[Game Over] Open 673 - Tit for Tat
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
Congrats Bella even tho I don't know you!
Tho you broke the chain of votes, I'm dissapointed in you!
Also Charloux, I swear I won't be bad at the video game this time.
-Ali- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
UNVOTE: BellaphantIn post 28, Bellaphant wrote:i haven't rqs-ed since....my first scum game!
i generally say scum, but i've flaked a few games and just wanna play a decent town game.
VOTE: Intermission
I also find it ironic that intermission asked the math phd a math question
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
Because you two are scumbuddies.In post 26, The_Jester wrote:@Inter why no questions towards me? I'm feeling left out
Saving this for later.
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
or maybe I was wrongIn post 31, The_Jester wrote:
ThisIn post 29, Charloux wrote:
I like to think that preserving your cards is essential in mafia regardless of alignment, so i consider this question kinda bad.In post 22, Intermission wrote: theplague42: What's your usual Day One strategy to sniff out scum?
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
I don't like you OR jester calling it out.In post 39, ECMitchell wrote:I liked seeing The_Jester call this out as well.
It's something so easy and opportunistic to call out
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
If I'm pointing out Sesq's instance, I must point out Charloux's as well.In post 39, ECMitchell wrote: I find it interesting you felt the need to highlight your first vote during the RVS as, indeed, random.
I liked seeing The_Jester call this out as well.In post 18, The_Jester wrote:Why do you feel the need to underline the fact of random voting?
I used that as well, but since i was first on the list, i decided to vote for someone else.
Neither case is particularly a scum read; both are certainly jovial. Just something to notice[/quote]
This progression is gross.
"interesting you random rvs'd"
"great job by jester calling it out"
"but actually this is jus something to notice and possibly jovial and not necessarily scum"
WTF- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
This progression is gross.In post 39, ECMitchell wrote:I find it interesting you [sesq] felt the need to highlight your first vote during the RVS as, indeed, random.
I liked seeing The_Jester call this out as well.In post 18, The_Jester wrote:Why do you feel the need to underline the fact of random voting?
If I'm pointing out Sesq's instance, I must point out Charloux's as well.In post 19, Charloux wrote:
I'm not mad at you! I just pretended to be so i could get some info from you!In post 15, Siblings Quarrel wrote: Also Charloux, I swear I won't be bad at the video game this time.
-Ali
I used that as well, but since i was first on the list, i decided to vote for someone else.
Neither case is particularly a scum read; both are certainly jovial. Just something to notice.
"interesting you random rvs'd"
"great job by jester calling it out"
"but actually this is jus something to notice and possibly jovial and not necessarily scum"
WTF
Fixed
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
I do too.In post 54, Bellaphant wrote:Trans, you have reads already?
You're town and this makes me incredibly happy.- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
So I agree him voting intermission is voting scum.In post 60, Transcend wrote:because he voted obvscum and the entrance on that vote doesn't look like a bus
But the way he approached it seemed weird.
He complimented intermission for the RQS questions, then voted him anyway.
like no conviction behind it
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
BTW ECMitchel, talk to me about Intermission.
Cuz you went from "I like your RQS and your entrance" to "It just feels like you're looking busy."
What prompted the sudden change?
-Ali- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
Why? I liked your questions to him.In post 69, Bellaphant wrote:
super town. you might be town?[/quite]In post 67, Siblings Quarrel wrote:if transcend and bella are both town we are going to fucking rule this game.
-Frog
100% town.
gonna leave transcend to you for a bit.
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
100% townIn post 69, Bellaphant wrote:
super town. you might be town?In post 67, Siblings Quarrel wrote:if transcend and bella are both town we are going to fucking rule this game.
-Frog
Why? I liked your questions to himgonna leave transcend to you for a bit.
(Fixed)
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
Talk to me about Sesq and Jester.In post 76, Cooperative Sheep wrote:I could also lynch Sesq (for coming across stilted to me, which, to stave off the inevitable question - is also how Intermission feels.)
-Ali- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
Was going to ask the same thing as Jester.
And I think Jester is probably town. He kept saying that intermission isn't the droid we're looking for, but is now changing his mind and questioning intermission on something I picked up on too. I even pointed out intermissions LAMIST statements and concern for his image to Ali in our hydra PT.
That jester is rethinking things and pressuring someone he originally thought was a bad spot for pressure, certainly comes from someone trying to figure the game out.- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
I thought the reaction was funny.In post 73, Bellaphant wrote:do you/does anyone have any feels about charl? especially the reaction to my rvs?
