Newbie 1769: Happy New Year! (Post-Game)

[schadd_]

hey friends! this is my first game here and fourth game ever (i have played on dominion forum) and i'm town

VOTE: gigabyteTroubadour

[schadd_]

ooh!

2. i like the people at dominion forum but part of the fun of mafia is making character judgments about people you don't know
3. thus far, i have been mafia twice and town once. at this point, i was happy to get town just because of that, but i also like town more because knowing everything is boring
4. i like target-investigative roles, the example here being tracker

UNVOTE: gigabyteTroubador, VOTE: ThinkBig

[schadd_]

_schadd, is your TB vote serious?

mine is

a bit. the questions were all things that i would either say or not say, if you catch my drift

_schadd, schadd_, sch_add are all fine. i'm usually schadd, i think it wanted a non-alphanumeric or something

[schadd_]

i think it wanted a non-alphanumeric or something

oh, nope, i just misunderstood it. which is why none of you have underscores

[schadd_]

how often does the IC get nightkilled, if town? intuitively, they will be the best target for killing a strong town player but also they ought to be kept around, from an etiquette standpoint

[schadd_]

obv was not trying to softclaim tracker, nor softclaim not tracker, etc. that said, i also got the rolefishing impression

Let's get some random questions
4. What is your favorite/least favorite role?

5. if you had to sum up your role in this game in one (1) fleetwood mac song, what would it be?

i've been reading the thread. i don't really trust my townreads, esp. d1 (my first and only town game was a flawless scum victory) so i don't have anything really interesting to say. rn i think creature is town, GBT is kinda town

not taking the vote off of TB for now

[schadd_]

there isn't any way to view all pages in one big stack of html? skull emoji

[schadd_]

(type in dead between colons to be just like me )

yeah. or i could click on the thing on the right side of my screen. skull emoji

also that's a boards of canada avatar right

ye

[schadd_]

i thought it was implicit in:

4. wouldnt you like to know

VOTE: ThinkBig

[schadd_]

woof. also, that's the mod's color, skull emoji

[schadd_]

feels too calculated to me

[schadd_]

we also definitely have less than 14 days

[schadd_]

feels too calculated to me

what, the claim?

yuh. {claim before catching up} {assert against the grain that there can be reasons to claim at l-2} rubs me the wrong way

we also definitely have less than 14 days

splitting hairs, the point is valid even if TB is scum because

Two players yet have to post...

sure

[schadd_]

~

[schadd_]

yuh. {claim before catching up} {assert against the grain that there can be reasons to claim at l-2} rubs me the wrong way

Could you go into more detail for me?

Can I get your analysis on some of the other players too?

sure. claiming at L-1 on d1 is generally an accepted thing (i don't think anyone claimed before that in any of the three i played, except for v special occasions/being especially frustrated) and TB did that; he did it without reading, apparently, but also (implicitly) acknowledges in 150 that you generally need a reason to do it. this seems to me like he just decided ahead of time that he was gonna claim on L-2, which rings a bit scummy to me.

re: other people: creature i'm town on, because GBT is especially confident about it; this seems too ridiculous for both scum and, uh, GBN seems uniquely confident enough about the read to rule out GBN town, creature scum.

GBT earns a bit of a townread just because they're posting very much a lot, not especially dense but not sparse either. at least, they are an especially confident scum player

nullish on you (raskol); interrogating is towny, emotions are scummy. a bit more of the former, tho

gayreen: agh, null. his only voting item was on me; newbie!clumsy!scumhunting is townie, voting me is scummy (+some tone je ne sais quoi that i don't like)

mbg: also null. 4 kinda sparse posts

again, i'm not confident on townreads

[schadd_]

GBN = GBT, whoops. GBN is an acronym for something else that i already know

[schadd_]

1. i mean for me i guess this is valid (i'm more of a quotestripper as scum based on my one game) but some people are good at faking this

2. is anything about my hyperposting genuine specifically?

3. also i think rasks's emotions are very townie, why would they be scummy?

numbers added

1. what's a quotestripper?
2. uh, nothing in particular. there's just a bunch of stuff (almost a third of posts in the thread) and it's more that you haven't screwed up than that you have done anything remarkably genuine
3. i only emotions'd once, as scum. i think it's easy to fake, since people tend to sound silly when they're angry anyway. it surely depends on rask's precedent, tho

[schadd_]

1. i mean for me i guess this is valid (i'm more of a quotestripper as scum based on my one game) but some people are good at faking this

2. is anything about my hyperposting genuine specifically?

3. also i think rasks's emotions are very townie, why would they be scummy?

numbers added

1. what's a quotestripper?
2. uh, nothing in particular. there's just a bunch of stuff (almost a third of posts in the thread) and it's more that you haven't screwed up than that you have done anything remarkably genuine
3. i only emotions'd once, as scum. i think it's easy to fake, since people tend to sound silly when they're angry anyway. it surely depends on rask's precedent, tho

1. Someone whose posts are usually long walls with bits of quotes and responses. Like if I write a big wall, a quotestripper would quote maybe each sentence or two and respond to it (or put a bunch of quotes in one post).

2. .... how exactly would I "screw up"? like outright scumslip or

3. Really? Most people (especially tone readers) usually believe that some degree of emotion is possible to fake as scum, but usually you can tell if someone is being genuine if you know what to look for. Like Rask's emotions feel really natural and reasonable considering their contexts (his annoyance at me saying that his play was within his scumrange probably, his reaction to TB's claim) to me. Scum might react more... obviously? (like they might state "ugh i'm pissed that..." and not really show their emotions as much through tone)

2. i dunno, you haven't done it. i don't mean full screw up, but, like, none of your opinions have seemed fishy
3. yeah, maybe i'm not as good at that as other people. i have scumread many a town for what seemed to me like "ugh i'm pissed that"

i'm used to strategy games where meta is an impersonal term, but i'll use it

voting me is scummy (+some tone je ne sais quoi that i don't like)

Why was voting on you scummy? And what does the stuff in the parentheses mean?

because i'm town, silly. and there is a vague sense of not-genuineness that i get from him, but it's not very compelling

[schadd_]

it makes it scummy from my perspective, tho; maybe you should seem town to everyone else

[schadd_]

ok, well you cant exactly call someone scummy because ,from your perspective, they lynched town (unless cop confirmed). And im pretty sure that last comment wasnt exactly needed? i mean, not everyone will always think im town anyways, and it isnt like you seem like town to everyone else as well...

it's an opinion. i will forever be slightly more willing to vote you than everyone else, and the reason behind that is documented

[schadd_]

if that's still directed at me, uh, sure. i'm familiar with the term. note that voting me once isn't sufficient grounds for me voting you (see: i'm not voting for you), it's just that you're a little bit more likely to do it if you're scum than if you're town. again, from my perspective

[schadd_]

hey. welcome

[schadd_]

it makes it scummy from my perspective, tho; maybe you should seem town to everyone else

why should scum bother to scum read you when they can just kill you? why town can't mistakenly scum read you? You're making no sense.

not sure where those questions come from. all i was saying is that when someone votes for me, it makes them seem scummy to me, given that i know my alignment. the second question doesn't have an answer; town can totally misread me. the first question doesn't make sense to me; if gayreen is scum, he is going to want to lynch a town during the day (which he would try to do by saying he has a scumread on them). he will also want to kill a town during the night.

