Mini Normal 1862 - Town win.

[Gamma Emerald]

I know you're not calling me scum. You're calling me a bad townie, implying that my reads are bad and that I don't know what I'm doing. Which is interesting, considering I'm scumreading you for reasons I clearly have and simply haven't posted yet.
Even if you're town, you can't know if my read on you is bad because I haven't posted it yet. How am I a 'bad townie'? It could be read as scum scared of a competent townie trying to discredit their reads early on.

It's not your reads I'm calling bad, I'm not even sure if you ARE a bad townie yet. I think you may be unaware of something very important.

[-Grey-]

Back to my first choice, I've been on Gamma long enough.

VOTE: Ircher

Define long.

Don't you have access to Google?

[Asphodel]

I called Asphodel Banana man in my post intentionally to see if he'd be more likely to miss it.

If Asphodel truly was 'really excited' to play this game, he would have read my post and realized it was directed to him and responded. Scum don't need to read the thread as intently, they already know everybody's alignment so legitimate scumhunting through posts isn't important to them.

Asphodel could have easily done a quick ctrl-f of his name and responded to whatever he came across.

I think Asphodel truly is 'really excited' to play this game, but I think it's because he finally rolled scum. Gonna have to put that Gamma wagon on hold, along with properly sorting Ircher for now.

Grey is still probably town.

VOTE: Asphodel

So your case is that I'm not actually reading the thread, but instead that I'm just CTRL + F'ing it and missed your post because of that?

I considered responding to your post, but thought that it was pretty self explanatory that I'd be excited for my first game in 6 months. I did the same thing with a post of Naomi-tan's.

But the more important thing is

Gonna have to put that Gamma wagon on hold,

along with properly sorting Ircher for now.

You can multitask.

[Alisae]

Back to my first choice, I've been on Gamma long enough.

VOTE: Ircher

Define long.

Don't you have access to Google?

Why are you avoiding the question?

[-Grey-]

But the more important thing is

Gonna have to put that Gamma wagon on hold,

along with properly sorting Ircher for now.

You can multitask.

Preach!

[-Grey-]

Back to my first choice, I've been on Gamma long enough.

VOTE: Ircher

Define long.

Don't you have access to Google?

Why are you avoiding the question?

Because common sense questions annoy me.

Asking someone to define a word that is not being used in an abnormal manner is just busywork.

[Human Sequencer]

Did you literally just softclaim page 7 of day 1?
Should I just make my first post in every mini 'Don't fucking softclaim'?

>inb4 I'm called scum for rolefishing
Look at that post and tell me that isn't a softclaim, it's so obvious it hurts.

I could be missing something obvious about the setup here, which is what Gamma seems to be implying. If so, would you care sharing that?

@Grey/Ashphodel
Remember when I said I was hoping to see how Ircher responded to the Gamma wagon? I can't do that without a Gamma wagon. Of course I'm still trying to sort Ircher, the aside was just me addressing that.

[Asphodel]

This is what I'm looking for. While I agree with the premise stated here,

I don't think it warrants a wagon in comparison to everything else Gamma has done so far.

Earlier posts make it seem like his defense of Gamma is based on Gamma not having done anything scummy rather than seeming overwhelmingly town.

VOTE: Ircher

how is that even scum-indicative? I really don't get it

Ircher's response to your post is just countering your suspicion of Gamma by saying "but look at all the towny stuff he/she's done so far!" Up until then, I've been getting the general vibe that he thinks Gamma's been NAI or a weak townread. This makes it look like Ircher's defending Gamma for the sake of defending Gamma, not because he's convinced Gamma's town.

[Alisae]

Back to my first choice, I've been on Gamma long enough.

VOTE: Ircher

Define long.

Don't you have access to Google?

Why are you avoiding the question?

Because common sense questions annoy me.

Asking someone to define a word that is not being used in an abnormal manner is just busywork.

Okay then you misunderstood the question. So let me rephrase it. In the context of this game, you said you've been on the Gamma wagon for long enough. And how long is that time period to you?

Also don't like the fact you're not willing to work with me. If anything you're being anti-town at the moment.

[Ircher]

Grey is still scum. And inability/unwillingness to multitask is not a scumtell because it is easier and more effective to try to sort only one person at a time versus doing a half-done job on multiple people.

