Shaziro's Mini Normal Review

[Firebringer]

Initial first glance is I am thinking this is scum sided

[Firebringer]

Ohh wait, I misunderstood the "Neighbor Cop" I thought that was a Cop who could only check if someone was in PTs or not.
Okay, that changes it to town sided.

It would probably be better if you limit Cop to only checking the neighbors to make it like a "Mason hood"
That could be your grey list role.

Problem is that there is a "Follow the Cop" issue even with the role blocker for scum team.
I would really still limit scum power here. A strongman and role blocker isn't necessary.
Either or, but both don't seem needed.

I guess the power is to justify a Cop and a Doctor being in same game, but still makes it very "Swingy" and unbalanced.

[Firebringer]

I am actually not sure if this initial setup is town sided or scum sided. But considering scum usually always have more info, it probably still is scum sided since theres two ways to stop the Doctor or Cop (Strongman or Roleblocker)

[Firebringer]

Scumsided. Cop and 2-shot doc not near enough town power given setup, and neighbors are very low utility.

Yeah, thats the problem with putting in a cop and doc into a setup. you have to give scum pretty powerful guns in order to "deal" with it.

[Firebringer]

Secondly, would removing the 2-shot modifier on the doctor make it sufficiently less scumsided?

Yes, since Doctor cannot be blocked for all their shots or waste shots anymore. Would definitely improve the Doctor+Cop combo, and kind of allow you to keep scum power as is.

[Firebringer]

You are a Scum Traitor

You are a member of the Scum Faction, along with X and Y. They do not know who you are, but they are aware that there is a Scum Traitor in this game.

If your faction members target you for a nightkill, you -will- die. You cannot privately communicate with them in any way. You cannot be directly recruited by any means, and if you are the last remaining member of your team you will be endgamed.

Your powers include your voice and your vote! Use them well.

You win the game when the Mafia control 50% of the vote

Confirm your role by replying to me with your Role and Alignment.

Good luck!

This is good.

[Firebringer]

Town
Cop
Doc
Fruit vendor or bodyguard
However you want to do neighbors

Scum
Roleblocker
Goon
Traitor

I think this is going too far in other way? I mean, if the Roleblocker at all gets lynched early, scum are really screwed on a full Cop and Doc game.

I guess you could do something like a Even Night and a Odd Night role blocker for scum team, so that makes that problem less of a issue.

[Firebringer]

Sounds interesting. So it'd be a traitor, an even night RB and an odd night RB?

Yes.

[Firebringer]

I think three Neighbours - particularly with the Cop in the Neighbourhood and godfathers being banned - work perfectly fine without feeling the need for a Fruit Vendor or similar. Particularly with the traitor being so weak.

I also think the traitor mechanics ought to be in the main team's PMs.

Is traitor required to be known to scum team for normals (I am having a brain fart)

I have no problem with Fruit Vendor, especially if Shaziro makes it so scum can act and perform kills on same night, reduces fruit vendor to complete fluff. Right now its only marginal good at telling you thats unlikely scum.

[Firebringer]

Shaziro, do you want to keep the Fruit Vendor?

[Firebringer]

That seems fine to me.

[Firebringer]

i already said this but ill repeat:

Approved with Fire