Mini 1768: Detective Conan Mafia (Game Over: Town Wins)

[A Real Scourge]

Firebringer why are you townreading Tails so hard if the majority of his hunting this day has been 'a pointless endeavor'?

[Firebringer]

i'm pretty sure Firebringer, myself, and Yarrrrgami are the only players in this game who've yet to claim. lmao

preview: Tails this is the first valid thing you've said about Phoenix tbh. it's weird he didn't seem to think about

anything

before just claiming

I am not claiming either.

[Firebringer]

Firebringer why are you townreading Tails so hard if the majority of his hunting this day has been 'a pointless endeavor'?

So because someone does something that is pointless they aren't town?
What the fuck is your logic at?

[Firebringer]

Seriously, I never even said Tails was town for his actions today. He was town for me before this day, before the setup spec and def before his claim.

Scourge, where is your head?

[Yarrrrgami]

Pirates, I'm getting why Fire is frustrated. I have scum trying to slip away from me here. I've got them dead to rights. I need some more help.

why do you think is frustrated? the only person he finds scummy in the entire game is suddenly moi, cos I a calling him out on his shit.

[Tails]

That was my point before I felt forced to claim. Phoenix's actions do not match up with his claimed role. He showed 0 suspicion of Sonic d2, even though he should have seen that as a counter claim i.e. scum claim (such as how I felt about his role in relation to mine), and then after he claimed a protection on NM, he didn't even consider a strongman and tried to lynch Sonic with the lying reasoning (something I would have also expected more from him as town a day earlier). Only later does he decide to "ask" the mod. Wouldn't that be something he'd do right away before outing if he was town?

[Firebringer]

why do you think is frustrated? the only person he finds scummy in the entire game is suddenly moi, cos I a calling him out on his shit.

I called your some of your behavior scummy, you even look at my reads list?
You can't read for shit.

[Firebringer]

That was my point before I felt forced to claim. Phoenix's actions do not match up with his claimed role. He showed 0 suspicion of Sonic d2, even though he should have seen that as a counter claim i.e. scum claim (such as how I felt about his role in relation to mine), and then after he claimed a protection on NM, he didn't even consider a strongman and tried to lynch Sonic with the lying reasoning (something I would have also expected more from him as town a day earlier). Only later does he decide to "ask" the mod. Wouldn't that be something he'd do right away before outing if he was town?

If you consider roles (which I don't), this actually has some good points.

[Tails]

@Pirates: The more I play this game, the more I get angry at just the game in general. And I'm hoping beyond all hope that this game follows some form of sanity, because if not, I'm done.

[A Real Scourge]

Firebringer why are you townreading Tails so hard if the majority of his hunting this day has been 'a pointless endeavor'?

So because someone does something that is pointless they aren't town?
What the fuck is your logic at?

Seriously, I never even said Tails was town for his actions today. He was town for me before this day, before the setup spec and def before his claim.

Scourge, where is your head?

Firebringer it's fine for you to townread Tails but you are

sheeping his read

that came from actions YOU have deemed pointless for scumhunting. that's about as useful as voting randomly.

[Firebringer]

Firebringer it's fine for you to townread Tails but you are sheeping his read that came from actions YOU have deemed pointless for scumhunting. that's about as useful as voting randomly.

I am voting someone who is Null, and therefore not town to me.
Then I looked at my town reads who had a case on someone and decided "well the person they are voting for is null for me, I don't see why not sheep"

Thats literally my train of thought.

[Yarrrrgami]

you do set up spec cos that is how the is played on your homesite at least that is what you said in ANOTHER game that I was in with you.

so you are lying and want to avoid any discussion on set up spec for some reason. mostly that you do it.

Shut up. I don't setup spec on Closed Setups because its a pointless endeavor.

My homesite never does a Closed Setup.

In summary: I am not a liar, you are misinformed and still a moron.

YOU stfu.

and stop it with the insults

[A Real Scourge]

That was my point before I felt forced to claim. Phoenix's actions do not match up with his claimed role. He showed 0 suspicion of Sonic d2, even though he should have seen that as a counter claim i.e. scum claim (such as how I felt about his role in relation to mine), and then after he claimed a protection on NM, he didn't even consider a strongman and tried to lynch Sonic with the lying reasoning (something I would have also expected more from him as town a day earlier). Only later does he decide to "ask" the mod. Wouldn't that be something he'd do right away before outing if he was town?