Why would you vote someone to get them lynched, that soon in the game?

If you have a scumread (you think someone is more likely to be mafia based on their posts and your perception of their motivations), then it's simply playing to win to vote to have them lynched. The only reason, at least to me, to withhold your vote is if you're not ready to end the day with a hammer and claim.

I'm assuming that by asking that, (if this is not true then you can ignore this question) that there's a reason you believe I shouldn't have voted TB in that instant? If so, why?

to add to this, even though it is very unlikely that a townie can be confident about who scums are on the first page, voting is still a good idea. firstly, most games have RVS at the beginning; there isn't really a way to naturally have discussion, especially if everyone is in the same position (not voting, not voted for). voting for people makes asymmetry and gives town something to talk about (which GBT sorta mentioned). as well, it makes you accountable; announcing townreads/scumreads as scum is difficult and unnatural because you already know alignments, and you're necessarily fabricating some reason to want to kill someone if they're town, or not to kill them if they're scum. people are bad at doing this. thus, if i say i think TB is scum for X reason, not only do other people get to talk about the validity of X reason, but also it makes me seem towny because that would have been a (slightly) difficult post to make if i were scum.
incidentally, if somebody avoids taking stances or only parrots what other people say, it will seem very scummy.
hope this makes sense.

[schadd_]

Okay, I'll post my reads as soon the two unexistent start existing.

[schadd_]

although i suppose we haven't really heard from rakkar

[schadd_]

@GBT, rask: how many games have you played?

i feel in a bit of a weird position. GBT can apparently confidently townread half the cast, and neither of rask and creature has really called them out on it. so, uh, we're golden i guess?

i'm gonna evaluate lynches, pretending that we haven't won the game. which is a possibility

TB is uh a vt if he's town, so that's a fine lynch. to me, he seems totally fake, but sometimes i hear people talking IRL and i'm like, you're scum, buddy, and TB gives me the same impression as those people. also, the fact that he colored "vanilla townie" green makes me wanna puke. esp. since it's the mod color, as i mentioned. he still has some posting to do.

rakkar is an uninformative lynch i think. he has posted twice and been talked about.

shade is active and tryna scumhunt, so, a bad lynch. creature is on him, though, and he's town. as far as my read goes, uh, the questions seem hard to fake but there seems to be a bit of a non-linear character progression. i will either explain that later or never.

another option: if GBT is actually that good at reading people, we can just lynch them and then know they're not fudging things up. which is a nagging concern that i have, albeit a small one

gonna stay on TB for now. there is more to be learned and we already know a lot, it looks like

[schadd_]

and yeah i am very easy and enjoyable to mess with

ooh
how to do?

[schadd_]

might we want to pressure lynch TB real quick? skull emoji

[schadd_]

imo the best way to get someone back into the game is to put them at L-1 and then vote them another time

[schadd_]

i would hydra with you but we might already be the same person

[schadd_]

i would like to hear about shade's non-linear character progression though

i asked myself whether i should reread shade and make sure that makes any sense and i decided, nah, i should just say that i might never talk about it again.
what it really boils down to is having an opinion on claiming:

Second I didn't vote Thinkbig for his claim. I'm voting him because I want him to answer "why he claimed".

...while also asking a bunch of questions that seem to reflect a misunderstanding of scum's intentions. there's a super obvious and likely town narrative there (not being/having been scum; understanding that lynch at l-1 after intent is standard/parroting other people's opinions) but it's also stuff that a scum emphasizing newbieness would try to feign

i don't like to overdo this but there isn't anything else going on:

scum to town
thinkbig
rakkar
shade
gayreen
rask
matthew broderblack
creature = GBT
...where "still substantially null" starts with matt and ends with rakkar

if anyone cares, my two games (that matter) (they need a login):
http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index ... ic=16147.0
http://forum.dominionstrategy.com/index ... ic=16339.0

[schadd_]

creature is townread because A: i dont know anyone of these folks and i trust their knowledge of him

what?

notes toward a reads list, p3:

rask is doing a lot of head-nodding, automated yesman behavior. "yeah, uh-huh, yep" with really shallow concerns tacked on.

HMMMMMM

HMMMMMMMMMMM

1: noobtown seems to lean toward the paranoid side. theyd see q4 and dive deep into the ocean of WIFOM madness and decide its best to just pick a role that isnt theirs, or they wouldnt care and the mafia learns absolutely nothing even despite that. certainly no ones gonna ask about vt, how the hell can this be rolefishin since everybody gonna pick a p common role most likely but no ones gonna say vt? scumscuse for anti-town behavior imo

this definitely describes less than all scenarios. this is a mafia forum, and it's probably hard to find if you're completely unfamiliar with the game, but there has probably existed some newbie, somewhere, that would see this post and say something readable about their role. it's really not a large probability, but scum might be able to pick off a PR with little risk, and i don't really see any way the question could add to discussion/hold people accountable somehow.

also noticing a lot of strong townreads from gbT but v weak scumreads, which is a tactic i employ as scum. you have perfect knowledge and you want to hide that, but you also have to look like youre contributing. this guy gets 4 perfect townreads by p4, but doesnt have any good scumreads? yeah no not buying that garbage.

uh, this doesn't make sense, especially considering that several other people are doing the same thing. newbies can be townread pretty easily, and apparently creature can as well.

am more certain after 110: getting bored, no suspicion in their direction, trying to encourage people to read past games so theyll see their town game and get suspicious (and i did). wants to have a chance of losing but everybody tiptoing around the subject and/or sheeping.

this is dumb. you gotta think of things in terms of town narratives vs. scum narratives, i.e., something is only scummy if scum is more likely to do it than town. sure, there's a pretty little reason that scum might do it (which assumes that someone isn't playing to their win condition, which is just not a good assumption) but there's also a super obvious reason town would do it, so that they are easier to read, which town wants to be.

also dismissing softclaims in an overly WIFOM-aware way, smells like S C U M. down to nullscum you go pal

i'm assuming you're referring to this sentence:

obv was not trying to softclaim tracker, nor softclaim not tracker, etc.

