Micro 667 - Chosen Mafia (Game Over)

[Mewtaph]

VOTE: Human Sequencer
Seems credible to me.

[Mewtaph]

I think Human is town.

[Mewtaph]

I'm not feeling the nn30 wagon. I liked + agree with their observations on Dave. While I'm not exactly taken aback by the second line of 58 with towniness, in fact it has almost an opposite effect, but I think I can attribute this to cautious townie. I agree with all of the short snippets he's made so far re: Dave and Human.
I'm liking everyone on the Vedith wagon (as of 1.02) for town except for Tenshii.
VOTE: Tenshii

[Mewtaph]

I don't like either of the competing wagons in terms of "I want this guy lynched." level. No one's really vote worthy, but Tenshii was the first person to come out of the gate with a serious vote and reasons for putting Vedith at L-1. I don't like the way he entered the wagon because I don't agree with how he said

his early townreads are there for the sake of buddying

I don't think his posts towards me and Human voting Human calling us town was serious, and far from what I'd call a "buddy" so the reason behind his serious vote starts to crumble.

Yeah, it's not much, but he's basically my only null lean scum read I have currently if I ignore everyone messing around at the start.

[Mewtaph]

@Misa: Reads on nn30 and Vedith?

[Mewtaph]

If you vote Vedith, you might hammer a chosen townie.

Catching up (sorry!)

The thing is

why mention Vedith in particular? nn (the counterwagon) could also be Chosen Townie, and this suggests knowledge of who are Chosen Townies, which mafia only knows.

VOTE: Creature

Yeah... I agree with Tenshii on this one.
Not liking this vote post.
VOTE: MisaTange

[Mewtaph]

Is Creature informing the mod of prod necessities an AI activity? Scum, theoretically, would be content to let things go inactive. Makes it easier to hide.

Yes and no. The prods would happen inevitably anyway, so I'm personally not factoring it into my read.

[Mewtaph]

He says nothing about his read on Vedith in 76, but says he likes everyone on it as town except Tenshii then votes Tenshii. Asks Misa for reads in 113, then sheeps a vote on her in 131 before she answers.

- 79.
- Didn't seem necessary to feelings my read on her. Tenshii's reasoning easily coincided with my own.

[Mewtaph]

Misa has three votes.

Why did you feel the need to point this out?

[Mewtaph]

Prodge. Siteflaked, trying to catch up on all my games. Posts should come in a bit.

[Mewtaph]

Unsure on shadow. Need more.
It's either 'probably town' or 'probably scum' once I work out his personality though, none of this 'kinda' bullshit.

This is too fence sitty. Scum trying to keep their options open.

VOTE: Human

Do you think that it is reasonable to have many strong reads due to how the game has turned out? If no, is there something about Human's "unsure on shadow" read post that feels odd to you?

[Mewtaph]

Misa has three votes.

Why did you feel the need to point this out?

Probably to make sure nobody ends the day early. Derphammers are terrible and antitown at best.

How can someone derphammer with two votes to lynch? This post seems to indicate that you disagree with ending the day early. Why didn't you express this when Human was trying to push for an early Vedith lynch earlier in the game?

[Mewtaph]

So that leaves Creature, Misa, Mew and Shadow as the other scum.
Out of those 4, Creature is the only 1 to really be involved.
Mew I don't like as scum

Why?

[Mewtaph]

Mewtaph is goodposting
Mew is either better at mafia than what I would first assume or town
Mew, who is your greatest scumread atm? Can you give me more details about what you think about tenshii?

Creature.
Tenshii is a weak lean town for me.

nn30 is town.

VOTE: Creature
4 days left till deadline? Lynch this. We aren't losing anything here but scum.
Human Sequencer pointed out that Misa has a meta of sorts, I took a brief look at it, I can get behind it. Taking this into consideration I don't like TTTT as a potential lynch option, at least for today. If you (nn30/Tenshii) can squeeze out some posts from him that somehow incriminate that he's town then sure, I guess, but I think the slot is straight town anyway. So you should vote Creature

[Mewtaph]

Spoiler:

33
Plays along with the fluff.
36 39 48
Prolongs it, himself, with useless questions.
43
Brings the conversation to a crapshoot topic: how inactive the thread is.
17 25 43 64 153 273
Looks like he has a ton of "realization" moments, I first took this as him not paying attention or this being his style or something but it heavily dropped off since early game. Just feels fake... idk how to explain this one, its mostly gut.
214
Bad. We don't know you'll flip town. Again, don't like how he refers back to lurkers.
223 231
Brings the attention back to lurking slots.

• Don't like how he decides to play off the early game start.
  
• Refers to "lurkers" a bunch and puts them in his lynch list. Like, it's just lazy.
  
• Gut.

Never lynching: nn30, Vedith

[Mewtaph]

Guess someone totally forgot I was the lurker at Death Note.

So, lurkers can be scum. Yes, but it's the way that you talk about them that is scummy. It's demotivation. "x, y, and z are useless at heart." is entirely different from saying "This game is going to be so inactive with this playerlist." You say that you have to sort players, but you don't take effort to sort the people that are partaking in the conversation.

You're ignoring any attempt to provide anything meaningful to town discussion, and have never invoked others to do so.
You being active doesn't give you a free pass.