Mini 1768: Detective Conan Mafia (Game Over: Town Wins)

[Soren]

VOTE: A Real Scourge Can't tell if the sonic avatar is angry or trying to be seductive.

[Soren]

VOTE: Barn Of Justice
For not confirming.

The whole point of rvs is to throw random bullshit to progress the game.
You are throwing random bullshit at a player who has not even confirmed yet.
Therefore your vote does not progress the game. (until perhaps they come into the game but it's better to vote someone who has already confirmed no?)

Why did you vote for someone who hasn't confirmed yet?

[Soren]

Because I can?

I can also choose to troll. Should I do that? No.

For trying to portray me as scummy and not laying a vote down.

I'm portraying you as not advancing the game state. Something I find anti town but not necessarily scummy. But I like where this is going. You didn't like that I called you out on it and retaliated in an omgus nature. Thanks
VOTE: Garmr

If you hold so much value in progress, Why did you lay a completely random rvs votes when you could of used that (terrible reasoning) on me.

Because I noticed it after.

[Soren]

Because I can?

I can also choose to troll. Should I do that? No.

For trying to portray me as scummy and not laying a vote down.

I'm portraying you as not advancing the game state. Something I find anti town but not necessarily scummy. But I like where this is going. You didn't like that I called you out on it and retaliated in an omgus nature. Thanks
VOTE: Garmr

If you hold so much value in progress, Why did you lay a completely random rvs votes when you could of used that (terrible reasoning) on me.

Because I noticed it after.

It's a random vote it's not trolling wow. Well I will tell you where you can stick your anti town bs (a random vote isn't anti town by the way.) Even if you noticed it after why didn't you switch your vote straight away and actually pushed something even if you found if you just found it antitown (which only a idiot would think it is) wouldn't you? You only seemed to dodge that line of thought.

Lol that's also cute that you use the word omgus completely wrong. Omgus is supposed to be a emotional response with no point to it. That's why it's called oh my god you suck. I provided reasoning and you pretty much try to discount that with a misuse of the word omgus. Explain why the vote on you was scummy?

Also I will content you were trying to push me in a negative light for voting someone in a rvs stage and I believe that original intent was trying to smear a scummy coat of paint. The fact you were called on it and made a make shift reason to vote me even through you thought it was supposedly antitown and not scummy means you preplanedto vote me anyway. I have never seen a scum fuck up so fast.

1. I didn't say you were trolling. I was making a point that just because you can do something it doesn't mean that you should do it.
2. Explain to me how a random vote that doesn't advance the game state is not anti town.
3. I wanted to question you first than to jump to conclusions.
3. Your reasoning sucked and came off way too defensive.
4. Your vote on me is just bad. You just didn't like what I said about you and so you voted for me.
5. You're pretty quick to call me scum. How confident are you?

[Soren]

It feels like either one of 3 thinhs is happening right now

Either
1)Soren is town and his reasons for being suspicious of garmr are right
2)Garmr is town and Soren is trying to paint him in a bad light because he's scum
Or
3)Both of you are scum and this is some early scum distancing

And what do you think it is?

[Soren]

VOTE: Phoenox Wright maybe both of them are TOWN??? You didn't consider that??

I don't like how defensive and tense they got right off the bat. It's just a feeling, but I think at least one of them is scum

if Nick had also listed the option of both of them being town, I would have called his post useless for avoiding putting down any opinion at all.

the fact that he put down the option of it being early scum distancing (instead of just saying 'lol there's at least one scum there) says to me that he's actually thinking about their alignments.

I agree with this. It seems Kain didn't think about the post deeply enough and instantly thought he made a scum driven post. His quick judgment demonstrates that he wanted to find something easy and quickly in order to place a vote down. And it's giving me some scum vibes at the moment.
What do you think this tells us about Kain's alignment?

[Soren]

Yes you did basically you put it on the same level as trolling from such a minuscule action.

So if I instead said "I can ran around the streets naked. Should I do that? No." does that then mean I was saying that you're running around the street naked? No. I'm making the point that just because you can do something it doesn't mean you should.

[Soren]

Yes you did basically you put it on the same level as trolling from such a minuscule action.

So if I instead said "I can ran around the streets naked. Should I do that? No." does that then mean I was saying that you're running around the street naked? No. I'm making the point that just because you can do something it doesn't mean you should.