firstly, that's not wifom. people asked whether i was softclaiming and i clarified that i wasn't. "not claiming tracker" kind of implies that you're not the tracker, so i added the second part. secondly, how is wifom in terms of your power role scummy? the sole reason you have wifom with respect to PRs is to get scum to nightkill the wrong people.

gbT trying to test the waters with how far they can make people sheep them in 115, seriously now. why was this not discussed? oh yeah because schadd_ legitimized it. S C U M B U D D I E S

115 uh, i don't see it. the third line, maybe? like, you're assuming that they said that thinking everyone is sheeping them, and so they asked me to figure out the gap in their townreads? again, this just makes sense as GBT is asking me opinions on someone they can't figure out.

schadd_; really, i just want you to explain your reads in detail, like, fullstop. theyre not feeling nice to me, im not liking them one bit. convince me you came by them honestly

detail is what i used, as scum, to look like i was doing something. if you say something simple and then link to a post, then the attention is taken off of yourself. to add to this, i don't really have any grandiose reasoning for anyone, but i have given some amount of support for all of my moderately strong reads; you can probably find them if you really want to. i couldn't go through everyone without repeating myself. if you scumread me for that, cool.
incidentally, "theyre not feeling nice to me, im not liking them one bit." doesn't feel nice to me.

[schadd_]

regarding my reads on you: the little bit of WIFOM-awareness in there was like, cherry on top? its not a strong aspect of what im working off of atm. theres also post 53's sheer evil (NAI at /best/ but no town wants to know that for town reasons imo, the best hope is sheer curiosity) and your really strange reads list.

alrighty then.
-again, not wifom.
-53 i dunno what NAI is. i posted that, kinda curious about the etiquette about IC & SE (where i played, there wasn't anything like that & newbies aren't distinct in any official way) and also knowing that somebody would probably have to answer uncomfortably
-mm. i'll have to take your word for it. maybe we disagree on rask because L-1 is easier to shrug off where i come from (it's not like there is any danger really associated with it; if somebody just hammers and then TB flips town, cool, let's go after the hammerer) and GBT because, uh, i don't see why you think they shut discussion down. we have, like, 20 pages here. also linking games about yourself is a bit brash and hard to do effectively as scum.

fuck, let's just go through all of them.
gayreen: you say "everyone agrees obvtown" a lot. i think that he's low on content, and tends to ask "should i do this?" a lot, which is definitely newbie but i don't see it as alignment indicative. i would say that my past reasoning def. wasn't "i don't like him," and i think i even clarified too much why it wasn't that. he voted for me with what i thought was a kinda dumb reason, and then didn't get why i found that scummy.

mbg: asks people for clarification a lot, seems to be reading a lot more than posting, and not drawing attention to himself. this is, i think, marginally more likely to come from town. going from mostly null to calling out an exact scumteam is definitely odd, but he's at least making himself accountable. i think scum doesn't really want to put themselves that much out there.

shade: 320, 365

TB: first line of 180, and 320 has some ~feelings~

creature i'm content to not look too hard into for today.

i havent seen any of your reasoning for your reads. i cant parse the reasoning behind a fair few.

these seem like different things. please feel free to ask me for clarification (and i would ask that you use the post tag)

[schadd_]

This lines up 100% perfectly with Rask's scum play in previous games.

i would say this is only valid if he doesn't do this in town games. he claimed at a point that it's intuitive to do so if he is in fact the tracker

[schadd_]

a lot of stuff from cass strikes me as confirmation bias rather than intentional misrepresentation.

@675: i agree that gayreen was quite low-content and made a lot of easy jabs. the inconsistency in character thing doesn't entirely make sense to me, but i see it regarding his finnicky/unfinnicky voting.

678 scumslip is the word of the day, isn't it. also a lot of this hinges on skimming being scummy, which i don't think is the case. wanting to post soon is pretty towny; scum tends to be more calculated. i guess, more so, it's NAI (which i know know what it means).

eh. i could consider the lynch, though. atm, gayreen is kinda on the scum side to me (i was expecting more to come out of him at my last list, which ofc it never did) and -grey- is angry, and kinda null. townish posting tendencies (simple callouts, responding frequently & self-consistently) but getting a bit too frustrated with cass's arguments (she's done that with, like, everybody, bub)

staying on TB; i want him to be at L-1 when he explains the reads. am v excited

[schadd_]

I guess you could say

people who live in glass houses

shouldn't throw stones

what a weird haiku

[schadd_]

schadd_ began slightly defensive but cleared himself after he realized i wasnt just trying to smash him flat -- i genuinely wanted to be convinced

what happened to that?

re actilurking: uh, i would say that i'm actually just doing the regular kind of lurking. i'm def. reading the thread, but for the last 6 pages i kinda wanted to let grey & cass argue, which has been fun.

readlist concerns are probably valid.

town
creature - dead horse (but watch it be a GBT-creature scumteam)

rask - claimed tracker and hasn't been counterclaimed. plus, tracker is a kind of difficult fakeclaim i think. forgetting this, though, i would put him at null-kinda-kinda-town. claim matches this one (again, needs a login; to quote: "Fuck this. I am the tracker. Move your vote now." the dude was the tracker.) he's also taken the same attitude as me about cass & grey arguing, which is biased. has been emoting a lot, which gets harder to do while seeming consistent, which he has as far as i can find. giving me a full newbie clear in 518 is odd considering his attitude in 563 (and i don't think i should be easy to read)

nulltown
shade - really nothing sticks out to me in a bad way. last time i commented about him i was worried about feigned newbiness, but there has been a steady growth in, e.g., use of the lingo and stuff that makes that seem more difficult to do. not impossible, though. he has also not been that big on reads; i certainly wasn't D1 of my first game but he has been calling out individual posts a lot; this is easier to do as scum than broad reads of a person i think. this isn't very strong, though, and there's def. some amount of scumhunting

null
GBT - well, dipped off a bit in terms of posting, which sorta kills my town-from-posting-a-lot read. 695 seems a bit of a convenient piece of emotionsing, considering such. my prevailing opinion about them now is that they shouldn't be readable D1.

mbg - there's a lot of stuff that reads as newbscum that is afraid of D2. town always has the reassuring knowledge that they're town, and any votes that they do are ultimately justified. as well, as a newbie, i was generally excited to try my hand at scumhunting and wasn't really worried about my reasoning being dumb. i'm not a fan of mbg's hesitance with voting and, recently, tendency to discredit his reads. i'm not sure how his confident reads at the start of the day fit in to this narrative. this all aside, he's been really transparent with his reasoning, and more so as the game progressed.

nullscum, not ordered
cass - wowowow, schadd. she went up to nullscum once she voted you, jeez. but yeah, not a fan. i think that she has gone back and forth on everyone at this point, maybe except shade. she is very talented in the art of choosing a person and cooking up a bunch of scum narratives and slips and whatever. it gets hard to townread that after a while, and it gets less useful as the days progress at the very least.

greyreen - more of a read on gayreen than -grey-, still. there ofc isn't more to say about gayreen since 738. grey is definitely angry, which i think you get good at feigning if you play F2F, but who knows. pointing things out before reading all the way is kinda towny, but i would think he knows that. there's a lot of rhetorical/unanswerable questions which gives me a yucky impression (see 534, 609, 801, 838). it's kinda hard for me to divorce scum from mean and abrasive, so this is more difficult.

tb - still waiting on the readlist, winky face

[schadd_]

grey is definitely angry, which i think you get good at feigning if you play F2F, but who knows. pointing things out before reading all the way is kinda towny, but i would think he knows that. there's a lot of rhetorical/unanswerable questions which gives me a yucky impression (see 534, 609, 801, 838). it's kinda hard for me to divorce scum from mean and abrasive, so this is more difficult.

