[Game Over] Newbie 1784 - Escape Room

[nancy]

You No Lynch until the BP dies or there's a guilty.

[TesXX]

But scum would kill the tracker, not the BP's vest.

[nancy]

True. I didn't think of that. Well, we would No Lynch until that happened, too, I guess.

[BlackVoid]

Because I was going to see if there were any partner-like interactions between Chronicle and either Drixx or WhyMafia.

I have a hard time following this. I'm looking at the alternative scenario: that you are scum with Drixx, and when you saw me and nancy consider lynching Chronicle, you saw an opportunity to save Drixx and "went through" Chronicle's ISO so you could justify a vote there. That world looks more likely than the explanations you are giving.

Just walk me through it one more time. You didn't vote Drixx because you were undecided on which of Drixx/WM you want to lynch. So, instead of reading through their ISOs, you look over Chronicle's ISO to see if there are partner-like interactions, why? Didn't you already agree that Drixx and WM look like partners themselves in 1151? You also preferred a Drixx lynch and you also said that Drixx lynch influences the most number of reads so your vote really should have been on him end-of-day.

[Srceenplay]

After whymafia answer to me I'm thinking maybe Tesxx first.

[nancy]

Me too tbh

[nancy]

I'm probably just going to follow the Tracker

[nancy]

It's his last day alive, after all.

[BlackVoid]

I looked over TesXX's mentions of Pine/Drixx. He starts out by questioning why nancy townreads Pine so much, then questions Loopdan on why he scumreads Pine. He agrees with WhyMafia in 301 that lynching Pine might cause us to lose an important power role and wants to wait for a replacement. Mostly, he has the slot as null until 1151 where he says that Drixx is a scumlean, reasoning being that he went over Pine's wall again and Pine did seem to be trying to townread nancy. He adds that he could see a Pine/WhyMafia team that I mentioned if WhyMafia flipped scum. His perspective of the gamestate in 1167 seems very reasonable as well. I'm just concerned that his last minute ISO'ing Chronicle doesn't really make sense with the reads he gave and it seems more than a co-incidence that just when we were discussing Chronicle, he decides to ISO him. I'm pretty conflicted. Thoughts on this?

[BlackVoid]

I'm trying to figure out why TesXX was even scumreading WhyMafia in the first place. All his mentions of WhyMafia before 509 were positive. As he mentions in 519, this was apparently because he was re-reading WhyMafia's ISO without bias and the bulk of his suspicion is apparently because a post seems "forced" and because WhyMafia suggested that he be lynched. It's not a great reason by itself but he at least had a consistent suspicion towards WhyMafia which makes sense with his overall readlist and trying to decide between WhyMafia and Pine. Overall, I'm thinking TesXX is probably town. I like that early push for getting the BP and tracker claims too.

[nancy]

What do you think, Srceenplay?

[nancy]

You're not really a Day 1 kind of guy but you're more in your element now, right?

[BlackVoid]

Before I forget, this post has been bothering me for a while and is just an overall weird post:

Regarding Stealthy's post, I was only defending Pine bc lynching someone based on someone who is inactive is ridiculous.

I also defended the person Cog replaced

(albeit less so bc I was busy when they were trying to lynch him)

What's notable here is when he was accused of defending Pine, he jumps to say that he was defended another slot as well. Feels like he knows Pine is scum and is saying "oh, it isn't just Pine I defended, look I defended this townie as well." He also tries to distance himself from his Pine defense. The language he uses "I was only defending Pine becuase..." whereas a townie would be more likely to back up that defense and say that lynching Pine for being inactive is ridiculous. I'd expect him to re-iterate his reasoning, not distance from it. I'm not sure I'm articulating this right. Let me know if not.

[StealthyNoodle]

Hmm, well observed

[MiniDeathStar]

N

ewbie

G

ame

#

1784

Notice

Loopdan

has been prodded.

[Srceenplay]

You're not really a Day 1 kind of guy but you're more in your element now, right?

Pssst.
I'm out and about tonight.
IIRC the only reason Tess was town read was because of his push for the claim strategy. He kinda fell off afterwards. Sat in the back and watched. I don't know if I believe his reasoning for not voting Drixx. Have to look at vote count later to see if he ever was there or whymafia.

[nancy]

You're not really a Day 1 kind of guy but you're more in your element now, right?

Pssst.
I'm out and about tonight.
IIRC the only reason Tess was town read was because of his push for the claim strategy. He kinda fell off afterwards. Sat in the back and watched. I don't know if I believe his reasoning for not voting Drixx. Have to look at vote count later to see if he ever was there or whymafia.

Well I'm not going to be around much over the weekend so I'll just look forward to coming back to all the words from Src.

[TesXX]

I will post in the morning tomorrow.

[Srceenplay]

No words. I'm just pillow talking.

[Loopdan]

Sorry for site flaking. Some stuff came up and I'm going to have to be VLA until the 19th. If you'd prefer I replace out I'm fine with that.

[nancy]

Replacing out would be preferable.

[StealthyNoodle]

Sorry for site flaking. Some stuff came up and I'm going to have to be VLA until the 19th. If you'd prefer I replace out I'm fine with that.

I don't mind VLA. It's only 4 days. And we're Day 2 with one scum out.

[BlackVoid]

I would prefer replacing out as well.

[TesXX]

Because I was going to see if there were any partner-like interactions between Chronicle and either Drixx or WhyMafia.

I have a hard time following this. I'm looking at the alternative scenario: that you are scum with Drixx, and when you saw me and nancy consider lynching Chronicle, you saw an opportunity to save Drixx and "went through" Chronicle's ISO so you could justify a vote there. That world looks more likely than the explanations you are giving.

Just walk me through it one more time. You didn't vote Drixx because you were undecided on which of Drixx/WM you want to lynch. So, instead of reading through their ISOs, you look over Chronicle's ISO to see if there are partner-like interactions, why? Didn't you already agree that Drixx and WM look like partners themselves in 1151? You also preferred a Drixx lynch and you also said that Drixx lynch influences the most number of reads so your vote really should have been on him end-of-day.

I did think that Drixx and WM were the scumteam, but I saw a Chronicle post that pinged me(1247)(and also I hadn't looked at Chronicle as much as I did with some of the other players) and so I wanted to read through Chronicle's ISO to see partner interactions that would make me reconsider anything.

[TesXX]

Sorry for site flaking. Some stuff came up and I'm going to have to be VLA until the 19th. If you'd prefer I replace out I'm fine with that.

Don't replace out. Unless you really need to.