Penalty box Mafia - Game over Hawks (Town) Wins 1-0

[ThAdmiral]

/confirm'd

[ThAdmiral]

Finally!

[ThAdmiral]

Has anyone been following the eagles game? And could they do a nice summary of it.
I would do it myself but....(runs away)

[ThAdmiral]

How is that advantageous to us?

Well I dunno, I haven't read it. But maybe there's something in it that would be useful for us to know.

[ThAdmiral]

I thought it was pretty clear what hjallti was saying and I'm a bit surprised by the backlash his comment recieved.

[ThAdmiral]

I'm still here I'm just a bit confused as to whats going on and don't really know what to say.

[ThAdmiral]

I'm still here.
i think we should do something productive, like a position claim.

[ThAdmiral]

I'm still here. I can hardly believe we've scored a goal without anyone actually having posted anything.
What are we supposed to be doing?

[ThAdmiral]

I will claim not in correct position. In fact i'm not the right side.

I agree the scum were probably on the bench day one. I'll have another look through all of them and then see who I want to vote for.

[ThAdmiral]

Hard to get on until after new years, but it is interesting to see there's a little wagonning going on. Good analysis fodder for later perhaps.

[ThAdmiral]

I have to agree with hjallti here. At the moment, while we are in front, we don't really need to claim. At some point I may support it but I don't think it's all that necessary now.

vote: no claim

[ThAdmiral]

Lurker lynching isn't always the best move, but in this case I will support it. Mainly just to get the game moving along.

[ThAdmiral]

vote: isquinndog

[ThAdmiral]

@lloyd: I've not abandoned. I'm still here. Just waiting for the coach to post the lineup.

I think your ability sounds more like something the scum would have than something a townie would have. I have half a mind to vote you but then everyone would just accuse me of omgussing.

[ThAdmiral]

Forward left wing by the way.

[ThAdmiral]

red

= completely wrong position

green

= correct position

blue

= right area (i.e. attack or defense), wrong side

orange

= right side (i.e. left or right), wrong area

Claims
Goalies: Farside22, swetapantsninja
Centers: Hackerhuck,*
Right Defense: ckillor, hasdfgas
Right Forward: Hjallti, isuquinndog (lynched)
Left Defense: Lloyd, *
Left Forward: ThAdmiral, Iammars

Day 1
Goalie: lloyd -

Left Defence

Center: sweatpantsninja -

Goalie

Right Defense: hackerhuck -

Center

Right Forward: JordanA24 -

Center

or

Left Defense

Left Defense: hasdgfas -

Right Defense

Left Forward: hjallti -

Right Forward

Day 2
Goalie: lloyd -

Left Defense

Center: Iammars -

Left Forward

Right Defense: TheAdmiral -

Left Forward

Right Forward: ckillor -

Right Defense

Left Defense: hasdgfas -

Right Defense

Left Forward: Hjallti -

Right Forward

Day 3
Goalie: farside22 -

Goalie

Left Defense: Lloyd -

Left Defense

Right Defense: hasdgfas -

Right Defense

Left Forward: Iammars -

Left Forward

Right Forward: hjallti -

Right Forward

Center: HackerHuck -

Center

Comments
- Day 2 seems to have a closer to correct side than day one (if indeed sides and areas come into affect at all).
- As such the theory that there must have been more mafiates on the field day 1 compared to day 2 is sound.
- This means, as people have already pointed out, thadmiral (me), ckillor and iammars are under the most suspicion.
- We should really dominate tonight!

Since it seems to be the best theory I will:

vote: ckillor

[ThAdmiral]

I am just confused as to how much the position on a team counts. It seems as though we got all the positions right last night but weren't able to score?
Can someone also tell me what is happening, exactly, with the eagles. Have they lynched all their scum or something like that?

[ThAdmiral]

Well I certainly don't like it very much.

The part about me being scum. Hjallti I could give a damn for.

I think it is pretty safe to say lloyd is confirmed town, what with the save and then the scum being in the left defence position.

[ThAdmiral]

Let me ask you this: if I had voted on the jordan wagon would I really look much more town. He was clearly being wagoned to death, so I think the smart scum move would have been to jump on.

[ThAdmiral]

You joined the quick lynch for isquinndog and Ckillor, but not Jordan and you don't think that should not look scummie?

Let me put it this way, if I was scum I would have been faced with two options:
- Vote for jordan, given the fact that he was clearly going to die, and then look slightly less suspicious the next day,
or
- not vote for jordan, look suspicious the next day. Sure I could then go "but hey, wouldn't a mafiate have voted him" (which is what I am doing), but even if people accept this argument (which I doubt) I still would have drawn attention to myself and would inevitably look more suspicious than what I would have looked if I had just voted jordan in the first place.
(It's a bit of a confusing sentence but it does in fact make sense!)

To respond the second part of your post: basically I had lost a bit of faith in the hit-and-hope quick-lynch after it failed us the past two nights.