Those questions are neither rhetorical nor unanswerable. They are pointed. They put the recipient on the spot for a reason.

mm. the one that stuck out to me was, perhaps intuitively, the one that you asked me. 801, "schadd_, why does your ISO read like coasting scum?" and obviously, i mean, i don't really see it, because i'm town. me being able to answer this pulls counter to the sentiment of 842 (though this may have been a rhetorical question, heh). so, it feels like you're just fishing for me to not be able to answer your question.

Scumreading somebody simply because they're not sunshine and rainbows is ignorant. Abrasive play gets more genuine responses than being Mr. Rogers.

yes, and wouldn't it be sunshine and rainbows if that was the basis for my read of you

[schadd_]

doing 880 later

[schadd_]

1 cleared my original concerns, yes. there are new ones,and some old ones, and my concerns arguably should have been addressed better by you originally.

2 did you see 876? it's a very good read. from the time i entered the game this has been a concern and it keeps going that way. you keep dodging scrutiny. may or may not be related, but lets live on the edge and just flatly claim that it is, unsupported by evidence.

3 and you sure are hyperdefensive. vote for you = scum instantly? why? why is scumreading you scummy? and where is your scumhunting behavior? scumhunting is natural to town even if it gets pointed the wrong way once in awhile

4 why is your vote the same exact vote as post #7? why has that not moved? its safe to say the wagon has stalled, in fact, on multiple separate occasions. do you really believe in that vote that much? do you truly have that much conviction in it? where do you get that conviction from a 23 post ISO which is devoid of content?

5 why is this second readslist substantially identical to the first aside from "gbT went inactive" "shade is uh something lets call it nulltown" "i actually have an opinion on cass and its mostly because she voted me and tries to aggressively scumhunt"? why would gbT taking a day or two off (because thats all its been, really) instantly drop them to null? why does it seem like you cant form an actual opinion on shade and so you just throw that slot in nulltown? indeed, from your description, why not just null? why are all your reads weak and without conviction?

6 how the hell are 801 and 838 unanswerable or rhetorical? mbg managed to answer 838, which is the exact opposite of that, and -grey- has pursued and asked followup questions to all of your examples. er, except 801. because, well, you havent even tried to answer it to begin with, just thrown your hands up and said "impossible! must be rhetorical." why dont you want to answer?

numbers added

1. cool

2. uh, i don't have especially a lot of townreads. creature has a thing, gbt i think is unreadable rn, as i said (i could lynch them on a different day, feel free to hold me to this), rask claimed. outside of them you see a kinda nuanced list.

as far as dodging scrutiny, what in particular are you referring to? beating a dead horse but you do have a tendency to throw stuff at the wall and see what sticks, and there's a lot that i don't think is worth responding to/don't really understand. what do you think is your strongest criticism of me?

3. mm, not instantly. if you're talking about how i'm reading you, there's other stuff.

what counts as scumhunting? i point out what i don't like.

4. why should it have moved? a 23 post iso that is devoid of content sucks. i've continually wanted him to come back with votes on his head, he never has, and that makes me want to keep the vote there.

5. uh, the people are the same people, still. except for the two that switched out, who are, granted, in the same place but with different reasons. tb has provided no reason to change the read, creature isn't gonna move, rask claimed. so, now there are 6 spaces to switch around, and they kinda did. gbt is not in null because they took a day off, but how, as somebody (rask? but can't find it in his iso) pointed out, posting a lot isn't as impressive if you like playing scum.

as far as the last part, uh, that is where we play this game differently. you can't actually know who's scum day 1. i only played the one town game but i have read through a lot of other ones, and i've been wrong enough times that having "conviction" just sounds dumb.

6. elaborated on why 801 is bad in 894. he's asking me to explain something that he is reading in me

[schadd_]

grey is definitely angry, which i think you get good at feigning if you play F2F, but who knows. pointing things out before reading all the way is kinda towny, but i would think he knows that. there's a lot of rhetorical/unanswerable questions which gives me a yucky impression (see 534, 609, 801, 838). it's kinda hard for me to divorce scum from mean and abrasive, so this is more difficult.

Those questions are neither rhetorical nor unanswerable. They are pointed. They put the recipient on the spot for a reason.

mm. the one that stuck out to me was, perhaps intuitively, the one that you asked me. 801, "schadd_, why does your ISO read like coasting scum?" and obviously, i mean, i don't really see it, because i'm town. me being able to answer this pulls counter to the sentiment of 842 (though this may have been a rhetorical question, heh). so, it feels like you're just fishing for me to not be able to answer your question.

I'm fishing for you to justify your play, which you aren't even trying to do.

Attempting to redirect my question as a reason to scumread me isn't going to make me go away.

i don't really want you to go away.

do you see the issue, though? the way that i naturally approach this game reads badly to you. i don't really know what about me reads like coasting scum. my skill in mafia is making connections between things people say, building/remembering characters, and uh math on occasion. prodding at people and arguing, not so much. my habit is to wait for people to argue things out and then find what's fishy. maybe that ends up sounding like actilurking or something, i don't know. adding on, you said it yourself, D1 is dumb, things will make more sense to me later on.

dunno if this is what you're looking for

[schadd_]

why does it seem like you cant form an actual opinion on shade and so you just throw that slot in nulltown? indeed, from your description, why not just null?

forgot this

...because i feel slightly town on shade, all things considered? it's ultimately kinda gut, as most reads are, but he did a reasonable swath of town stuff (pointing out some inconsistencies, having some opinions) and asked questions about scum motivation, and there was increasing reason to believe that he wasn't feigning it.

