Mini Normal 1873 (Game Over)

[ThinkBig]

@Garmr, how do you know Alisae is town?

[ThinkBig]

I think scum is between Alisae/Garmr/BBT. I really don't like BBT's hammer. He has contributed very little to the game.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Lies.

[ThinkBig]

Truth.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

More lies.

[BlueBloodedToffee]

Alisae is today's lynch.

Am I the only person surprised that All Alone died and Real G&T are still alive?

[ThinkBig]

All Alone was a surprising kill. Though the fact that he had a power role shows that the scum team probably detected him. I fully support lynching Alisae today.

VOTE: Alisae

<<< Fixing broken vote tag. >>>

[ThinkBig]

VOTE: Alisae

I hate phone posting

[PranaDevil]

Looking at BBTs ISO, I could see an argument in them being scum, next to no discussion, no actual contribution to discussion. However two thing make me believe he's not scum. First, he was on karnos early, and had tons of time and options to get off that wagon and go elsewhere, especially with so little contributed, it wouldn't be hard for him to argue jumping to another wagon to get off a buddy, he didn't, therefore I don't believe BBT would be scum with karnos.

Second, the sudden hammer of LQ, I'd accept a quick hammer from scum in LyLo or MyLo, but not that early into day 2.

Put together, and I'm not feeling BBT as scum.

Garmr, you are solidly behind Alisae being town, and you've provided no reason as to why. Now I'm reading you as confirmed town at the moment, so it leads to the question... why? You say Alisae has done worse as town in the past, that's all fine and dandy, but why is he not scum now? These aren't situations where Alisae changed an opinion after re-looking over everything, or coming to a better conclusion (see: My change in stance regarding him believing karnos was obv. town when he was clearly getting away from the wagon), they are literal opposing views. Karnos is town, but is also a great lynch... this has not yet been explained. Preparing to hammer karnos, but wanting to use two more weeks of discussion... again, how does that prove they are town? It doesn't... but it's great evidence they are scum.

What doesn't help is you trying to keep the lynch off Alisae so much, yet never giving an explanation beyond "he's done it before". That's not a legitimate argument, and Alisae needs to be todays lynch without fail. We screwed up yesterday by lynching LQ after getting distracted from obv. scum, and I see no reason for us to do the same today. I'm all for looking at others and using the day phase t the best of our ability, but I want Alisae lynched, like yesterday.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Alisae is today's lynch.

Am I the only person surprised that All Alone died and Real G&T are still alive?

You are not the only one surprised.

I'm going to go ahead and claim now as my death is pretty much in the near future.

I'm another town JOAT, I have a a Cop/Gunsmith/Neapolitan shot and used the first two.

ThinkBig is 100% town, hence why D2, I was saying how much I loved Thinkbig so incase I die, I had crumbs to hint at who invested.

I used the Gunsmith on BBT, he is also clear.

The Neapolitan shot, I really don't know the use for but hell I got it.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Scum is most likely In shannon,think big and/or BBt. Alisae has down worse shit as town in the past and I can see alisae doing this as town.

2/3 are completely wrong. I'm starting to feel like the 3rd would be wrong as well.

[ThinkBig]

Shannon is a strong town read of mine. That clears BBT. Thanks for clearing him as I was unsure about him.

[ThinkBig]

Now that you pitted your results, Garmr is even more of a scum read

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

What is the possibility that I was kept alive over All Alone because I sided with Garmr yesterday? If I was doing a great service pushing mislynches, I could see it likely being that I was kept alive due to myself being easily manipulated into getting whipped into the read they wanted.

That's assuming a Garmr/Alisae final two scum team.

[ThinkBig]

I think we will learn a lot from Alisae's flip. I'd Alisae is scum, then I want Garmr lynched. No ifs ands or buts

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Although I'm more than happy to abide by that, I'm going to wait for Pep.

<<< If this is another request for a Pepchoninga replacement, I will point you to my edited response in 1023, as well as 1131: I cannot replace a slot unless either the slot itself asks for replacement, or it fails to pick up a prod. I cannot prod a slot until 72 hours after day's start. Day has lasted, as of this edit, 13 hours. Pepchoninga would not be eligible for a prod for 69 hours: (expired on 2017-02-06 16:58:09). If day is still ongoing when that meter expires, Pepchoninga will be prodded. Not a moment sooner. >>>

Also, I must give a thousand apologies to Lexa. I am become error.

[ThinkBig]

LQ was widely scum read day 1 and was probably pushed by scum. I think you probably should have investigated him day 1

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

I town read him so freaking hard tho, I knew in my SOUL that he was town and then Garmr told me why LQ could be scum and I liked the smell of it and took off lol

[Garmr]

Alisae is today's lynch.

Am I the only person surprised that All Alone died and Real G&T are still alive?

You are not the only one surprised.

I'm going to go ahead and claim now as my death is pretty much in the near future.

I'm another town JOAT, I have a a Cop/Gunsmith/Neapolitan shot and used the first two.

ThinkBig is 100% town, hence why D2, I was saying how much I loved Thinkbig so incase I die, I had crumbs to hint at who invested.

I used the Gunsmith on BBT, he is also clear.

The Neapolitan shot, I really don't know the use for but hell I got it.

UNVOTE: think big

that good to know still it irks me that he has the audictiy to accuse me of being scum.

[TheRealGin-N-Tonic]

Who is scum now?

[ThinkBig]

Let's try and form a solid town block and try to eliminate possible scum mates from the remaining pool.

@Garmr, I still think you are scum. Sorry.

[Garmr]

I town read him so freaking hard tho, I knew in my SOUL that he was town and then Garmr told me why LQ could be scum and I liked the smell of it and took off lol

Also fuck you for putting all the blame on me. I am town I don't know who's who i can only guess. If my case didn't make sense then lq wouldn't of got lynched. It's LQ on fault he played bad.

[ThinkBig]

I town read him so freaking hard tho, I knew in my SOUL that he was town and then Garmr told me why LQ could be scum and I liked the smell of it and took off lol

I began to town read him mid day 1. That's why I try to stick to my gut reads.

[Garmr]

Let's try and form a solid town block and try to eliminate possible scum mates from the remaining pool.

@Garmr, I still think you are scum. Sorry.

Knowing your town only makes me fucking angry at your shitty case.

[ThinkBig]

I town read him so freaking hard tho, I knew in my SOUL that he was town and then Garmr told me why LQ could be scum and I liked the smell of it and took off lol

Also fuck you for putting all the blame on me. I am town I don't know who's who i can only guess. If my case didn't make sense then lq wouldn't of got lynched. It's LQ on fault he played bad.

I think we still learned information from the LQ wagon and his flip.

Also, why do you still have Alisae as town?