[ThAdmiral]

Claims
Goalies: Farside22, swetapantsninja
Centers:

Hackerhuck

,

Cubsfan4eva

*
Right Defense:

ckillor

, hasdfgas
Right Forward:

Hjallti

,

isuquinndog

Left Defense:

Lloyd

,

JordanA24

Left Forward:

ThAdmiral

,

Iammars

*He didn't claim this but I guess he must be this or else he doesn't have a position, which would mean hackerhuck becomes more likely town. Basically it would be good if he could come back from wherever he is and help us out here!

Red

= lynched town

Dark Red

= lynched scum

Green

= fairly certain town

Orange

= under suspicion

As we can see we can't take off all the suspicious players - in fact we can't really take off any of them if we want to keep players in their correct positions.
However I would say that townies in the wrong positions are better than scum. So...

Goalie: Farside22
Center: Cubsfan4eva (or if not a center then Hackerhuck)
Right Defense: Hasdfgas
Left Defense: Lloyd
Right Forward: Sweatpanstninja
Left Forward: ThAdmiral

Leaving Hjallti and Iammars and potentially Hackerhuck on the bench.
I reckon if we do that we'll be bound to score.

and...

Pseudovote: Iammars

The fact that I know I am town and in the same position is just more evidence for me that he is scummy.

[ThAdmiral]

I too believe hackerhuck.

In that case I would probably make the team something like:

Goalie: Sweatpantsninja
Center: Hackerhuck
Right Defense: Hasdfgas
Left Defense: Lloyd
Right Forward: Hjallti
Left Forward: ThAdmiral

If we don't score with that line up then I give up and you can just kill me.

[ThAdmiral]

vote: no lynch

[ThAdmiral]

I reckon if I was on the pitch we would have scored.

Oh well - next time.

[ThAdmiral]

Using the analysis (and considering that the puck swaps teams each day, which seems to be the case) have we found out anything new about the current players?

[ThAdmiral]

I am leaning towards believing hackerhuck here just because if he's not centre, who is?

[ThAdmiral]

I think we should just put Thadmiral back in at left forward. This was my position yesterday and now we've got to go back to it to try it today.

To be fair to farside this is the slip that he was talking about which clearly shows hackerhuck was confused to some degree as to what position he was in.

Once again I don't think the slip revealed any maliciousness and I tend to believe hackerhuck is town.

[ThAdmiral]

I'd say one of hjalliti or hasfdas out.

[ThAdmiral]

Seconded.

[ThAdmiral]

No lynch sounds fine but we don't look like catching any scum soon unless the team analysis makes it clear who is and who isn't - which it hasn't so far.

[ThAdmiral]

The team seemed to be pretty effective. Give it another go in attack?

I'm pretty sure the puck switches - it would be too much of a coincidence that the puck would go back and forth each day.

[ThAdmiral]

Same line-up.
Watch us score!

[ThAdmiral]

Hey if we don't score you can come down on me, but until then let's play ball!

[ThAdmiral]

we might as well lynch iammars as we have all basiaclly agreed that he is scum.

vote: iammars

[ThAdmiral]

I really think we should lynch iammars today though. We all seem to agree that there's a good chance he's scum so we should find out for sure. We're obviously going to lynch him at some stage and we might as well find out sooner rather than later if he is scum or town, in which case we can reasses who else might be scum.

[ThAdmiral]

Hope not, it was finally getting somewhat interesting.

[ThAdmiral]

vote: iammars

[ThAdmiral]

What sweatpants said - what are the chances of two scum left wing forwards in the same team?

[ThAdmiral]

We were able to figure out that iammars was scum with information from teams and how they performed, so who would be the best person to put in for the most information?

[ThAdmiral]

I'd say chuck in sweatshop.

[ThAdmiral]

There seems to be scum in either hasdfgsas or hjallti so I agree with the above plan

[ThAdmiral]

We're ahead so I think the safe, defensive, option would be to no lynch.

vote: no lynch

[ThAdmiral]

Any thoughts?

Yes - you're an ass-hat. Trying to hold the town at ransom.

[ThAdmiral]

It doesn't matter if the person stays on or is absent after the lynch, either we'll be a man down, still have scum on the pitch, or be a man down

and

have scum on the pitch!

[ThAdmiral]

I'll extrapolate.

There are four possibilities - we hit scum or we don't hit scum, if someone on the team is lynched we are a man down or if someone on the team is lynched we aren't a man down.

There are four combinations - scum-man down, town-man down, scum-no man down, town-no man down.

The combinations:
Scum-man down: we hit scum, but we are a man down so we are at a slight disadvantage.

Town-man down: we hit town, and we are a man down so we are at a large disadvantage.

Scum-no man down: we hit scum, but he plays anyway so we are in the same position.

Town-no man down: we hit town, but he plays anyway so we are in the same position minus a town.


The best we can hope for is breaking even.

[ThAdmiral]

well if the choice is between me and no lynch,

ima gon vote:

no lynch

Where did all the heat on me come from all of a sudden anyway?

[ThAdmiral]

that's

vote: no lynch

[ThAdmiral]

I've had a gut feeling about sweatpants, which means he almost certainly town.

In a choice between me and him though, I'll choose him.

[ThAdmiral]

vote: sweatpantsninja

[ThAdmiral]

good, we won.

it probably would have been better if more goals were scored.