[schadd_]

See schadd online. Hi Schadd!

hi

[schadd_]

^also bbcode for schadd_ since i'm like 100% he'd use this reaction picture too

i know bbc, and am not generally interested in reaction picturing this game

So far schadd_ is the only possible counterclaim to Rask.

not ccing

i still think schadd_ did not address anyones concerns and that i really, really want to hear more from him soon on them.

l0l

Wouldn't mind seeing cass claim.

i stand by my rask read (i.e., superscum)

Vanilla Townie

l0l

my reads were crap

l0l

(though tb looked p undeniably like scum)

do you really believe in that vote that much? do you truly have that much conviction in it? where do you get that conviction from a 23 post ISO which is devoid of content?

fuuuuuuck off

[schadd_]

VOTE: cassielle

[schadd_]

Also very good points schadd.

thanks mom

[schadd_]

im really, really confident of that read though. even though theres literally no point in it. can we drop it? like, for real.

i don't think i need to say it again

[schadd_]

Cass already claimed, I'd take her out of hammer range for now.

mm.

[schadd_]

pedit: schadd_ is townposting

are you calling our town shit?

[schadd_]

If there's a BP in the game they should probably claim, though.

uh, scum doesn't necessarily know whether it's doc or bp yet, but presumably they shot you

incidentally, are you saving the tracker result for something? feel free to not respond

good night

[schadd_]

agh, do i have to?

[schadd_]

G'night!

[schadd_]

also schadd i gave u the bbc in case you phone post so u dont have to upload to imgur but if it's not ur thing i feel

l0l

[schadd_]

for a minute there i thought maybe we could actually scumhunt properly (yknow instead of trying to pick the easiest player to build a case on when QED all of our townreads are messed up) but im p sure most of town is going to take that deal in 1096 because im easiest target

only issue is that im gonna flip green

im standing by 1092

im also gonna say that ... TOWN: regardless of your opinion on his reads: RadiantCowbell's post 1095 is /mandatory reading/
there will be a /test/
seriously, reread that post until it is burned into your brain
your town block contains one or both scum
you need to lynch them before you run out of MLs
today is the best time but im willing and ready to go down as a martyr on this so you can get it right d3*
again: you are townreading scum, period

*-this is partially because somehow and i dont know how, i have no credibility here anymore, so ive given up on being able to save myself. its not MyLo or LyLo so idc too much.

i have thought about it for 29 hours and determined that this post is meaningless

[schadd_]

I have only once been wrong on a townread of this nature and it was on someone who basically stalked my mafia play for months to understand how to beat me.

this sounds like a lie

The answer to where you're wrong, assuming town, is that Creature knows exactly what you're looking for to townread him and did exactly that.

mm. especially considering:

early game I don't like to give reasoning for most of my actuons because it helps develop my reads

...and i vaguely remember them making some other argument about hiding that sort of information (maybe with cass?) that i can't find

speaking of grey

i'm kind of curious how he's actually reading me

With my EYES!

fart off

That said, I'm likely to sheep RC if Cass flips scum because no way does scum enter the game power-bussing the way RC came in screaming for cass' head. He's pretty much conftown when she flips red.

that whole most cunning manipulator accolade isn't really doing him any favors, though

[schadd_]

I did some digging and it would be insanely uncharacteristic of Grey to replace in and hard bus a scumbuddy.

So what would be characteristic?
Even though you can't bring up examples, you could still summarize it right?

I don't bus.

It's a stupid tactic that is overused when a little dancing could avoid a scum lynch 99% of the time.

that's not real

[schadd_]

Spoiler: quote

I did some digging and it would be insanely uncharacteristic of Grey to replace in and hard bus a scumbuddy.

So what would be characteristic?
Even though you can't bring up examples, you could still summarize it right?

I don't bus.

It's a stupid tactic that is overused when a little dancing could avoid a scum lynch 99% of the time.

that's not real

Your face isn't real.

my avatar has 3 faces and yours only has 1

[schadd_]

Preflip associatives are trash, people.

First, flip scum. THEN find their partner.

in sorta the same vein as the bussing thing, dunno if this is real

@schadd_ this is what i meant by me being fun/easy to fuck with earlier in the game i think

mm yes. i can tell because of the skull

[schadd_]

im considering your wagon. it looks juicier than schadd_'s about now. what the hell?

lord

[schadd_]

when i got weak reads and then this comes out of nowhere i guess it isnt that hard to overshadow your wagon

but keep in mind that since the start of d2 ive been considering yours most highly of all schadd_, so its a p big change from my side of things lol

it's less that (though that's silly) and more that "juiciest" is evasive and you're spooked by your own read

[schadd_]

-grey-: i'm leaning town. we have someone on dominion forum that's very similar (argumentative, likes to tick people off, pulls shit like 1131) and he is more helpful and easy to deal with as scum, to the point of being a tell. obv they're different people though, but that's the parallel that i have

i could go for a creature lynch. i guess there isn't really strong reason to believe me but i was sorta feeling uncomfortable with him through d1 for uh other reasons that he voted for me (you can kinda see i just stop talking about him in readlists, and i went from "he's town" to "he's not readable today probably" around the same time as i did so with gbt) (it went sorta the same way i feel about toni morrison: good thing i know that she got an award for being a good storyteller, because otherwise i'd be pissed). assuming it's not gigabyte/creature, i can totally see him noticing giga's read on him, totally not acknowledging it at all, and proceeding to try to seem engaged; his d1 iso is a bunch of one-liners, kinda dime-a-dozen opinions, and general opinions of the game as a whole; not a lot of reasoning on reads. not like there isn't a town narrative there (one of our better town players is sorta similar), but it fits cleanly as an inflating-y scum. assuming it is a giga/creature team, l0l

UNVOTE: cassielle, VOTE: creature

[schadd_]

and creature and cassie schadd_?

?

[schadd_]

Giga, isn't Grey like conf scum now?

nop. my guy that i'm comparing him to will do that thing, addressing someone as scum, while being like "nah they're town." it's still possible to be scum that forgot his reads tho

[schadd_]

literally every slot in this game that isn't conftown is what i call a "frog-in-a-blender" read

constantly moving at 500 mph

red and green. red and green.

gah

[schadd_]

nop. my guy that i'm comparing him to will do that thing, addressing someone as scum, while being like "nah they're town."

As a joke or being serious? Because it didn't look like Grey was joking.

1190 doesn't seem like joking/not joking; grey just likes to get under people's skin, and it might be a post that he makes still thinking creature's town. a third person yet that i'm thinking of from dominion forum does this as well; he called a scumteam of me and two other guys (when, incidentally, the three of us were scum) and crafts a silly narrative with it, then puts me as his highest townread next post.