Pedit: Stop side-stepping the issue.

Pedit2: You had your time to see my response. I stayed off it and said why I didn't support it.

Pedit3: What's not scum is probably town. Again, I already given one instance of what I read as town posts from Gamma.

Pedit4: Another ninja!

[-Grey-]

@Grey/Ashphodel
Remember when I said I was hoping to see how Ircher responded to the Gamma wagon? I can't do that without a Gamma wagon. Of course I'm still trying to sort Ircher, the aside was just me addressing that.

You know how pressure votes don't work when they're announced as such?

Same concept. Make a case on why Gamma deserves the wagon if you want it to be effective.

[Ircher]

What? Did the use of the word "ugly" become a scumtell?

What? Did the use of the word "ugly" become a scumtell?

See? His guilty scum mind confesses in his confusion!

Surprised by my quick deduction that he is scum, he questions how I caught him.

No, that's no slip. I'm asking if "ugly" is said more by town than scum.
BTW people need to post here FAST.

I liked these two posts. Grey stated his responses were humor, but I disagree - he would've stopped with his first response if it was simply humor. Continuing to call it scum posts makes people believe it is serious.

Gamma's reactions were fine -- he is questioning Grey's reads because there dies not appear to be evidence supporting them.

Town posts from Gamma.

[-Grey-]

And how long is that time period to you?

You've read the thread, right?

Do the math.

Still feels like busywork questions.

[Gamma Emerald]

GinNTonic could be a bad townie too.

[-Grey-]

Also don't like the fact you're not willing to work with me. If anything you're being anti-town at the moment.

So?

[Ircher]

VOTE: Grey - Add question evading and literal wording vs. meaning to the list of his "crimes".

Pedit: So it's a much better case than any of the others so far presented.

[Asphodel]

What? Did the use of the word "ugly" become a scumtell?

What? Did the use of the word "ugly" become a scumtell?

See? His guilty scum mind confesses in his confusion!

Surprised by my quick deduction that he is scum, he questions how I caught him.

No, that's no slip. I'm asking if "ugly" is said more by town than scum.
BTW people need to post here FAST.

I liked these two posts. Grey stated his responses were humor, but I disagree - he would've stopped with his first response if it was simply humor. Continuing to call it scum posts makes people believe it is serious.

Gamma's reactions were fine -- he is questioning Grey's reads because there dies not appear to be evidence supporting them.

Town posts from Gamma.

Give me something more than that. This is just him defending himself against Grey's accusations.

[Ircher]

Tell me why that isn't valid. In the end, most posts will end up as null cuz thats just how things work out.

[Ircher]

Gamma is scumhunting, formulating reads on non-bogus reasons (aka I can see reasons for why he feels the way he does) and is cooperating for the most part with everyone else by elaborating when asked and questioning things he does not understand.

[-Grey-]

VOTE: Grey - Add question evading and literal wording vs. meaning to the list of his "crimes".

Pedit: So it's a much better case than any of the others so far presented.

You're really desperate to build a wagon on me, aren't you?

Yeah, no.
VOTE: Grey

Pedit2: VOTE: Gray. Also, those posts were awful. Humor or not, still awful.

VOTE: Grey
Still scum.

How many duplicate votes do you think you'll need before you sucker someone into sheeping you?

[-Grey-]

@Human: See my point, yet?

[Ircher]

The biggest complaint is prob. his posts about discussion not being about things he wants them to be on, but a minor default does not make Gamma not town.

In literature, there are tragic heroes who are characterized by their major fault. That doesn't make them any less a hero, even if it contributes to their downfall. The same applies here with my read on Gamma.

Pedit: So voting you multiple times is a scumtell. Noted.

[Alisae]

Also don't like the fact you're not willing to work with me. If anything you're being anti-town at the moment.

So?

If this is your way of being lynchbait, I don't like it.

[-Grey-]

Also don't like the fact you're not willing to work with me. If anything you're being anti-town at the moment.

So?

If this is your way of being lynchbait, I don't like it.

I'm just making the point that anti-town =/= scum.

[Ircher]

Yes, but that doesn't guve you an excuse to actively try to be anti-town.