In post 975, Desperado wrote:if you had flipped scum there would only be one scum left, max. any more would mean we started with an SK, three group scum, and a two man survivor team, which means it would have been 7 v 3 v 2 v 1
ps i dont trust anything you say. your information suggests it was two man survivor team + sk + one scum + three other third parties (four if you go by what you said originally), which means it would have been....6v2v1v1v1v1v1(v1)?
lol
In post 976, SnarkySnowman wrote:I mean you assume I don't think it's ridiculous? Come on now :/ m
My guess is there are only 4 town (based on Narnas claimed info) and it's more like 4v2v2v1v1v1v1 or something silly like that. Clearly this is an extremely bastard game, do you expect it to follow normal proportions?
okay I'm gonna need you all to wake up to facts that are right in front of you.
Roles were
not randomly assigned
. Obviously.
The setup is
not normal
. Strong odds it's
not even balanced
. It has a shit ton of factions, whether or not Snarky is telling us the truth, a shit ton of
killing roles
,
(secret double votes, possible influence by dead players, mid-game changes at mod discretion, ???), possible (unconfirmed) lynchers. Some players have extra info.
If you're lynching based on expecting this game to be normal you're gonna have a bad time. You're going to get fucking steamrolled.
My interpretation? The setup isn't designed to be normal. It's designed to be fun (which it is) and give us all a chance to play the perfect game, where we have the roles and mechanics we all wanted, according to the questionnaire. The only exceptions are when strict adherence to the questionnaire would make things less fun.
There's symmetry here -
Mason, one or more weaker info roles
Mason Vig, one or more weaker vig roles
That symmetry makes me say, okay. I know we have a mason vig and another limited town vig. That's two. Then we have another mason and
four
additional info roles including a cop, watcher, and questionnaire info roles. That's SIX. And despite this number, almost none of them actually got any info last night! WTF
I'm sorry but this
doesn't compute
.
So, wake up already. We should either be lynching in that group OR lynching based on behavior without consideration of roles. Which might be the best idea, and from my pov still points toward the same players. (Not a coincidence.)