WWE Mafia - RAW (OFF TELEVISION)

[Kmd4390]

*shrug*

I try not to look at associative tells while both players are alive. If one of them flips town, that work was all for nothing. It also creates a bias in the sense that one townflip makes you realize you were wrong and you question the accuracy of your other scum read.

I'm also townreading mcmenno.

But if we lynch malpa and he flips scum, I'll gladly entertain that case.

[MathBlade]

Yes, I've never once questioned the slot and never will. I've never been more confident on a read in my entire mafia career than I am on pep being town.

Go back and look at thinkbig's reaction to mcmenno's shot again. He clearly shows that he knows mcmenno shot town. It's a stretch to say that that makes mcmenno scum, and it's bad logic on thinkbig's part, but you can see that that's what he truly believes. In thinkbig's mind, mcmenno shot town so he's scum. Then he can't believe that no one sees it and he replaces out. It was poor play, but it was obvtown. People tend to suspect poor play as scummy play, but that's because they refuse to try to get inside the player's head. Why, as scum, would a player who believes they are dying anyway inisist that they player who shot them was scum and do absolutely nothing else even when the shot is stopped? That's town who believes scum shot them.

If he knows who is Town and who is scum that makes the person who knows Think Big scum. Pep replaced Think Big.

I don't see how you get a townread off that.

Math - I didn't quite follow. What I hear Kmd saying is that ThinkBig's response was a response from someone who knew they themselves were town and being attacked. Think Big then assumed that the attack must be coming from scum (although if Town, he couldn't actually know it was scum.)

I don't see what you are saying because of what is in parenthesis.

[MathBlade]

*shrug*

I try not to look at associative tells while both players are alive. If one of them flips town, that work was all for nothing. It also creates a bias in the sense that one townflip makes you realize you were wrong and you question the accuracy of your other scum read.

I'm also townreading mcmenno.

But if we lynch malpa and he flips scum, I'll gladly entertain that case.

Malpa will not be lynched. Move on to someone else.

[McMenno]

not sure what to say, really stumped this game

say would anyone be up for a kmd lynch

[Kmd4390]

*shrug*

I try not to look at associative tells while both players are alive. If one of them flips town, that work was all for nothing. It also creates a bias in the sense that one townflip makes you realize you were wrong and you question the accuracy of your other scum read.

I'm also townreading mcmenno.

But if we lynch malpa and he flips scum, I'll gladly entertain that case.

Malpa will not be lynched. Move on to someone else.

If I were ready to compromise, I'd go you or columbo first and then mcmenno. I'm not touching Almost or pep.

[MathBlade]

VOTE: Knd4390

Almost and Kmd scums for the wins.

[Vince McMahon]

Vote Count 4.03

Ms. Columbo

(0/4)

-

Pepchoninga

(1/4)

- McMenno

Kmd4390

(1/4)

- MathBlade

Almost Chara

(0/4)

-

McMenno

(0/4)

-

MathBlade

(0/4)

-

Malpascp

(0/4)

-

Not Voting:

Ms. Columbo, Pepchoninga, Kmd4390, Almost50, Malpascp

Notes:

-

(expired on 2017-02-11 12:20:00) until the end of Day Four.
With seven alive, it takes four to lynch.

[Kmd4390]

Math, are you just gonna scum read anyone who suspects you? lol

[Almost50]

Math, are you just gonna scum read anyone who suspects you? lol

'nough said!

Also, re: a McMenno-Malpa scum duo, I'm not sure anymore. I strongly believe I have been Town reading a scumster, but WHICH one? I don't see a scum!McMenno in his play this game, and I'm not sure about Malpa either.

Now to put them both on the same pot w/o having something solid to go by is a bit too much for me. Don't forget I was responsible not for one but TWO mislynches already, so I confess I lack the confidence to pass judgements and enforce them at this time.

[Ms Columbo]

Yes, I've never once questioned the slot and never will. I've never been more confident on a read in my entire mafia career than I am on pep being town.

Go back and look at thinkbig's reaction to mcmenno's shot again. He clearly shows that he knows mcmenno shot town. It's a stretch to say that that makes mcmenno scum, and it's bad logic on thinkbig's part, but you can see that that's what he truly believes. In thinkbig's mind, mcmenno shot town so he's scum. Then he can't believe that no one sees it and he replaces out. It was poor play, but it was obvtown. People tend to suspect poor play as scummy play, but that's because they refuse to try to get inside the player's head. Why, as scum, would a player who believes they are dying anyway inisist that they player who shot them was scum and do absolutely nothing else even when the shot is stopped? That's town who believes scum shot them.