[schadd_]

l0l

gonna talk this evening

[schadd_]

wall

1345 is a bit of an odd way to start an especially confident scumread, pinning it to someone else

I wish I had actual meta on some of you guys

i posted my games [nervous anime face]

Schadd lies here

lol

his team mate would be a bad lynch, because he's active and trying to scumhunt when he only had 7 real posts, and most of those posts like contained basic questions about the game.

this is so obviously misleading; he had something like twice the word count as you at the era of 320, and only about 4 fewer posts, having replaced in. ditto for the latter part; you even used the word "contained"

Shade saw there was a ton of pressure on Schadd with him being at L-2, and had no idea how to react so he just flaked.

or, you know, maybe he couldn't keep up with the pace of the game and might try again when his current project finishes.

uh, the rest of the post is you describing how events happened under the assumption that we're scum. "he feels it gives him a bigger chance of winning" is especially hilarious because it's by definition true for either alignment

creature isn't really deflecting because no one really prodded him for anything. disengaged, though. and i think he has a lot of nai "i usually think" sorts of things as well as "this feels towny," which in excess reflects negatively on an experienced player as far as i've found

He dug himself in a hole saying that Schadd is obvious town and the only way out of it was to hammer ThinkBig.

908 is 20 minutes before the hammer. the assumption you're making is that he dipped in, impulsively townread his partner, then realized aw crud that's a dumb idea.

whats everyones thoughts on 1442

kinda town in the obvious sense that scum only doesn't want to get lynched, but mbg probably knows that and i've put thought into doing the same thing when i was scum

holistic mbg read: reverse r kelly. that is to say, my mind is telling me yes but my body is telling me no. so, deciding both days that your reads are correct and you win, having them be completely different between, having one of the ones on d1 flipping town and one on d2 being me, sucks farts. but agh. there is a town thing behind it. see, both days he did it after we started to stall: d1 it was after we all townread each other & decided not to do anything until everyone had posted, toDay there isn't really anything waiting to happen and we've had a few irl days where nobody really posted. i can see town mbg wanting to get something going and dumping his livelihood into some reads that he has.

but agh. that doesn't really make sense given that he's willing to die for the reads. i mean, the case to me seems pretty obvious and i think that it's generally pretty weak (not gonna put words in people's mouths but i get the impression that's the consensus) and mbg seems savvy enough to notice that. so maybe there's my thoughts on 1442 v2

[schadd_]

having read a small amount of bee movie mafia just now i think there might be a very small chance that it doesn't count for fuckall

[schadd_]

also shit you mentioned the thing at the hecking beginning of that game too

[schadd_]

...but that is a creamy-ass p-value

[schadd_]

gosh he reads pretty similar in that game to this one; a lot of asking questions, not really explaining reads at all (he pointed to a post one time but then said "this just solidifies my read"), commenting on gamestate. and, incidentally, initially scumreading tb but then townreading him at the end of the day. and also, incidentally, claiming somebody solved the game d1 at the beginning

...but that is a creamy-ass p-value

i can do a statistically accurate test to show that post count is alignment indicative for him btw (i think it's like a p value of .002 of it not being AI)

yes i saw. creamy af

[schadd_]

Schadd lies here, and says his team mate would be a bad lynch, because he's active and trying to scumhunt when he only had 7 real posts, and most of those posts like contained basic questions about the game. Really since when is 7/320 posts active and scumhunting? This is just a blatant lie.

Well to me it seems like Shade is more likely to flip town than ThinkBig just because of the questions, and points that shade has been bringing up. Shade really does show a drive to scumhunt, and I don't think he would be asking these types of questions if he were scum (Although I do not really know his personality outside of this game) :

[schadd_]

i reread, u guys!

[schadd_]

i also promise

[schadd_]

dang, i already promised

[schadd_]

as long as we're sitting around

rc, what's the deal re: saying you're an alt? the second link in your sig says i'm not authorized

[schadd_]

thanx

[schadd_]

how do you feel about this wagon, you like where its heading? you like the folks on board? where do you think the other scum is?

the last few things read like scum giving up. town mbg cares enough to, like, talk about anything

creature noticeably absent and hasn't really commented, but he maybe hasn't been on for the good parts. grey is watching, which is fine, he does that (obv softclaiming watcher for him). everyone else is here

uh, still don't like creature. you, also. you changed today, from member of angry mob to reporter on the whole angry mob issue

mbg flips green, we weep

[schadd_]

schadd has been lurking (yet no one called him out for it besides me) most of the time.

i don't think that's true

[schadd_]

yup

[schadd_]

If you object to this, tell why Shade was towny.

Well to me it seems like Shade is more likely to flip town than ThinkBig just because of the questions, and points that shade has been bringing up. Shade really does show a drive to scumhunt, and I don't think he would be asking these types of questions if he were scum (Although I do not really know his personality outside of this game) :

[schadd_]

"This means that you can be mafia as well? I was assuming it's 1 newbie/1 SE team, isn't it?" pretty obviously newbtownie but still is
"What gave you the impression that someone is going to hammer you soon?" @ TB
"why should scum bother to scum read you when they can just kill you? why town can't mistakenly scum read you?" @ me for not liking that gayreen voted me (i don't really get what his thought process was but i think that's townie in this case)
"what is POE ? Point of elimination? If you hate that why you used it last page when you started striking people?" is scumhunty. helps that you're pretty high on my scumlist

a bunch of other stuff like that. it is ultimately a holistic and intuitive read, because i can read through his questions and nothing stands out to me like "no, you don't have an excuse not to know that" or something. that's kinda hard to do i think

[schadd_]

really? dang

[schadd_]

re: mbg

would you agree that once he essentially got a majority behind him, he stopped helping at all? if so, should that not read as quite the scum?

[schadd_]

4th q: maybe we think scumhunting is different things, who'd've thought

he called out a contradiction he saw, which is a good

this is a reply to both cass and creature

[schadd_]

mm

remind me not to mislynch you, then, creature, if we meet later

[schadd_]

with tracker, lynching red >>>> lynching interesting. is creature red?

[schadd_]

Well, imma put him at L-1, if thats ok

[schadd_]

UNVOTE: creature VOTE: mattblackguy

[schadd_]

i forgot how town gayreen was tbh

i don't see the thing that i quoted as town (funny, rather. humorous)

[schadd_]

am vomiting rn

[schadd_]

i dont think creature will die tomorrow regardless of your flip

nk, you mean? he seems like an obvious lynch if mbg is redguys

[schadd_]

sure

[schadd_]

He can't claim doctor.

hi, welcome to the thread. what?

[schadd_]

how big of a deal is that? you guys seem less concerned than me

[schadd_]

no, like, the thing where a wrong account posted here. i mean we don't do alts at dominion forum but that's the sorta thing that gets modkilled

[schadd_]

ok good to know

[schadd_]

see, it's a newbie game. we're learning things.

