36 and 40 are pro-town points and inquiries, RK is calling out scummy behavior from karnos.
In post 49, karnos wrote:Care to explain your logic? A guilty is 66% likely to be a true scum. You lynch that every fucking time, it's much better odds than anything else in the game.
it's not about your logic that you posted
it's about what you implied by posting it and the fact that you didn't consider or realize what you were implying when posting it
"I think I no longer believe in monsters as faces in the floor or feral infants or vampires or whatever. I think at seventeen now I believe the only real monsters might be the type of liar where there's simply no way to tell. The ones who give nothing away"
36 and 40 are pro-town points and inquiries, RK is calling out scummy behavior from karnos.
In post 49, karnos wrote:Care to explain your logic? A guilty is 66% likely to be a true scum. You lynch that every fucking time, it's much better odds than anything else in the game.
it's not about your logic that you posted
it's about what you implied by posting it and the fact that you didn't consider or realize what you were implying when posting it
You mean like how you didn't explain your logic when you posted that my behavior was scummy?
I think I see what you are trying to do, and I don't see any reason for town players to do it.
Do you understand what my problem is with your post, or do you not? You argue that I "didn't explain" my logic, yet you also implied that you get it when you say "I see what you're trying to do". Which is it? Do you see why your post was bad?
"I think I no longer believe in monsters as faces in the floor or feral infants or vampires or whatever. I think at seventeen now I believe the only real monsters might be the type of liar where there's simply no way to tell. The ones who give nothing away"
In post 32, rb wrote:If you genuinely think I'm trying to distract you from a target, why are you not voting me? That's a strong scumtell for this early in the game, but you aren't following it? Why?
How would this look to you: "Hey! RB! Are you scum or an idiot like me? Well, it doesn't matter (Votetag)."
I also thought you were at L-2 at the time(maybe the mod counted it regardless?), so me not bringing someone to L-1 should be NAI. SO your premise for me being scum is wrong, thus your seriousness about me getting lynched is ridiculous.
And i also said before that we don't have tacos here, so i don't have an opinion about them.
Btw 28 Was supposed to let me see what kind of person you are, but your disregarding half of my post to call me scum gives me scummy vibes.
So let's clarify.
You thought I was scummy but didn't vote because I was L-2?
But then you say you didn't think I was scummy you just wanted to know more about me? Can you make up your mind?
If the latter by the way, that doesn't make any sense. Why would you say I'm "trying to distract from a target" - is that what you say to people you want to get to know better?
"Hi, I'd like to get to know you better - I think you're distracting me from a target." - Said no one ever.
So firstly you're actually full of shit and secondly you're backing off on something you obviously thought was scummy (but now you just wanna get to know me). Why?
Getting to know you better =/= I want to be friends. I was judging what kind of person you were, so i'd have a better understanding of your actions later on. 28 Was fake, but i did get scum vibes from you in 32.
In post 46, karnos wrote:Has anyone played with RK before? Does she always post like this? Kinda reminds me of killthestory, but spammier and less rational.
I'm just trying to figure out if she is being scummy, or if this is her typical play.
Lol thats the last time I post when tired, apparently 1 mistake is enough to make you a spammier and irrational version of KTS
Reflect on yourself in the heat of passion to reveal what the cold eye of logic sees not.
36 and 40 are pro-town points and inquiries, RK is calling out scummy behavior from karnos.
In post 49, karnos wrote:Care to explain your logic? A guilty is 66% likely to be a true scum. You lynch that every fucking time, it's much better odds than anything else in the game.
it's not about your logic that you posted
it's about what you implied by posting it and the fact that you didn't consider or realize what you were implying when posting it
Did you miss that 40 was pointed out by karnos to be inaccurate
But yeah its like, the fact that u included yourself in that death miller example is so weird, like youre just so COMMITTED to protown play that u have to make sure everyone knows that your setup spec rules apply to you as well
More importantly it makes it sound like you expect to be guilted, when the chances of that happening if ur town is only 20% and not a PR, but you implied u werent by unnecessarily listing the possibility at all
Reflect on yourself in the heat of passion to reveal what the cold eye of logic sees not.
