LicketyQuickety's Mini Normal - 1847

[Secret Agent Jin]

Nobody seems interested in talking about 1SVT. Come on Garmr, widen your scope a little bit

.

Alright, i ISO'd 1 shot and he had 17 posts with little actual substance. He was big on TB/Shadow being scum and he talked about Dreal before he was killed, Dreal was a vig shot and Shadow might have also been a vig shot. So either 1-shot is lurker scum or he is a lurker vig. Should we put pressure on him and risk outing a vig or risk letting him go and flipping scum later?

[Garmr]

Judging by the night kills scum are comfortable with their position because the big talkers aren't dying.

[nn30]

Nobody seems interested in talking about 1SVT. Come on Garmr, widen your scope a little bit

.

Alright, i ISO'd 1 shot and he had 17 posts with little actual substance. He was big on TB/Shadow being scum and he talked about Dreal before he was killed, Dreal was a vig shot and Shadow might have also been a vig shot. So either 1-shot is lurker scum or he is a lurker vig. Should we put pressure on him and risk outing a vig or risk letting him go and flipping scum later?

I don't think the 'maybe he's a vig' is enough for me to not want to pressure him.

[Secret Agent Jin]

Nobody seems interested in talking about 1SVT. Come on Garmr, widen your scope a little bit

.

Alright, i ISO'd 1 shot and he had 17 posts with little actual substance. He was big on TB/Shadow being scum and he talked about Dreal before he was killed, Dreal was a vig shot and Shadow might have also been a vig shot. So either 1-shot is lurker scum or he is a lurker vig. Should we put pressure on him and risk outing a vig or risk letting him go and flipping scum later?

I don't think the 'maybe he's a vig' is enough for me to not want to pressure him.

See, my thought process is that even if he is a Vig, he hasnt been talking and interacting much and he needs to be a more proactive member to the town.

If/When you show up 1-shot, please let us know your updated thoughts on the game and explain why two of the night kills were the only players you actively talked about.

[nn30]

@Secret - who do you believe today's lynch should be if not 1shot?

[Secret Agent Jin]

@Secret - who do you believe today's lynch should be if not 1shot?

I believe it should be 1-shot. I also believe we need more questioning of LUV but im nursing a migraine right now and it hurts to even look at my screen. Ill write up some questions when my migraine dissipates.

[nn30]

Judging by the night kills scum are comfortable with their position because the big talkers aren't dying.

Or maybe scum are going for quieter folk in order to not have a NK lead back to them?

[LicketyQuickety]

Vote count 3.1

Pine - Lil Uzi Vert, Garmr (L-2)

1 Shot Vanilla Townie - nn30 (L-3)

Not Voting (4): 1 Shot Vanilla Town, Secret Agent Jin, Pine, PenguinPower

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Day ends in (expired on 2016-12-24 18:00:00)

[Pine]

I've done my ISOs, and am most comfortable lynching 1SVT.

VOTE: 1SVT

[nn30]

What did you learn from your ISOs of the other players?

[Pine]

Well, I only ISO'd 1SVT and SAJ, and neither of them are particularly great. 1SVT seems to be treading water a lot, and my guess is that he's been availing himself of the old scum standby of letting Town fight Town. Me vs Garmr is a goldmine for them. SAJ seems also to be coasting, but there's some effort to gamesolve which may indicate Townishness. In light of that, I'm wondering if 1SVT and LUV are our team, as LUV seems to be the one going for the low-hanging fruit, but any of the three in combination wouldn't surprise me.

[Garmr]

My gut says a active player and lurker player Is scum. The active players probably keeping heat off the lurker and pushing for town lurkers. I feel like luv is probably scum out the lurkers.

[Pine]

Then why the fuck is your vote on me.

Flashwagon on LUV?

[Garmr]

Then why the fuck is your vote on me.

Flashwagon on LUV?

VOTE: luv
Honestly I'm starting to doubt your scum at this point I do want you to be through.

[nn30]

I don't think LUV is scum. Can't really quantify it for you guys - it's a gut feel.

Speed lynch him if you need to, but you can count me out.

[Secret Agent Jin]

I don't think LUV is scum. Can't really quantify it for you guys - it's a gut feel.

Speed lynch him if you need to, but you can count me out.

Im not too sure on LUV either but i could see myself voting for 1-shot very easily.

VOTE: 1-shot VT

[LicketyQuickety]

1 Shot Vanilla Town is being prodded for low activity:

Last Post

PenguinPower being prodded for low activity:

Last Post

[nn30]

Man, this wagon is no fun when 1SVT isn't here to flail for us.

[LicketyQuickety]

Searching for a replacement for PenguinPower:

Replacement request

Kmd4390 replaces PenguinPower.

[Kmd4390]

Hello. Will do some reading later. Anyone wanna fill me in?

[nn30]

I wouldn't want to color your interpretations by doing that.

[Kmd4390]

I've played too much mafia for people's thoughts to cloud my own like that.

[nn30]

I'll give you a summary of how I feel after you've told me your own thoughts on the game.

[Kmd4390]

Fair enough.

[Kmd4390]

Ok, I'm doing this page by page. If things are outdated, deal with it. This is more for me than it is for you guys. I'll have some comments and questions on just about every page. My goal is to get through at least 15 pages tonight. Anything else, I should have done tomorrow night.

Page 1:
I don't like secret agent opening the game with a boring ego post. Why not vote or make a lame joke or something? I'm sure after 27 pages this won't be significant in any way, but I'd have poked and prodded there if I'd played this game from the beginning. He made a real RVS vote in post 18 anyway.

Pine's RVS vote on dreal (flipped scum) feels like he's going out of his way to show that his vote is a joke. Secret agent's vote was the same way and then he avoided voting dreal. Yes, this is weak page 1 crap, but I could see either of those as scumbuddy interactions.

Page 2:
Pine calling dreal guaranteed scum is more of what I saw on page 1.

Can't wait to see where 1 shot's no lynch vote went. His reaction to thinkbig's vote feels town though so consider that my first legit read.

Page 3:
Lil's point about 1 shot trying to prevent discussion is BS. No one actually thinks as scum that they can stop people from talking. That's just not how scum thinks.

Nn seems to be making real attempts to scumhunt and is openly talking about his scum meta. Town points

Wow. Pine got pretty serious in the whole no lynch thing. Lol.

Page 4:
I don't like Pine's OMGUS on josh or his attempt to pin it on nn. I guess this is turning into a real scum read.

Not sure how josh is the only one standing out to secret agent when, as he acknowledges, quite a few people have participated at this point.

Page 5:
This page is all drama around josh and I didn't get anything out of it from living players so on to the next page.

Page 6/7:
Garmr looks town. I like that he recognizes his differences with 1 shot as playstyle and his josh view feels genuine. Also, changing his mind on something while in the shower shows a genuine thought process because it shows that he's actively thinking about the game and his reads even while he's away from it. I've done this at work before.

At this point, josh is obvtown. It should be clear that he thought he was dead when he claimed. Lil not unvoting doesn't look so good. I realize thinkbig (dead town) didn't unvote either, but he's clearly caught in his tunnel.

On a related note, I like Pine's unvote of josh. Maybe I was wrong about him.

Page 8:
Yeah, Pine's dreal vote here reads as legit rather than bussing.

I don't like lil unvoting because of replacement right after a few others unvote. I doubt he's townreading josh for replacing out so it feels more like unvoting because the opportunity to lynch josh is gone.

And I'm through Day 1. Quick break then I'll read more