I think charl is probably town, although I'm having a hard time reconciling these two posts from him with no explanation of why he townreads intermission in the latter post
In post 29, Charloux wrote:
Why ask how he plays as town and not as scum? And nonchalantly saving it for last. I like to think that preserving your cards is essential in mafia regardless of alignment, so i consider this question kinda bad.In post 22, Intermission wrote: theplague42: What's your usual Day One strategy to sniff out scum?In post 84, Charloux wrote:Liking intermission for town.- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
Alright guys.
I want everyone to sheep this vote.
VOTE: Cooperative Sheep
Here is why: His reads are very shallow and they just feel fake and easily fakable.
His hop onto the Intermission wagon was already sus. They just put Intermission at L-1 so god dam casually it's not even funny.
Not to mention now they're trying to start up another easy wagon.
Sheep me guyz.
-Ali- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
Let's also add that Sheep is adding pressure but not doing anything with the pressure.
And asking questions but not doing anything with those actual questions.
-Ali- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
Fuck L-2 not L-1. mybad.In post 111, Siblings Quarrel wrote:They just put Intermission at L-1 so god dam casually it's not even funny.
-Ali- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
It's also super "look at me I'm doing something!" by sheep (LAMIST)In post 105, The_Jester wrote:Pressure voting kinda loses its purpose when you make it obvious it's nothing more, you know
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
If this is your reasoning for wanting to vote Bella, you REALLY, REALLY, REALLY need to look at Sheep's ISO.In post 122, theplague42 wrote:Lots of questions, not much saying.
-Ali- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
And I am okay with adding you to my lynch poolIn post 124, theplague42 wrote:
I accept him role-playing a sheep.In post 123, Siblings Quarrel wrote:
If this is your reasoning for wanting to vote Bella, you REALLY, REALLY, REALLY need to look at Sheep's ISO.In post 122, theplague42 wrote:Lots of questions, not much saying.
-Ali
-Ali- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
How many times have you played with Bella?In post 122, theplague42 wrote:
Maybe to you.In post 58, Siblings Quarrel wrote:^ -obvfrog
UNVOTE:
VOTE: Bellaphant
Lots of questions, not much saying.
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
God dammit I promised myself I wasn't going to hydra slipIn post 128, Fro99er wrote:
Apparently never.In post 34, theplague42 wrote:You're the only person I recognize. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
That's an awful shallow read to just vote her for asking questions. You know nothing of her play and you're just going to throw a bullshit reason out there.
You're going to have to explain why the questions are coming from scum, and not town.
-Frog
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
No because it refers to ongoing and ECM should never have said that in the first place.In post 138, Bellaphant wrote:
Can either you/sheep/sibs talk about this fact some more?In post 135, ECMitchell wrote:I'm hesitant to sheep your vote on Sheep, since in the only two games I've been able to observe you in, you've adamantly led a lynch on them. I'm starting to wonder if you two are just on completely different wavelengths and naturally clash with each other. For what it's worth, right now I'm not getting much of a scum read on Cooperative Sheep.
I suggest this not be talked about anymore before there are force replaces
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
I refer to talking to my hydra partner in our PT in every hydra game. It's my style. My style is NAI.In post 135, ECMitchell wrote:The bold statement in particular comes off as you trying to establish the fact that you're actively scum hunting "behind the scenes"—and of course, why would you do that if you were scum? If you're a hydra account, it probably goes without saying that you're collaborating, right?- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
The read on us from sheep is shallow af. How does he get we're town from that one single post out of all the posts we made? It's a really bullshit read on us.
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
This is such a terrible reason. We're town for many reasons, but just to put it as this single reason is craptasticoIn post 85, Cooperative Sheep wrote:For Siblings, I really liked post #68, it read like a legit inquiry with some consideration behind it and less like noise.
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
What's not true about it?In post 132, Cooperative Sheep wrote:
I think this is provably untrue - could you provide supporting evidence that makes you believe this?In post 113, Siblings Quarrel wrote:Let's also add that Sheep is adding pressure but not doing anything with the pressure.
And asking questions but not doing anything with those actual questions.
-Ali
You voted sesq and did nothing with that vote. No comments on why he's scum or follow up things to put pressure on him. Just a vote then nothing else after that (as of the time we made our comment about it).
The questions you've asked were mostly filler about effort, and not really an attempt to sort alignment.
