In post 418, cassielle wrote:im on board with most of these, but imo post 53 schadd_ is pure evil, its a quiet way of asking "is it a good play to off the IC for mafia?" like, the best you could say is NAI, to me it comes off as ultrascum
i asked a similar question when i was town in my newbie game, i don't see it as AI honestly
the idea of an IC is kind of strange at first but having one around is like training wheels. by the time D1 is over you don't really need the IC any more and the SEs can usually pull their weight
In post 419, Creature wrote:In post 148, gigabyteTroubadour wrote:is that town i'm not sure honestly
The bigger your personal townblock is, the less you'll accept other townreads.
yeah basically but
usually in the early-game if i see something that pings me as town/genuine i just call it town, if I find something scummy i call it scummy. if that ends up in having more of one type of read then i re-evaulate
didn't really get a vibe one way or the other from
225. i realize there's the temptation to call it a townslip but it's kind of a cheap townslip to intentionally go for for newbiescum, but i don't get the vibe that means he legitimately thought that the scumteam had to have an experienced player and a newbie. I like casserole's read on it that it could be a newbie frustrated that they rolled scum with another newbie but that shows how many angles you can really come up with. it's just a meh post that doesn't ping me.
Creature, what do you mean by "harsh" in
437?
Casserole, if the general vibe is to follow me, wouldn't that insinuate I'm town? Like I suppose I could just be really influential scum, but the table seems decently smart here and capable of coming up with their own opinions. I don't see "follow giga" happening if they're my scumbuddies (i'd tell them in the PT to try to think of original thoughts and that's backed up by my last game), nor do I see it happening if they're all town and I'm scum. I'm going to look more into this once I finish catching up.
dont really agree with casserole's point on rask not crossing himself out but it is kind of funny.
creature what about my meta seems different here in
463? significant changes in posting style aren't AI for me and my town and scum games are constantly going to look and feel different depending on my mood.
honestly what irks me most about rask is that he doesn't townread GAYreen but I don't know how much of that is playstyle vs. AI
yeah
471 i get the rask scumreads now. still feel a good deal of emotional engagement so i'm probably just going to straight up reread the game but i think i'm only comfortable with {Grey, Casserole, Creature} townreads now, maybe schadd_ too.
472 is a good vote though...
can't really tell what rask is thinking about casserole page 20.
489 is a good post imo. can go into detail but i'm not really vibing with cassie's scumread of this slot
dw
492 should always be implicit
@Shade, you can always declare a V/LA for a couple of days if something like that comes up again (or you see this)! anyway, I'm not exactly following what you find scummy about GAYreen's reaction to the claim, could you go more in-depth?
don't really think the reasons cassie brings up
497 to sr mbg aren't alignment indicative, like i don't consider him a lurker and i felt his early posts had a genuine tone to them but i'm probably rereading that slot too
499 are my thoughts exactly. @TB, The best way to deal with pressure is to just contribute, trust town to find town. if you can't keep up mentally then i would definitely suggest replacing out, i've done it before in a similar situation and i won't think anything ill of you if you do.
i can vibe with
503 at this point, though i don't really feel as strongly about the scumreads (i never do tbh) so i'd say they're all about equal.
In post 517, ThinkBig wrote:{S}Schadd
{S}Cassielle
i would definitely like to hear more about these...
on
526, creature getting that "conftown" read was more from my understanding of his meta. vibe with the TB read. GAYreen read seems a bit shallow/simplistic but i can see it coming from town. actually had the same thought on casserole (too many scumreads) but like conviction wise and just how much she needed to break up the kumbaya it's obvtown. worth noting that in a tb/rakkar world that doing what cassie is doing is TECHNICALLY the optimal play i highly highly highly doubt that that's what she's trying to do.
i still think matt's town tbh
yeah my posts are shit lol cassie
don't think
536 was a scummy answer, calling the whole thing a circlejerk i think did answer the question but
agreeing with
545 and that's basically why i've been townreading mbg. same with
563.
((just saw the tracker claim here))
actually i still need to sit and think about the claim and it kind of compromised my catch up (i just woke up like an hour ago and i have to go back to sleep so uh)
i'll just post this now
Raskolnikov wrote:Fuck you too. "Top townread" and you don't defend me at all, don't see you anywhere and you appear the moment I claim.
dude you guys are posting like crazy and you've never been my top townread??
like give me some time to catch up i just woke up