Mini 1781: Plotinus Mafia: Game Over

[Minsc and Boo]

Vote: Minsc and Boo

Hi there.

You angry? Or desperate to counter Fire?

I'ma let Radja catch up.

[Minsc and Boo]

I'm also not wanting scum to think you're a viable mislynch to push.

Why not?

We box the mislynches away, we'll lynch within my scum pool and we'll win.

[chamber]

Vote: Minsc and Boo

Hi there.

You angry? Or desperate to counter Fire?

I'ma let Radja catch up.

Do you actually think me + fire is a plausible scum team at this point?

I'm also not wanting scum to think you're a viable mislynch to push.

Why not?

We box the mislynches away, we'll lynch within my scum pool and we'll win.

That doesn't actually answer my question. The scum still aren't going to want to lynch themselves? If you think maru is town leaving him on the table as looking like a mislynch can only be good because you can jump on people that actually take the bait. I don't think this is actually alignment indicative but I do think it was a really empty statement.

[Iecerint]

You should know I like to check how my townreads are reading players I feel weird about.
Xkfyu wasn't a random player, he is someone I have an odd feeling about.

It read like "pls produce anti-Xkfyewkf content." I thought I remembered you listing 2 ppl tho which made it more like that but maybe I'm misremembering.

It would be sketchy if a major game topic were my alignment and I hadn't posted, ya, probably (to make the Smudger analogy clearer).

[Iecerint]

I am so cross with Daniel.

[Gorkington]

Do you actually think me + fire is a plausible scum team at this point?

i'd like you to explain why you feel like you&fire isnt plausible after titus answers this.

[Minsc and Boo]

Gork, my vote is reaffirmed by FA's posting. Tell me thoughts on X, IEC, and FA.

xkfyu is null with faint here-and-there feels of towniness that i dont particularly trust.
iece is maybe town but im scared because hes good and i havent played with him before so not confident about that at all.
fa is still a scum-guy. nothing about anything hes doing feels town to me.

are these questions for buddying purposes or sorting purposes?
let me know so i know how to react o them.

You consider Minsc and Boo town?
Boo!!!!!!

I don't know how wrong town can be in a game, but I think you are pretty pretty wrong so far about reads.
Meh.

Ewwwwww.

-Radja

[chamber]

Do you actually think me + fire is a plausible scum team at this point?

i'd like you to explain why you feel like you&fire isnt plausible after titus answers this.

I haven't thought of the plausibility of a me + fire scumteam in any depth. I think I defended him reasonably hard and in a way that would be weird if I were scum with him (we are thinking too much alike so he has to be town! falls back on me if he flips scum) which does make me think we should be at least a bit less likely, but that's not where I was going with the question of titus.

[Titus]

Vote: Minsc and Boo

Hi there.

You angry? Or desperate to counter Fire?

I'ma let Radja catch up.

Do you actually think me + fire is a plausible scum team at this point?

I'm also not wanting scum to think you're a viable mislynch to push.

Why not?

We box the mislynches away, we'll lynch within my scum pool and we'll win.

That doesn't actually answer my question. The scum still aren't going to want to lynch themselves? If you think maru is town leaving him on the table as looking like a mislynch can only be good because you can jump on people that actually take the bait. I don't think this is actually alignment indicative but I do think it was a really empty statement.

Yes. I do. Why should I suddenly believe you're town when you're hard defending scum and chainsawing on their behalf.

If scum have to vote somewhere. If there are no mislynches, scum are forced to bus. Blocking off mislynches is ideal play.

[Minsc and Boo]

Vote: Minsc and Boo

Hi there.

You angry? Or desperate to counter Fire?

I'ma let Radja catch up.

Do you actually think me + fire is a plausible scum team at this point?

I'm also not wanting scum to think you're a viable mislynch to push.

Why not?

We box the mislynches away, we'll lynch within my scum pool and we'll win.

That doesn't actually answer my question. The scum still aren't going to want to lynch themselves? If you think maru is town leaving him on the table as looking like a mislynch can only be good because you can jump on people that actually take the bait. I don't think this is actually alignment indicative but I do think it was a really empty statement.

Yes. I do. Why should I suddenly believe you're town when you're hard defending scum and chainsawing on their behalf.

If scum have to vote somewhere. If there are no mislynches, scum are forced to bus. Blocking off mislynches is ideal play.

[chamber]

That 2nd bit was directed at your other head wasn't it?

[chamber]

Do you actually think me + fire is a plausible scum team at this point?

i'd like you to explain why you feel like you&fire isnt plausible after titus answers this.