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
Sheep's vote of sesq wasn't a naked vote. It was a vote for pressure, and then they never pressured sesq on anything.In post 161, Charloux wrote:@Frog: Could be because i didn't read this properly, but i see some unlaborated naked votes that are just staying around. How do you tell the difference when it's scummy and when it's not?- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
jfc: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 9#p7389339In post 163, ECMitchell wrote:Frog, since you claim to do it regularly, can you show me an instance of you proclaiming to actively work with your Hydra mate in PT from past games?
i'm not going to dig through more exmaples, but go look up banana frog or Frog Mollie (Ori in archived mini theme games) or the like and ISO them and ctrl+f " PT" (with the space bar in front of the PT). Froggaphant (bellaphant, who is in this game) I hydra'd with but I never said it there.
I had a hydra with salamance I cant remember the name of but it was ika's large theme that is archived. I think I may have hydra'd with 1 or 2 others.- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
The rule is don't talk about or refer to ongoing games.In post 163, ECMitchell wrote:Apologies. Didn't realize, since I've seen others regularly refer to other games and it's what I'm used to. Distinction must be current games versus completed ones, yes?
Period.- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
I will say...in THIS GAME...Alisae is the head of the hydra that started the read on sheep. If you're not taking Alisae's read on sheep into account, you're doing it wrong
-Frog- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
Right, but sheep himself did not continue the pressure.In post 164, Charloux wrote:All votes are for pressure actually, so you using it as a scumtell is ridiculous. And sesq did provide reads after sheeps vote.
He said he was voting for pressure, then did nothing to pressure other than the vote itself. It was just like "hey, let's pressure sesq with a vote" ... but saying it's a pressure vote, as jester pointed out, defeats the purpose. If you want to pressure someone, make them talk.- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
Yeah sure. Go look at your iso, then at yourself, then your iso, then at yourself.In post 132, Cooperative Sheep wrote:I think this is provably untrue - could you provide supporting evidence that makes you believe this?
-Ali- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
How was it forced?In post 136, Intermission wrote:Also losing confidence in Siblings Quarrel. The Sheep wagon feels very forced
-Ali- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
This might actually be a scumclaim? Maaaaaybe.In post 148, Intermission wrote:If you can't or won't explain yourself, then it's fair to vote you.
VOTE: Transcend
Idunno, will talk to Frogger about it.
-Ali- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
I'll claim whatever I want to claim tyvm.In post 180, theplague42 wrote:Well at first it seemed like she wanted to ask some questions then back off, unlike Intermission who kept following up on what he was saying. If you claim that's her playstyle, then fine, I can accept that. But don't try to claim that my lack of meta-knowledge means I can't make a statement about what I think is suspicious because of "playstyle".
Your scum read was based off "lots of questions, not much saying"
Yet you didn't even try to bother to figure out if that's her playstyle. You just pigeonholed her into scum for that. That's why I think it's bullshit, because you made ZERO attempt to understand if it's her playstyle. So yes, I will claim your lack of meta-knowledge means you can't make a statement about something suspicious since you didn't try to understand if it really is suspicious in the first place.
I'll give you a hint ... Bella as town isn't the most confident, is pretty cautious (which she's been with me so far), and doesn't play all tryhard.
Scum bella is a total tryhard and is more confident with her reads (I wonder why...because she knows who everyone is).
And if all you think is she's asked questions with not much saying, I'll disagree. She's made some subtle points that you haven't picked up on, and instead have just dismissed as questions without saying.- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
And that's EXACTLY the problem.In post 182, Cooperative Sheep wrote:I literally didn't post between 1 and 4, so you called me out *before* you had a chance to see what I would do and called me scummy for not doing anything - how do you justify that?
You didn't follow up with any questions for sesq, and other pressure for sesq. Just a vote. It was clear you didn't care about *actually* pressuring him, just throwing a vote there instead to look like you were doing something.
You could have immediately followed your vote up with some pressure, challenged him on things in his ISO, asked him what he felt about certain people, but you didn't.- Siblings Quarrel
-
Siblings Quarrel Goon
- Siblings Quarrel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 714
- Joined: February 2, 2017
In post 76, Cooperative Sheep wrote:Baaaaa
Vote: Intermission
I could also lynch Sesq (for coming across stilted to me, which, to stave off the inevitable question - is also how Intermission feels.)
I like Siblings and Jester for town.
You could have pressured sesq on the things you think made him stilted. But you chose not to. Instead just a vote for pressure, but no ACTUAL pressure on him, like trying to sort him through pressing the "stilted" part or by interacting with him.In post 104, Cooperative Sheep wrote:How about we try to get Sesq to actually do something relevant to the game - or flash wagon him for funsises! Either way, we win.
Vote: Sesq - Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel
- Siblings Quarrel