[schadd_]

spanish flea

[schadd_]

[aloof anime face]

[schadd_]

i know a father who had a son
he longed to tell him all the reasons for the things he'd done
he came a long way just to explain
he kissed his boy as he lay sleeping, then he turned around and he headed home again

[schadd_]

why would we want to agree that

[schadd_]

i guess what i meant is why would we want creature to be green if mbg is (though partners seems pretty likely)

[schadd_]

lol yes we can.

they are scumpartners schadd.

If they're scum partners, why would Creature tie himself to Matt right before Matt's flip?

lynch mbg -> lynch creature is already seeming like the course of action; scum creature wants to raise questions (like yours from just now for example) so that such doesn't happen

[schadd_]

wifom is the short answer

[schadd_]

mbg might as well have flipped

[schadd_]

you also preflip association'd just now, except in a different way

[schadd_]

If mgb flips scum, let me talk a little tomorrow before lynching me.

by the nature of the game, this can never happen

[schadd_]

you can accomplish this by hammering, just a thought

[schadd_]

ok

[schadd_]

sorry, quoted the wrong thing

If mgb flips town, I am town and voting me is a scumclaim.

that can never happen

[schadd_]

Definitely don't buy this "creature-mbg" scumteam though.

I'm not buying it either

u don't have any fucking money

[schadd_]

If you do not claim a track on him I am autovoting him and not posting until he is dead.

but i like it when you post [blushing anime face]

[schadd_]

can you lynch mbg though? i implicitly agreed that today has been going on for too long a little bit ago

[schadd_]

aaaaaa

[schadd_]

si se puede

[schadd_]

fie

[schadd_]

lord. i was gonna jump on him today, mostly for 1684 and skipping the part where you defend him vigourously to the part where you get towncred. but, well, that's dead. at least i didn't draft a big ol post on it, which i considered

[schadd_]

and it is telling us when day 2 ends

[schadd_]

gonna wait for rask to post before i talk reads in case there's a guilty

shouldn't the opposite be true? accountability &c

[schadd_]

those are both very good points.

i'm also just happy you're alive and well

[schadd_]

oh?

[schadd_]

anyway, back to square 1. grey, why does your iso read like coasting scum?

[schadd_]

VOTE: Grey

babe!

[schadd_]

that is a babe that is a combination of "omg baaaaabe i didn't bother ppeing and we were thinking the same thing" and "omg babe don't fucking vote"

mostly the former i guess

[schadd_]

dont want to influence the nk

not sure i follow

[schadd_]

well, uh, that's gone then. i don't know what theatre is

[schadd_]

yeah i think the argument is definitely a place to look. at least, an "ego fight" should be easy to fake in theory

[schadd_]

anyway, well, my scumread of cass never really died. dumbfounded silence is dumb, at least one of the several of us that started talking just now has to be town, and we were not in dumbfounded silence

anyway, back to square 1. grey, why does your iso read like coasting scum?

You can say I did a lot of things, but coasting ain't one of them.

I shoved the Matt lynch down people's throats. That's the polar fucking opposite of coasting.

no, matt did that. it was really a huge point of agreement, actually, other than creature. i think that if you consider that your big thing you did yesterday, then you were coasting

incidentally, i want to call someone a cunt before the game's over but it should surely wait for a good time (wikipedia describes it as one of the few words left in english with shock value)

[schadd_]

incidentally, i want to call someone a cunt before the game's over but it should surely wait for a good time (wikipedia describes it as one of the few words left in english with shock value)

Telegraphing your intent nullified the shock value.

not if you forget about it. and i'm glad you addressed that part, then brushed away the other stuff that i said. i mean, mbg was town, perhaps recall. egging on a mislynch that everyone pretty much agreed on after he hail mary'd and then locked the fuck up; i don't know what else coasting scum is.

not an easy argument to make. i can predict his posts -- both roughly what is going to get his attention and demand a response, and roughly what that response will be. ill read a post and say "greys gonna show up here soon", see the avatar and say "and its gonna be along the lines of x" and be in the ballpark every time

mm. i think i'm missing the town part.

I initially liked cass' posting day one, it looked productive and seemed to vibe well with my own thoughts.

l0000000000000l

l0l0l0l0l0l0l0l0l0l0l0l0l0l

ahahaha

[schadd_]

my one-liner mnemonic for d1 is that cass and grey were eventually able to overcome their differences and vote me

[schadd_]

If Cass was scum, I'm pretty sure I'd have been a priority nk simply because of our d1 interactions.

but you layed off of her

i'm going to see how genuine i think the interaction is once i can reread

If you were scum and I came after you the way I went after Cass d1, would you leave me alive and simply hope I didn't get another hair up my ass?

idk. they did that with me no problem. and rc. i mean, it would not hard to realize cass is a dangerously easy lynch this game. in fact, she would be such an easy mislynch if it weren't for tb and mbg

[schadd_]

how often is RC wrong about 3 scumreads in a row?
is BoP fair here?

I was wrong about 1 scumread.

i suppose he means TB (which i think you said was a slightly preferable wagon rather than a scumread), mbg ( ) and creature (the "i knew he was doctor" coulda been post-hoc)

you're saying that though like a cassie wagon would have been a permanent vanity wagon

yeah, from my experience in dominion forum, hers is not the kind that remains in limbo very long. though i guess there's longer days here

schadd_, are you scumreading anyone who isnt me or grey

id just ask for top 3 but you made us the top 2 so

there are four people at all that might be scum. you are asking for my top 3 out of 4 people. suffice to say, i don't think i have reads anymore, i just have an opinion that might change with results and a reread

[schadd_]

and schadd_ and cassielle as a team is... lol...

[stock photo of uncomfortable guy holding up both hands as if to say "no thanks"] + [tornado]

[schadd_]

his shitposting bothers me and he seems to be kinda happy we're in mylo

it's less happy and more of the feeling of "well, now we know what needs to be sorted out" after you pee yourself

[schadd_]

schadd_ i was asking to try and get a better opinion of you, what reason do you have to not share your best answer at the present time ffs

the first part is the most generic reason to ever ask a question in this game. the second part is uh, you and grey seems like way the most sensical scumteam (is that what you meant by best answer?). other than that i would say rc is a tad scummier than gbt. am currently rereading to get any sensible ranking of scumteams

[schadd_]

It's just frustrating the people I want the most from I get the least from

is this me?

sorry, i was doing the heal/fos thing and i kept circling around the same few reasons for them and so i decided to just dive into rereading

anyway, now marks the time where i noticed your result and, uh, fuck me.

solemnly swear i was going to fos: cass and heal: rc. thus far my reread has eliminated several now irrelevant teams. (gbt/rc from 218, 262 and i remembered rc said to lynch cass and track him the one time, which is tooooo clumsy if you didn't have a crystal ball to see mbg lynch)

this has been in a tab for a while as well:

Lol, you guys are saying 772 was theatre? That was probably the first scumteam I ruled out and I'm not making the same mistake as I did with matt again.

it seems to me like a lot of generic mafia argument. aah i'm so frustrated i can't convince you. aah i'm so frustrated you're misunderstanding/misconstruing my posts and that you think i'm doing that to you. i'm done with you, other people pls weigh in

[schadd_]

don't lynch. we have stuff to do

[schadd_]

rusjdiejehdud

dvorak?