If he knows who is Town and who is scum that makes the person who knows Think Big scum. Pep replaced Think Big.

I don't see how you get a townread off that.

Math - I didn't quite follow. What I hear Kmd saying is that ThinkBig's response was a response from someone who knew they themselves were town and being attacked. Think Big then assumed that the attack must be coming from scum (although if Town, he couldn't actually know it was scum.)

I don't see what you are saying because of what is in parenthesis.

Rephrase: Think Big automatically assumed McMenno was scum but was not in a position to actually know McMenno was scum.

[MathBlade]

I am scumreading people making dumb arguments.
There is 0% chance Town has a gladiator and a vig and <redacted>.

A50 gladiated me as soon as I suspected him and panicked.

Pep and Kmd are crazy for suspecting me a Town vig.

A50 and Kmd need rope.

Exactly my point which makes Pep my backup if either are wrong. Assumes facts not in evidence.

[Kmd4390]

So yes?

[MathBlade]

It is more than that. *glares* Read my ISO.

[Ms Columbo]

I am scumreading people making dumb arguments.
There is 0% chance Town has a gladiator and a vig and <redacted>.

How is Massive as town-gladiator on SD and masons with 2 (conditional) day-vigs, any less powerful or possible than what you just described?? The SD roles are 100% FACT. The assertion that there is a 0% chance of something comparable on this brand defies common sense.

[malpascp]

I am scumreading people making dumb arguments.
There is 0% chance Town has a gladiator and a vig and <redacted>.

How is Massive as town-gladiator on SD and masons with 2 (conditional) day-vigs, any less powerful or possible than what you just described?? The SD roles are 100% FACT. The assertion that there is a 0% chance of something comparable on this brand defies common sense.

Shhh Math is always right ok? Ok? Don't question Math's logic unless you want to be scumread too

On a side note if McMenno is scum and wins this game I'll be very pissed. JUST GIVE SOME READS OR SOMETHING.

Also if Math actually thought people who make dumb arguments are scum then he'd be voting for Pep.

[MathBlade]

I am scumreading people making dumb arguments.
There is 0% chance Town has a gladiator and a vig and <redacted>.

How is Massive as town-gladiator on SD and masons with 2 (conditional) day-vigs, any less powerful or possible than what you just described?? The SD roles are 100% FACT. The assertion that there is a 0% chance of something comparable on this brand defies common sense.

Reasons. Of which are derived from planetary bodies which are true but no one understands.

[malpascp]

I am scumreading people making dumb arguments.
There is 0% chance Town has a gladiator and a vig and <redacted>.

How is Massive as town-gladiator on SD and masons with 2 (conditional) day-vigs, any less powerful or possible than what you just described?? The SD roles are 100% FACT. The assertion that there is a 0% chance of something comparable on this brand defies common sense.

Reasons. Of which are derived from planetary bodies which are true but no one understands.

...

I am scumreading people making dumb arguments.

...

Nuff said

[MathBlade]

That is part of it. To understand you gotta read my entire ISO.

[Vince McMahon]

Holy shit. How did I miss Pepchoninga being V/LA?

I take responsibility for this huge fuck up, especially since I've sensed something was really missing, but couldn't figure what.

I'm giving him a V/LA and if he doesn't respond in 24 hours, I'm replacing him.

[malpascp]

There's no way this is LyLo, right?

[McMenno]

On a side note if McMenno is scum and wins this game I'll be very pissed. JUST GIVE SOME READS OR SOMETHING.

I did

this is where I end my post

nah I have given some though I forgive you from not distilling extreme wisdom all the time from my crypto fu posts.

I'd like to like pepchoninga first and foremost. kmd as well. after that? you and ms columbo. between almost and math, I'd choose to lynch almost. but I don't think it'll come to that

[malpascp]

ffs my brain is screaming that you're scum and I wish I knew why

[McMenno]

because I am

[Kmd4390]

There's no way this is LyLo, right?

Very unlikely.

[malpascp]

How likely is it that scum is lurking at this point?