In post 32, rb wrote:If you genuinely think I'm trying to distract you from a target, why are you not voting me? That's a strong scumtell for this early in the game, but you aren't following it? Why?
How would this look to you: "Hey! RB! Are you scum or an idiot like me? Well, it doesn't matter (Votetag)."
I also thought you were at L-2 at the time(maybe the mod counted it regardless?), so me not bringing someone to L-1 should be NAI. SO your premise for me being scum is wrong, thus your seriousness about me getting lynched is ridiculous.
And i also said before that we don't have tacos here, so i don't have an opinion about them.
Btw 28 Was supposed to let me see what kind of person you are, but your disregarding half of my post to call me scum gives me scummy vibes.
So let's clarify.
You thought I was scummy but didn't vote because I was L-2?
But then you say you didn't think I was scummy you just wanted to know more about me? Can you make up your mind?
If the latter by the way, that doesn't make any sense. Why would you say I'm "trying to distract from a target" - is that what you say to people you want to get to know better?
"Hi, I'd like to get to know you better - I think you're distracting me from a target." - Said no one ever.
So firstly you're actually full of shit and secondly you're backing off on something you obviously thought was scummy (but now you just wanna get to know me). Why?
More votes on Charloux please.
rb noah fence but this logic doesnt make any sense and youre missing that charlouxs initial scumread post was a blatant joke
even if youre scumreading him for his tone and responses, which is fine u do you, dont pretend this logic holds water
Reflect on yourself in the heat of passion to reveal what the cold eye of logic sees not.
I'm still thinking rb is town, but yeah that logic is not the best. At the same time, Charloux seems very defensive, but I'm not seeing anything overtly scummy.
Karnos' comments on the Death Miller stuff really do seem a bit scummy though. Including himself in the example could be just a cautious townie move, as it makes him seem more committed to his assertion that all cop scum reads should be lynched. Alternatively, if he were scum, that could be a way to buy a bit of credit. It seems suspicious.
For now I'll keep my vote on culted since they still haven't said anything substantial.
In post 32, rb wrote:If you genuinely think I'm trying to distract you from a target, why are you not voting me? That's a strong scumtell for this early in the game, but you aren't following it? Why?
How would this look to you: "Hey! RB! Are you scum or an idiot like me? Well, it doesn't matter (Votetag)."
I also thought you were at L-2 at the time(maybe the mod counted it regardless?), so me not bringing someone to L-1 should be NAI. SO your premise for me being scum is wrong, thus your seriousness about me getting lynched is ridiculous.
And i also said before that we don't have tacos here, so i don't have an opinion about them.
Btw 28 Was supposed to let me see what kind of person you are, but your disregarding half of my post to call me scum gives me scummy vibes.
So let's clarify.
You thought I was scummy but didn't vote because I was L-2?
But then you say you didn't think I was scummy you just wanted to know more about me? Can you make up your mind?
If the latter by the way, that doesn't make any sense. Why would you say I'm "trying to distract from a target" - is that what you say to people you want to get to know better?
"Hi, I'd like to get to know you better - I think you're distracting me from a target." - Said no one ever.
So firstly you're actually full of shit and secondly you're backing off on something you obviously thought was scummy (but now you just wanna get to know me). Why?
More votes on Charloux please.
rb noah fence but this logic doesnt make any sense and youre missing that charlouxs initial scumread post was a blatant joke
even if youre scumreading him for his tone and responses, which is fine u do you, dont pretend this logic holds water
unless ur his scumbuddy pls dont be a chainsaw it makes it harder to reread the game later
In post 32, rb wrote:If you genuinely think I'm trying to distract you from a target, why are you not voting me? That's a strong scumtell for this early in the game, but you aren't following it? Why?
How would this look to you: "Hey! RB! Are you scum or an idiot like me? Well, it doesn't matter (Votetag)."
