Grand Idea Mafia

[The MM]

Town Night-lynch Enabler

As long as you are alive, players may send the mod a PM of who they want lynched. The players with the most votes gets lynched during the night before other Night actions occur.

[The MM]

Town Night-talk Enabler

As long as you are alive, players may talk during Night phases.

[The MM]

Town Demi-God of Long Days

Players are informed that there may pray to a Demi-God at night instead of performing other night actions.
For each prayer you receive, you gain 1 stack. If the number of stacks you have is superior or equal to the lynch threshold, you consume a number of stacks equal to the lynch threshold and there will be another Day phase after the next one.

[The MM]

Third-party Lynchee-maker

Each night and at the start of the game, choose 2 players to be your Lynchees for the next day. If a Lynchee is lynched, you win the game. If there are 3 players to choose from, you can only pick one player. If there are less than two players to choose from, you cannot pick a player, and thus are guaranteed to lose.

[callforjudgement]

Vanilla Townie

Several of these roles are broken:

Survivor Scumstaller

All players from scumfactions and yourself arrive in the game Day 2.

Trivial to determine it exists (searching the thread for roles that could cause a late arrival won't come up with many options), and provide a nice handy roadmap to determine the entire set of scum (Survivors are also normally considered scum). If the setup gives town any chance to win on day actions, they'll almost certainly be able to take it, as scumhunting is also a factor.

Town Innocent Sunbringer

You are announced as Town at the start of the game.
As long as you are alive, all nights are skipped.

Will never get lynched, making the game Nightless and defeating most of the point of Grand Idea. (It's rare for scum to get a dayvig.)

Sunkiller

(alignment at mod's discretion)

As long as you are alive, all day phases are skipped. (If the game cannot progress because of this, you and whatever other role combines to make it so that the game cannot progress will lose your abilities.)

As most roles in this thread aren't killing roles, there's a very high chance that the only killers will be scum. If they're lucky, they'll get off a sequence of unopposed kills, maybe outright winning the game, before town can do anything consequential.

[Mewtaph]

Mafia Seraph Knight

[Mewtaph]

1-Shot Universal Doctor

(alignment chosen by the moderator)

[Mewtaph]

Town Even-Night Watcher

[Mewtaph]

Town Odd-Night Tracker

[callforjudgement]

Survivor Dayvig

You can daykill one player per day.

[McMenno]

Town Mason-Monkifier

Two non-mafia players become masons. Two non-werewolf players become monks. (In addition to their normal roles)

[BigYoshiFan]

PT Cop

Checks if their target has access to a PT. I was given this role in a Large Normal, I liked it.
Alignment at the mod's discretion.

[The MM]

Serial Killer Townstaller

All townies are out of the game until Day 2. Until then, no win condition may apply.
Each night after Day 2 starts, you may shoot another player.

---

Several of these roles are broken:

Yeah, this kinda can happen when you take the list of mechanics people would want to see and make roles based on that in a frenzy. It's not like mods don't already apply Wisdom Of The Mod when making Grand Idea.

Survivor Scumstaller

All players from scumfactions and yourself arrive in the game Day 2.

Trivial to determine it exists (searching the thread for roles that could cause a late arrival won't come up with many options), and provide a nice handy roadmap to determine the entire set of scum (Survivors are also normally considered scum). If the setup gives town any chance to win on day actions, they'll almost certainly be able to take it, as scumhunting is also a factor.

First, I treat Survivors as

Third-party

, since they don't win by killing everyone not from their faction or being sure to do so.
Second, a Survivor can't be a scumfaction since they're alone
And yes, it needs at least some sort of multiball that involves town being less than half the base players to function. I tend to assume this is the case.

Town Innocent Sunbringer

You are announced as Town at the start of the game.
As long as you are alive, all nights are skipped.

Will never get lynched, making the game Nightless and defeating most of the point of Grand Idea. (It's rare for scum to get a dayvig.)

You could be lynched Day 1. Several roles have an Innocent Child announcement yet are scum - I even made one ages ago.

Sunkiller

(alignment at mod's discretion)

As long as you are alive, all day phases are skipped. (If the game cannot progress because of this, you and whatever other role combines to make it so that the game cannot progress will lose your abilities.)

As most roles in this thread aren't killing roles, there's a very high chance that the only killers will be scum. If they're lucky, they'll get off a sequence of unopposed kills, maybe outright winning the game, before town can do anything consequential.

Yes, this is indeed likely a game-breaker. Apply caution.

[McMenno]

Town Mason-Monkifier

[McMenno]

Mafia Mason-Monkifier

[McMenno]

Werewolf Mason-Monkifier

[McMenno]

Alien Mason-Monkifier

[Mewtaph]

Magic Lamp

(alignment chosen by moderator, preferably town)

If you are ever gladiated, you may message the moderator

USE: Lamp

. It will summon a genie who makes the person you are gladiating with vanish, immediately removed from the game state. Their alignment and role will not be revealed. You are privately messaged their role PM. [The day will either continue or enter night phase immediately at the moderator's discretion.]

[Mewtaph]

Town Compulsive Ninja Giant

Each night, you must visit somebody during the night phase. This action doesn't actually do anything. The next day, it will be announced that a giant visited your visit target the next day.

[Mewtaph]

Clarification to above role

: Add "You will never be seen performing this action by investigative roles." or remove the "Ninja" modifier.

Mafia Ninja Giant Trickster

In addition to your factional night kill, during the night phase you control a giant that you may direct to visit somebody during the night phase. This action doesn't actually do anything. The next day, it will be announced that a giant visited your target the next day. You will never be seen performing this action, but your factional kill can still be watched.

[Mewtaph]

Town Halfling

You act as a normal vanilla townie for all extensive purposes but you have an alternative win condition. If you ever hold possession of two objects (inventions or fruit), you may sell it during the night phase and you will win regardless of the game's result.

[Mewtaph]

Town Sabertooth

Others see you as intimidating. You will appear as "Guilty" or come up as a negative result in any investigative action.
Once per game, you may prey on a player. If they have ever visited you before, you will kill them. If they haven't visited you before, this action will do nothing.

[Mewtaph]

Town Tentacled Evangelistic Doublevoter

Investigates as "Alien" to any "Alien/Not Alien" investigators and "Cult" to any "Cult/Not Cult" investigators.
You have two votes that you may use during the day phase.
Your double vote ability is disabled during MYLO/LYLO.

[Sméagol]

Town 1-shot instant karma bringer

Whatever your target does, it does to itself (even when normally not able to target itself). You won't be notified, it doesn't affect the original action.

[Sméagol]

Ultimate warrior

(aligment up to mod's discretion)
When someone challenges you to a gladiator duel, you automatically win.