[schadd_]

yeah, def. don't lynch anytime soon, please

[schadd_]

oh fock off

[schadd_]

rc has had a female avatar for maybe 88% of the game, gbt accepts "she" for esl. i'm a detective

[schadd_]

rc has had a female avatar for maybe 88% of the game, gbt accepts "she" for esl. i'm a detective

Your avatar looks like a close up of a used maxi.

so does your role pm, cunt

[schadd_]

rc has had a female avatar for maybe 88% of the game, gbt accepts "she" for esl. i'm a detective

Your avatar looks like a close up of a used maxi.

so does your role pm, cunt

Yup, no shock value.

Sorry!

i guess the result took it away. and maybe how i nabbed you at the beginning of today

[schadd_]

schadd_ how do you feel about a grey/gbT pairing? im not seeing any reason not to treat that as the true scumteam from where im at

gbt townread gayreen where i didn't at all, plus it would make a lot of sense since they were doing that with all the newbies

[schadd_]

u did it first, and cass's reasoning doesn't matter. hi-oh!

[schadd_]

if i'm really honest, i was in a bit of a daze some 20 minutes ago, and now there's a mountain of confusion and stress that i don't get to have access to anymore

[schadd_]

I am 1-shot bP.

stop

[schadd_]

#TeamShitpost

weoooooooooo

i need to fucking sleep or do some other thing

[schadd_]

if i ask in the morning, tell me i got to 270

[schadd_]

oh, also, cass/grey is the only team where grey does the kill

[schadd_]

votestump: grey. though he's fighting quite admirably

[schadd_]

you have not seemed like a scum that likes playing scum, and you like playing scum as far as i can tell. between gbt and cass, cass seems scummier on pretty much every front. she mutually buddied with grey, she scumread me beyond usefulness, and for so many of her reasonings she just described an elaborate thought process, which seems more like an intent to look difficult to fake than to actually affect other people's thoughts. gbt posted a heck of a lot, and to this day i can't really find any particular caveat to the fact they are generally transparent and accountable. i'm still in the process of rereading the game and both of their ISOs.

to some extent, my reads are now "how impressed am i if this is your scum game?"

rc: wowowow. fukken nice, keep the scummy i guess
gbt: you're quite industrious
cass: i mean, i couldn't help but feel it pretty much the whole game.

[schadd_]

i'm also being a Good Dude and trying not to pay any mind to the modslip

[schadd_]

oh also there's rakkar. a name we haven't heard in a while

[schadd_]

in other news, doctor/tracker seems buuuuuusted.

[schadd_]

skull emoji

[schadd_]

being perfectly honest, after -grey- let up on me i was determined to NOT read that slot. that was not fun for me and i didnt want to be put in a position of scumreading him and getting another face full of angry

this seems largely in contradiction with 1817. if you've downloaded him, i should generally think he is less frustrating/saddening to deal with

[schadd_]

in other news, doctor/tracker seems buuuuuusted.

not to belittle rask though. hitting grey was clever

[schadd_]

i think now marks the time i largely stop mentioning/addressing cass and GBT; i probably shouldn't have even posted my reads. rc i will still talk to (in spite of grey's best interests. what you're doing is cool, but ultimately shouldn't be doing you any favors)

when to end today? rask, how much more do you want to say

[schadd_]

i guess i didn't say i would stop talking to you. are you an alt?

[schadd_]

no. but thanks for asking

[schadd_]

i'll see what i can do

[schadd_]

man. if nothing else i got him at the start of today

[schadd_]

thanks

[schadd_]

although, now that i think about it for about an hour, maybe i can't say it came out of left field; rc got it about 30sec before i did

[schadd_]

track rc tonight

[schadd_]

ok

[schadd_]

those two things might be connected

[schadd_]

can we finish toDay? rc and rask, is there anything you want from me?

[schadd_]

VOTE: -grey-

[schadd_]

i've spent most of toDay reading and all of my not-meh is in a notepad document at the moment

[schadd_]

i've spent most of toDay reading and all of my not-meh is in a notepad document at the moment

Are you saving it on purpose or?

no i have been accidentally not posting it skull emoji

NLing in this situation just hurts town because I don't expect Schadd to be able to properly read into the wifom of the nightkill if I die.

:c

i'm not nolynching out of the gate, which i think is the expectation. toMorrow is the day that we scumhunt, and by that i mean RC scumhunts and i notice some things and then paste a pile of think into the thread at some point. i'll nolynch at the very end so i can get reassured that it's not rc, i guess

aero: what happens in the event of repeated nolynch -> nokill? do scum have the option of no kill?

[schadd_]

I think that if I get a read worth pushing Schadd to follow me on that he will follow me on it or vice versa.

[schadd_]

why should you get to hammer? it's not like you tracked him

[schadd_]

catch you on the ~flip~ side rask

[schadd_]

If I get lynched here somehow I am going to be really sad.

that's generally how it works

[schadd_]

aw, wish you were here started playing

[schadd_]

[schadd_]

excited 4 the flip!

[schadd_]

aw, rask became a sad

[schadd_]

no

[schadd_]

ok

[schadd_]

no comment

[schadd_]

plead the fifth for about an hour

[schadd_]

i haven't stopped pleading the fifth

[schadd_]

hey look i'm town

[schadd_]

i'll do it with rc later

[schadd_]

powervoting anyone who talks about a mod thing again

[schadd_]

Schadd if at any point you are expecting me to vote Cass you are going to need to do more than.

notepad document

[schadd_]

i'm here my darlings

[schadd_]

should i, though?

[schadd_]

we have so many fun endgame things to do

[schadd_]

wanna hammertest? or something

[schadd_]

i'm not in an especially productive state of being right now, for a few reasons

[schadd_]

???

why would i want to hammertest you

[schadd_]

No, I want you to contribute reasons why you think that Cass is scum over GBT.

you're not allowed to want me to do things yet

[schadd_]

i don't see myself doing anything other than hanging out here for another while. notepad document isn't caught up thru day 3, nor curated at all. and my shoulders are too tense from {other thing} to finish it.

how are things going, you guys. RC, what % gut would you say your read is right now?

[schadd_]

maybe i just want cass to come in and have another case of the vapours after seeing i'm town

schadd_ have you read casserole's masterposts now knowing that grey is scum?

oh, have i

[schadd_]

masterpost theatre