Mini 1811 [Game Over]

[Nahdia]

Votecount 2.01

Tam (2):

Accountant, JaeReed

JarJarDrinks (2):

Impoetic, MURDERCAT

Accountant (1):

iraonavp

Not Voting (4):

JarJarDrinks, Sonrio, Xkfyu, Tam

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline:

(expired on 2016-08-02 23:40:00)

[Xkfyu]

What are the assumptions xk?

As soon as we get the vig claim, I'll explain.

[Impoetic]

UNVOTE: just saw the gunsmith claim and will probably vote tam but I don't really wanna speedlynch before she's posted, esp. since almost everyone's going along with jae for once

[Impoetic]

also now that I'm pretty much clear I can say

o sorry, was channeling ira

nice one!

...without being accused of buddying the IC

[Impoetic]

also I'm of the mindset that vig shouldn't claim unless they're actually highly scumread, in which case they should go ahead and do what xkfyu is saying.

[Impoetic]

Like, say, if Tam is vig. Or Ira, I guess. It would make sense for Ira to be vig with that bad shot + omgscumclaim lulz. If murdercat is a PR that is NOT vig, her claim would make sense, but if she is vig I don't think it does since she wasn't getting lynched today and oh wait

like okay if she only has two shots then yeah go ahead and claim. I forgot that piece of logic lol

[Xkfyu]

also I'm of the mindset that vig shouldn't claim unless they're actually highly scumread, in which case they should go ahead and do what xkfyu is saying.

The vig should absolutely claim, regardless. The difference between being confirmed town and not being a scum read is huge.

Plus, it doesn't matter. They are more than likely out of shots now (or, at most, only have one shot left), anyways. So, not claiming is just unnecessarily hiding information at this point.

[Xkfyu]

Ok, you got there.

[Accountant]

A two shot vig who suspects mafia roleblocker might not claim, but that's the only situations where a vig wouldn't claim today.

[Impoetic]

Yeah I was just thinking PR that could still be useful. I'm a bit of a spaz

[Xkfyu]

A two shot vig who suspects mafia roleblocker might not claim, but that's the only situations where a vig wouldn't claim today.

Ok good point.

[Xkfyu]

But, I still think it's worth it to have the extra confirmed town.

[Xkfyu]

At this point, our advantage lies in our number of confirmed townies. We need to keep that number high.

[Impoetic]

It really sucks that both of our investigative PRs are out/dead though. Like seriously. What does mafia have if we had two of those? We've gotta be at a heavy disadvantage here.

Anyway with 3 mafia are left so Tam can't be the only one. Contestants:
Tam/Son/Acc/ira/Xkf/MUR

There are 3 town and we have a 50% chance of lynching right. (We know Acc, Son and Xkf aren't vigilante already which lowers their theoretical % chance of being town compared to the others for now, but that will change later today.)

[Impoetic]

We also know there's 1 in acc/son/xkf because duh but I'm just assuming son isn't vig actually

[Impoetic]

Fine I guess I was maybe wrong on Sonrio fck it all

[Xkfyu]

Anyways, there is no telling how long we'll have to wait for this, so I'm gonna go ahead and say it.

I think Tam is actually the vig. It's the only possible way that I see that Tam doesn't draw the vig shot. Don't forget also, that she claimed to "welcome" the vig shot. I originally thought that it was because she was scum and, based on her and her buddies roles, she was pretty confident that there wasn't a vig, or that they had a Mafia Doctor.

If I'm wrong though, the real vig needs to correct me immediately, because she either is the vig and I won't vote her, or she isn't the vig, and I won't be voting anyone else.

So, I'm still basically waiting on the vig claim to decide on who I'm voting. If Tam is the vig, then I want to lynch Sonrio.

[Accountant]

I dont buy vig!tam

[Impoetic]

tbh when I read that I was very confused because she welcomed it but not the lynch so I thought vig shot on this site just meant pr visit/being investigated for some odd reason. But yes, I thought there was a good chance she was vig for that too and come to think of it you're right that's totally scummy if she isn't. I remember some people saying she couldn't be PR though, which she objected to adamantly

there's also ira, but eh

[Impoetic]

Why not, Accountant?

[JarJarDrinks]

agree w XKs analysis

[Accountant]

Why not, Accountant?

Call it gut. I thought she was mafia from day 1 and nothing she has done has changed that

[Xkfyu]

there's also ira, but eh

I don't think it's ira. I doubt he would come out and defend his own vig shot, without claiming it first.

[Xkfyu]

Why not, Accountant?

Call it gut. I thought she was mafia from day 1 and nothing she has done has changed that

I completely agree with your point that she hasn't done anything to warrant a town read. The only thing that saves her in my eyes is the vig claim. Otherwise, she's getting lynched.

Hopefully, we'll find out soon.

[Xkfyu]

@Ira

If I'm wrong, and you are actually the vig, you could save us all a bunch of time if you would just go ahead and claim.

There's no telling how long it'll be before Tam comes back to the thread.