Your so called point still sucks lol. It's extremely weak as pointed out by other people and what's funny is you think it's valid and you haven't moved past it despite all the activity that's going on. You didn't even mention it or put in to it.

[Soren]

what

[Soren]

What's happening right now?...

mod edit, alt slip

[Soren]

I don't have much of a grasp at this game to be honest.

[Soren]

Was busy today, will try to post tmrw.

[Soren]

I don't see anything in his iso.
VOTE: Barn Of Justice

[Soren]

kain are you just a troll

[Soren]

can we talk about Soren's hammering Barn without a claim? we would have unvoted if he'd claimed CONAN the ROLECOP. :/

If he flipped vanilla townie would you have the same view on me right now?
Because his role has nothing to do with how he played in the game.

[Soren]

can we talk about Soren's hammering Barn without a claim? we would have unvoted if he'd claimed CONAN the ROLECOP. :/

If he flipped vanilla townie would you have the same view on me right now?
Because his role has nothing to do with how he played in the game.

i probably wouldn't be as annoyed about it, i would still be on your case about hammering without a claim.
that's just proper course, it doesn't matter what their play is like, you ask for a claim before hammering. why didn't you? i made my intent to hammer very clear so that Barn would know he needed to claim, but you decided to hammer anyways, before Barn even got back.

I hammered because his slot didn't look town.

[Soren]

I'll admit that the hammer was bad because I didn't give him time to come to the thread and claim. I'm not sure ARS is expecting more from me, I gave my reason already, I didn't have any scum reads, it was the most likely lynch to go through that day and I didn't think he looked town, so I hammered.

[Soren]

I may have missed your point so link me your post if you already explained it but I'm not seeing the evaluation to draw the conclusion that the hammer was scum motivated.
I want you to consider my quickhammer to come from town, and then consider my quickhammer to come from scum.
Then tell me why the action is more likely to come from scum than town.

[Soren]

what's your read on me from all this, Soren? and your reads on the other people who were on your wagon?

I have town reads on Tails, A Real Scourge, Firebringer, Kain and Not_Mafia

[Soren]

Kain

Explain this one.

Don't think he would troll as scum.

[Soren]

Kain

Explain this one.

Don't think he would troll as scum.

Isn't that the perfect reason to do it?

Not a good scum strategy.

[Soren]

Kain

Explain this one.

Don't think he would troll as scum.

why wld you think this?

and how much experience do you have with kain?

More of an objective view so I guess it's not a strong indication.
None.

[Soren]

So you think ARS is pushing a miss lynch on you?

[Soren]

it just feels like she hasn't actually been trying to hunt people.

Do you find this to be an inaccurate observation of you, FA?

[Soren]

according to the last votecount, nobody is close to lynch

look at this shit!
and he just claimed that previous votes weren't policy ...
so what the fuck!

It appears as if she's trying to break away from the current stagnation and progress the game, what's wrong with that?

[Soren]

Only if I get head pats.

[Soren]

It appears as if she's trying to break away from the current stagnation and progress the game, what's wrong with that?

that vote he did on me to make someone closer to lynch and suggesting a kind of insta lynch while I just started playing the game is not bothering you?!

oh come on. he said those votes weren't policy , but voting an inactive player is obviously what we call a policy lynch.

and we have like 8 days ... so whats up with that vote and suggestion to push people close to lynch?!

that post is contradicting itself from up and down

He could just be pressuring you.
It's not strictly a policy. More like hey everyone active is looking town, and we got this inactive player here who isn't scum hunting so they might be scum, let's lynch it.

[Soren]

VOTE: Phoenix Wright

[Soren]

hypnotic

[Soren]

VOTE: Phoenix Wright

Explain

wanted to place a vote, i dont have a town read on him

[Soren]

busy today will catch up another time

[Soren]

is turtle scum? i'll sheep it

[Soren]

firebringer your avatar is too squashed

[Soren]

i havent read the past 15 pages btw ive been really busy

[Soren]

might even be 20 pages actually.
rip

[Soren]

dont know how i feel about this

[Soren]

Jeanne11 VC please

[Soren]

Reporting for duty

[Soren]

Soren should claim

I am Kaito Kuroba and I am vanilla townie.

[Soren]

We are lynching Soren today. And I will be suspect of anyone who refuses to do so.

There's a difference to being scummy and not being helpful to town.

[Soren]

are you asking me to self vote

[Soren]

last mafia shouldnt be too hard to catch, good luck town

[Soren]

gg