Mini 1820 — Lazy Summer Mafia (Game Over)

[Antihero]

So you don't think if a Doc claims D1/D2 the other cc and we lynch through both every time? Like what?

if your setup spec is based on the simplistic and arbitrary premise "there CAN'T be town duplicates" then... yeah ya'll deserved the two mislynches.

[Antihero]

you also lynched your friendly neighbor on day 1 so it looks like town flushed some of the help marquis was giving them with the setup down the toilet anyway

[Antihero]

marquis advertised this mechanic before signups....

[Antihero]

and the night-specific modifier is explicitly normal so... why is it not normal?

[Antihero]

marquis advertised this mechanic before signups....

I was a replacement.

it was in the first round of posts too

[Antihero]

All non-Vanilla roles hold the modifier "Night 2". Other modifiers may exist in the game (in conjunction with "Night 2") if applicable.

what else did you want marquis to do?

[Antihero]

Like If I announced "roles will have flavor" you would say thats not normal, but thats just because of the rule.

...and that's not analogous b/c that explicitly not normal....

[Antihero]

Beacuse it goes against the standard of providing a consistent set of expectations of a game?

what's the "expectations" here?

[Antihero]

what is "the norm" though?

you have to define it or else it's arbitrary

[Antihero]

if your definition is "something that players will see as predictable" then i'm at the same point as infinity to agree to disagree

different players will see different things as "predictable" and i think it limits the mods' design space too much

[Antihero]

no i'm not trying to be clever

if you already recognize there can be two docs then why would they both get lynched?

[Antihero]

what is binding town to lynching both doc claims?

that's not being clever, i'm seriously asking

[Antihero]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=57689
there was 1 town neighborizer 1 scum neighborizer we didn't lynch either

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=55&t=23589
two town millers, didn't lynch both

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=62944
this one's a theme, but i had a nearly identical copy of another townie's role as scum and didn't get lynched when i claimed and got cc'ed

[Antihero]

and as a player, i wouldn't lynch through 2 people just for a claim/counterclaim.

i don't think i'm special. i think i'm average.