I haven't thought of the plausibility of a me + fire scumteam in any depth. I think I defended him reasonably hard and in a way that would be weird if I were scum with him (we are thinking too much alike so he has to be town! falls back on me if he flips scum) which does make me think we should be at least a bit less likely, but that's not where I was going with the question of titus.

Following up on this post answer, titus's comment felt quite reactionary. They were the first person I stated a suspicion of, they were listed in my top 3, and there is a building wagon on them where as my preferred vote is sitting idle, I think it's completely natural that I'd move my vote to them when I did. I was wondering if she was seriously considering me as a scum partner to fire for it.

[Titus]

Do you actually think me + fire is a plausible scum team at this point?

i'd like you to explain why you feel like you&fire isnt plausible after titus answers this.

I haven't thought of the plausibility of a me + fire scumteam in any depth. I think I defended him reasonably hard and in a way that would be weird if I were scum with him (we are thinking too much alike so he has to be town! falls back on me if he flips scum) which does make me think we should be at least a bit less likely, but that's not where I was going with the question of titus.

Following up on this post answer, titus's comment felt quite reactionary. They were the first person I stated a suspicion of, they were listed in my top 3, and there is a building wagon on them where as my preferred vote is sitting idle, I think it's completely natural that I'd move my vote to them when I did. I was wondering if she was seriously considering me as a scum partner to fire for it.

You asked me a question. I responded. So yes, that is reactionary.

Your timing suggests you were waiting for things to become popular and just naked voted after support arrived.

[Minsc and Boo]

You should know I like to check how my townreads are reading players I feel weird about.
Xkfyu wasn't a random player, he is someone I have an odd feeling about.

It read like "pls produce anti-Xkfyewkf content." I thought I remembered you listing 2 ppl tho which made it more like that but maybe I'm misremembering.

It would be sketchy if a major game topic were my alignment and I hadn't posted, ya, probably (to make the Smudger analogy clearer).

what do you mean "listing 2 ppl?"

[Minsc and Boo]

Do you actually think me + fire is a plausible scum team at this point?

i'd like you to explain why you feel like you&fire isnt plausible after titus answers this.

I haven't thought of the plausibility of a me + fire scumteam in any depth. I think I defended him reasonably hard and in a way that would be weird if I were scum with him (we are thinking too much alike so he has to be town! falls back on me if he flips scum) which does make me think we should be at least a bit less likely, but that's not where I was going with the question of titus.

Following up on this post answer, titus's comment felt quite reactionary. They were the first person I stated a suspicion of, they were listed in my top 3, and there is a building wagon on them where as my preferred vote is sitting idle, I think it's completely natural that I'd move my vote to them when I did. I was wondering if she was seriously considering me as a scum partner to fire for it.

You asked me a question. I responded. So yes, that is reactionary.

Your timing suggests you were waiting for things to become popular and just naked voted after support arrived.

[chamber]

Hmm? I didn't mean your answer felt reactionary, I meant 500

You aren't wrong about the fact that building pressure on you lead to me moving my vote? It's in the sake of reasonable compromise though, it's hardly the first thing I've said about your slot.

[Minsc and Boo]

Hmm? I didn't mean your answer felt reactionary, I meant 500

You aren't wrong about the fact that building pressure on you lead to me moving my vote? It's in the sake of reasonable compromise though, it's hardly the first thing I've said about your slot.

No. That's called testing the waters.

[chamber]

I don't actually know what that means.

[Minsc and Boo]

I don't actually know what that means.

It's where scum float a mislynch, see who is interested, and jump on when support arrives if the wagons go wrong.

[chamber]

Oh, you were responding to that half. I mean, your position doesn't allow for any fluidity in lynches, which is terrible? I understand that in this instance you know your alignment and I can only guess, which is possibly clouding your judgement, but if you are town and take a step back I think you'd realize your stance is ridiculous in general.

[chamber]

What's the actual benefit in doing what I did vs just voting you from the start if that's what it was?

[Minsc and Boo]

What's the actual benefit in doing what I did vs just voting you from the start if that's what it was?

You'd have gathered support and doubtcasting a lynch on scum.

I am willing to consider you as town, but that makes sense to me and that's where I'm at. Rolling with what makes sense.

[chamber]

How do those things not happen if I vote first?

[chamber]

If you are town and have multiple suspects what does that look like and how does it differ from what I did?

[Minsc and Boo]

How do those things not happen if I vote first?

If you would have voted first, you would have taken a stance rather than seeing if it was acceptable to take or not. There wouldn't have been the doubtcasting. It still would have a chainsawy feel to it but not as bad.

I don't understand your second question.