I also thought you were at L-2 at the time(maybe the mod counted it regardless?), so me not bringing someone to L-1 should be NAI. SO your premise for me being scum is wrong, thus your seriousness about me getting lynched is ridiculous.
And i also said before that we don't have tacos here, so i don't have an opinion about them.
Btw 28 Was supposed to let me see what kind of person you are, but your disregarding half of my post to call me scum gives me scummy vibes.
So let's clarify.
You thought I was scummy but didn't vote because I was L-2?
But then you say you didn't think I was scummy you just wanted to know more about me? Can you make up your mind?
If the latter by the way, that doesn't make any sense. Why would you say I'm "trying to distract from a target" - is that what you say to people you want to get to know better?
"Hi, I'd like to get to know you better - I think you're distracting me from a target." - Said no one ever.
So firstly you're actually full of shit and secondly you're backing off on something you obviously thought was scummy (but now you just wanna get to know me). Why?
More votes on Charloux please.
rb noah fence but this logic doesnt make any sense and youre missing that charlouxs initial scumread post was a blatant joke
even if youre scumreading him for his tone and responses, which is fine u do you, dont pretend this logic holds water
unless ur his scumbuddy pls dont be a chainsaw it makes it harder to reread the game later
This is now the longest quote period I've ever made.
"I think I no longer believe in monsters as faces in the floor or feral infants or vampires or whatever. I think at seventeen now I believe the only real monsters might be the type of liar where there's simply no way to tell. The ones who give nothing away"
I'm not sold on scum!karnos but I don't like how his reaction in 52 was to try to peg me for some kind of hypocrisy so I'm trying to get more there if/when he answers my questions
"I think I no longer believe in monsters as faces in the floor or feral infants or vampires or whatever. I think at seventeen now I believe the only real monsters might be the type of liar where there's simply no way to tell. The ones who give nothing away"
In post 59, Road Kamelot wrote:rb noah fence but this logic doesnt make any sense and youre missing that charlouxs initial scumread post was a blatant joke
even if youre scumreading him for his tone and responses, which is fine u do you, dont pretend this logic holds water
This also feels like she knows rb is town.
-Logic makes no sense - is that not why we scumread people? lol
-You somehow know he missed the joke and isn't scum misrepping
-Throws the biggest benefit of the doubt I've ever seen like, where did rb talk about tone at all
-Doesn't care if he keeps pushing him but doesn't think it holds water --- what
Like it feels too easy but I think it's just RK + someone who hasn't shown up yet.
In post 70, GuiltyLion wrote:I'm not sold on scum!karnos but I don't like how his reaction in 52 was to try to peg me for some kind of hypocrisy so I'm trying to get more there if/when he answers my questions
He did say he 'thinks' he knows what you're getting at. He doesn't though, because he's probably town, get what I'm saying?
It's a tell. And it's also trying very hard to look like it's saying something but is only saying one thing.
It's the attention to consistency -- look again.
In post 59, Road Kamelot wrote:rb noah fence but this logic doesnt make any sense and youre missing that charlouxs initial scumread post was a blatant joke
even if youre scumreading him for his tone and responses, which is fine u do you, dont pretend this logic holds water
This also feels like she knows rb is town.
-Logic makes no sense - is that not why we scumread people? lol
-You somehow know he missed the joke and isn't scum misrepping
-Throws the biggest benefit of the doubt I've ever seen like, where did rb talk about tone at all
-Doesn't care if he keeps pushing him but doesn't think it holds water --- what
Like it feels too easy but I think it's just RK + someone who hasn't shown up yet.
1-I townread bad logic lol, who scumreads people based on bad logic anymore
2- i dunno if he missed the joke or not im saying it was missing from his analysis and how hes approaching the situation
3- Charloux's tone and responses are scummy thats why i said it, idk if thats what rb is picking up on or not
4- its early day 1 i dont care who pushes who
Reflect on yourself in the heat of passion to reveal what the cold eye of logic sees not.
