Newbie 1769: Happy New Year! (Post-Game)

[Creature]

So far my PoE indicates schadd_, -Grey- and RadiantCowbells. I think we're more likely to find scum there.

I think RC is most likely town from here.

Thoughts on them?

[Creature]

tbh schadd_'s been pretty quiet, sorta remembers me of rJXr.

Meanwhile, I think Grey v RC contains scum.

[cassielle]

i agree with schadd_

i dont buy mbg being town and i dont see either of -grey- or rc being scum

id like to see explanations for those reads.

[mattblackguy]

i agree with schadd_

i dont buy mbg being town and i dont see either of -grey- or rc being scum

id like to see explanations for those reads.

So you think I'm scum with schadd? lol Alright I'm down. Let's lynch him today. Rask tracks me/RC then we win tomorrow.


And Rask my other possible scum teams involve Giga, and looking through their ISO I'm just not feeling as strongly about them flipping scum anymore.

[cassielle]

im not wholly sold on schadd_, creatures just as likely there from where im at

you on the other hand are near 100%

this vote is staying put

[Creature]

VOTE: schadd_

[Creature]

you on the other hand are near 100%

Okay it'll be hard.

[cassielle]

sorry, but i want an in depth defense of mbg's slot being townread before i even consider a different path here, because i dont see any defensible townread of him

if you can knock down, lets say any three of my arguments from 1418 ill think about dropping that read. i make at least 6 arguments there and i think theres 4 i would be swayed on if you can come up with almost any convincing town reasoning for them, so i mean, this shouldnt be hard at all if youre really solid on that mbg townread and it isnt a plain gutread

until then scum is scum and im here to lynch scum

[mattblackguy]

Okay it'll be hard.

It really shouldn't be. Either we lynch scum today or I get lynched and you guys lynch scum tomorrow. (you, rask, giga, and grey are going to need to knock some sense into cass tomorrow though)

[Creature]

mattblackguy - Town
GAYreenHamster - Town
Shade - Town
rakkar - Mafia
schadd_- Town
Raskolnikov (SE) - Town
ThinkBig (SE) - Mafia
gigabyteTroubadour (SE) - Town
Creature (IC) - Town

So did we win?

This is like the craziest thing to say.

Also, his reads are more believable than most of others.

[cassielle]

yeah its crazy to say. its also exactly what everyone else was saying at the time, just not quite as strongly as that

[cassielle]

also wrt his reads he has a gamesolve readslist when no one else is that solid on their reads?? one is ONCE AGAIN effectively a lurk slot and the other is widely scumread because of an unpopular hammer, making them both fairly easy lynches to push?

im not seeing that

[mattblackguy]

@creature, @rask, @grey If I get lynched today will you lynch RC/Schadd tomorrow? Because I'm not worried as long as you guys will lynch a scum tomorrow. I just don't want you listening to RC/Schadd and following his Cass/Creature/Grey push tomorrow.

Because you know after I'm lynched he's going to push this for the final mislynch.

[Raskolnikov]

It wasn't out of the blue. I said earlier that RC/Schadd were in my top 3 scum teams.

And there was no Eureka moment. Just the way Schadd/Shade interacted and the how RC has been acting since he joined the game.

What's your offsite experience like matt?

[Raskolnikov]

Fucking quotes always giving me trouble

[mattblackguy]

Does it matter?

[cassielle]

checked my notes

IF mbg flips town (im pretty sure he wont) then rc and schadd_ are top of the list anyway with grey and gbT as runnersup based on his posts to date

i will call this bluff

imo: lynch mbg. in the incredibly unlikely universe where thats a townflip, track rc or schadd (rasks pick) and lynch the one most likely to have been nk based on rasks info
if it flips red, others dead

i can live with this

[mattblackguy]

IF mbg flips town (im pretty sure he wont) then rc and schadd_ are top of the list anyway with grey and gbT as runnersup based on his posts to date

Thank you I just didn't want my ML to be for nothing.

[cassielle]

whats everyones thoughts on 1442

[mattblackguy]

My thoughts on it is no one will listen to me until I'm dead so kill me and then listen to me and win the game.

[cassielle]

yeah im asking everyone else though, lemme see a couple replies here

[cassielle]

in fact

UNVOTE:

i want day to keep going until i get an opinion from every slot on 1442

full stop

[Raskolnikov]

Does it matter?

If you have any faith in the system at all then more info should generally be better than less

But if you don't want to that's okay, it wouldn't be ethical to force something like that out

[Raskolnikov]

idk cass it kind of reminded me of what you said earlier when you were getting wagoned

[Creature]

idk, if we mislynch today it's very unlikely Rask will track a kill (if he doesn't die before).