implosion's Mini Normal Review

[mastina]

Yeah, need to see those things.
But balance-wise, I'd actually say this is fine? I'd maybe even make the 1-shot loyal friendly neighbor be a full Loyal Friendly Neighbor because motion detector is only a weak situational PR (it does not get a definitive guilty). The mafia rolecop gives the scum a fair chance of finding the town power roles but does not provide the scum a strong advantage; the town does not have any gamebreaking power, strategy, or whatnot and is also not horribly underpowered. (Though again I'd probably make the Loyal Friendly Neighbor be unlimited.)

It's really close to the mark balance-wise.
So we'd basically need to see the rules, see the roles, and see setup quirks. (Does the Rolecop get a result of 'Motion Detector', or 'Motion Detector Neighbor'? Similarly, 'Vanilla' or 'Neighbor'? Can mafia both kill and act, or just one? Do the mafia have daychat or not?)

[mastina]

My opinion is that I want the friendly neighbor to be full rather than one-shot, but that if that were done:
Loyal Friendly Neighbor
Rolestopper
Backup Rolestopper
Motion Detector Neighbor
Neighbor
VTs

Goons
Rolecop

...Would be balanced. Or reasonably close to balanced. (The most iffy part would be the rolecop there but even that I think would be fine.)

[mastina]

That is a quirk I can get behind.

[mastina]

Technically we should get a repost of all role PMs before approval, which I would insist on--details can and will be caught by doing so, so it's a necessary formality for me.
But I don't have balance-concerns.

[mastina]

You are a Mafia Goon, along with NAME (who is also a goon), and NAME (who is a rolecop).

^Case 'n' point, this should be N2 rolecop.

[mastina]

Yep, good to my eye.
/pass.