Tails you know that Nick attempted to jailkeep Not_Mafia LAST NIGHT, (n2) right? he wouldn't have known about his action failing on Day 2.

[Firebringer]

YOU stfu.

and stop it with the insults

You have been misrepresenting me since the start of this day.
And you want me to shut up?

I thought you wanted to read me?
I guess you just wanted to discredit and misrepresent.

[A Real Scourge]

Firebringer it's fine for you to townread Tails but you are sheeping his read that came from actions YOU have deemed pointless for scumhunting. that's about as useful as voting randomly.

I am voting someone who is Null, and therefore not town to me.
Then I looked at my town reads who had a case on someone and decided "well the person they are voting for is null for me, I don't see why not sheep"

Thats literally my train of thought.

okay then why aren't you sheeping me on Turtles? that fits all the same criteria? your readslist you just posted says so.
considering Tails' case is based on setup spec, which is 'pointless', why are you sheeping that case instead of mine?

[Firebringer]

okay then why aren't you sheeping me on Turtles? that fits all the same criteria? your readslist you just posted says so.
considering Tails' case is based on setup spec, which is 'pointless', why are you sheeping that case instead of mine?

I would lynch Turtles, but Pheonix is also more active.

[Tails]

But he should have been at least suspicious of Sonic's roleblocker claim. He wasn't.

[Firebringer]

Tails you know that Nick attempted to jailkeep Not_Mafia LAST NIGHT, (n2) right? he wouldn't have known about his action failing on Day 2.

That action doesn't make sense.
Who would jailkeep Not Mafia?
Seriously.

[A Real Scourge]

okay then why aren't you sheeping me on Turtles? that fits all the same criteria? your readslist you just posted says so.
considering Tails' case is based on setup spec, which is 'pointless', why are you sheeping that case instead of mine?

I would lynch Turtles, but Pheonix is also more active.

activity is NIA
lurkers are bad for town in late-game anyways
so if thats the only thing that's weighing your vote i then have to ask if you are playing for town

[Firebringer]

I am sorry Yarrrgami, I want to apologize for my insults.
But I am very annoyed that you say I setup spec on this site.
Then you bring up one game (that was semi open) and use it as proof.

I find that very misleading.

[Firebringer]

activity is NIA
lurkers are bad for town in late-game anyways
so if thats the only thing that's weighing your vote i then have to ask if you are playing for town

No, I am obviously scum.

What kind of leading question is that?

[A Real Scourge]

Tails you know that Nick attempted to jailkeep Not_Mafia LAST NIGHT, (n2) right? he wouldn't have known about his action failing on Day 2.

That action doesn't make sense.
Who would jailkeep Not Mafia?
Seriously.

*shrug*
thought he was scum? idk
ask Phoenix yourself, make your own judgements about him
the scum killed him so it was obviously a good choice????

you could make the case that Phoenix said that because his scumteam killed Not_Mafia i guess

[Phoenix Wright]

That was my point before I felt forced to claim. Phoenix's actions do not match up with his claimed role. He showed 0 suspicion of Sonic d2, even though he should have seen that as a counter claim i.e. scum claim (such as how I felt about his role in relation to mine), and then after he claimed a protection on NM, he didn't even consider a strongman and tried to lynch Sonic with the lying reasoning (something I would have also expected more from him as town a day earlier). Only later does he decide to "ask" the mod. Wouldn't that be something he'd do right away before outing if he was town?

I don't know what a strongman is, so why would I consider it?

[A Real Scourge]

activity is NIA
lurkers are bad for town in late-game anyways
so if thats the only thing that's weighing your vote i then have to ask if you are playing for town

No, I am obviously scum.

What kind of leading question is that?

respond to the first two points, not the last one, which was an obvious jab at how your reasoning was bad.
that shouldn't be what's weighing your vote.

i will not lose this game to lurking scum.

preview: Phoenix you've played ten games and you've never looked up roles on the wiki...?

[Firebringer]

Phoenx since you are here, why did you JK Not Mafia?