretty sure that Diamond is scum. Second the way I see it even if Diamond is town here we can't have him in lylo, so either we lynch him sometime or we find all scum before lylo. Since I think Heim is scum and if he is town he isn't going to help us, we should just lynch him here.
In post 731, DiamondSentinel wrote:Fine. You've set this up yourself...
I'm the doctor. I healed someone (not revealing) last night, thus the comment.
In post 740, Not_Mafia wrote:lillith is not ice scum
In post 747, lilith2013 wrote:In post 743, Titus wrote:In post 741, DiamondSentinel wrote:I didn't reveal who i healed because you said it only helped scum. I healed wanderer just randomly.
You healed "randomly" as a doctor? Also, why didn't you vote NM when he CCed you?
I read NM's post as "lilith isn't ice scum because if she were ice she would push for doctor to keep quiet about confirming someone to be non-Ice." Not a CC. NM, what did you mean by that post?
In post 754, lilith2013 wrote:In post 751, SnarkySnowman wrote:Can Not Mafia say things that are more than one or two lines?
Also again I buy DS being town and would really like to not lynch him today.
You really buy that doctor claim?
In post 865, itlepip wrote:In post 864, lilith2013 wrote:Could you explain why he's fire and not ice? Who do you think ice is?
Jester, MOHIS or sharky are my top picks as long as NM does flip fire. I don't see him flipping ice but if he does all my reads right now are worthless. Snarky is probably his partner because of his whiteknighting yesterday. If he was ice he wouldn't know that NM was the fake claim, but as fire he would.
In post 912, My Other Head Is Scum wrote:In post 907, itlepip wrote:
In post 740, Not_Mafia wrote:lillith is not ice scum
In post 750, Not_Mafia wrote:I may or may not have claimed doctor
How is that a claim exactly?
Saying "I may or may not have claimed doctor" is not claiming doctor...
Neither is voting someone for claiming doctor
Neither is saying that someone is not scum...
So again, show me where NM claims.
-Vedith
In post 941, itlepip wrote:wait do we actually want to lynch scum right now? If we lynch town then the two scum will probably want to kill each other. If they both miss then we have 2 scum versus 1 town which I think is a town win 50% of the time. If 1 misses we are in lylo 2 which is the worst situation for us, and at best the two scum kill each other.
In post 1041, Not_Mafia wrote:No
