So yeah MarioManiac4 is super scum seriously guys wtf. Let's look at what he's done today.
His entire lynch pool is the lowest hanging fruit. His reasons for scumreading these people? Loopdan because of "being around but coasting". PP because of "being around but not contributing". Oldwino because of his bad tone. Well, if we're going to talk about being around and not contributing, let's look at what MarioManiac has decided to spend this day 2 on.In post 532, MarioManiac4 wrote: So really I only want to lynch within {PP, Loopdan, oldwino} in forever.
In post 537, MarioManiac4 wrote:Actually scratch that
@ {PP, Loopdan, oldwino}:
Who is scum?
Why are they scum?
What are your thoughts on the dual town wagons of yesterday?
This fucking post man. I admit, I thought it was a good actual example of non-superficial content at first. But that's just cause I skipped the wall. I mean, what does he say in this post? He's stated the facts of the PP wagon I guess. He's painstakingly explained his lack of confbias with a fucking WIKI LINK. He claimed not to have an ego which is hilarious. But nowhere here is anything to be found that isn't just trying to look busy. The last sentence is my favourite. "depending on the read it may mean different things". I mean, come on guys. These days, tone and posting style is way too big in scumhunting. Oldwino is the biggest wagon because of the stupid and emotional person he is. Maniac is given a free pass because of the town-leadershippy role he's taking in an incredibly superficial way.In post 536, MarioManiac4 wrote:In post 535, Loopdan wrote:[quote="InIn post 559, MarioManiac4 wrote:If PenguinPower comes into this thread and posts anything that isn't a readslist that involves critical analysis, we should lynch him today.In post 596, MarioManiac4 wrote:Hello PenguinPower! I noticed you were online!
Could you give your reads and the reasoning behind them please?In post 597, MarioManiac4 wrote:yeah we can lynch penguinpower at any point!In post 600, MarioManiac4 wrote:I mean I'm being harsher in here than I should be and want to be.
But we're not going to win this game without some significant contribution by the one of those three who is town.In post 607, MarioManiac4 wrote:Reminder.In post 559, MarioManiac4 wrote:If PenguinPower comes into this thread and posts anything that isn't a readslist that involves critical analysis, we will lynch him today.In post 608, MarioManiac4 wrote:hello oldwino.
I noticed you were online.
I would like you to proceed with giving reads and placing a vote.Pretty much that's what he's been doing today. All he's done is pushing his scumreads, all of which areIn post 632, MarioManiac4 wrote:I promise you oldwino if you present your scumread and why you think they are scum it will help the town win condition no matter who it is.coincidentallythe single easiest mislynches in the game, to post things. This is an excersize in trying to look busy while having incredibly superficial reads. This is textbook scum play, except instead of being from the textbook that you want to read written by an expert, this is the textbook written by your shitty professor that he makes you buy for 350$ because corruption. It's not just today that Maniac has been scumreading the easiest lynches. Yesterday he was on the wagon that ousted one of the easiest lynches on the site, BTD6maker. You know what my favourite terrible Maniac post is?In post 677, MarioManiac4 wrote:@oldwino;
Longer days are not always better. Sometimes, they blow out all of town's momentum and bore everyone in the game, making them lose interest.
Deadlines are a suggestion, not a rule! If we are ready to move onto Day 3, we should move onto Day 3. I do agree this day has some more life in it, though. No intent to hammer has been stated so I'm not sure what your issue is. Leaving wagons to deadline, on the other hand, can be largely dangerous and result in compromise lynches of town.
We are not lynching PP for lurking as you seem to suggest. We are considering lynching him because the content of his posts are heavily shifted towards empty setup maths rather than trying to find the scum.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias
Can you explain how I am showing this here?
Perfect scum games happen all the time. I've been on the good end of one of those despite being mediocre at scumplay. 7:2 is biased towards Mafia and there are plenty of ways that you could lose to scum by chainlynching Town.
Despite me being on the receiving end of your backlash it seems that you agree with me. Which is somewhat nice.
People HAVE unvoted PP. I am the only one who hasn't, looking at the voting.
The wagon was orchestrated by LicketyQuickety and I because PP has been here and has done things, just not useful ones at all and dodged questions. Firescreamer then voted it up once more to L-1. It's really not all that big of a deal.
It really feels like your play today is more wired towards winding people up than actually finding the scum.
I will now take a moment to refute your points on my play;
a) "others (MarioManiac4) do have bias, and I don't trust their reads."- Why do you feel like I have bias? I haven't scumread you since RVS. I came into it during D2 for completely different reasons which you have ignored, like you think "THEY ATTACK ALL OF MY POSTS" is a valid substitute for "they scumread me because they find my posts scummy. Loopdan's reads would be no better than mine in this regard because he was full-out tunelling Maker by the end of the day.
b) "login police are watching"- I did this twice. Once for you and once for PP. I feel like this is justified, though; you were online and willing to be on MS so you could have given your scumread while there, right? Same with PP.
c) "some egos are more important than their wincons"- You'll have to explain this one for me. I don't really have an ego nor have I been exerting one in this game.
d) The posting where you made it sound like it was my fault if you voted me because with my confbias tunnel you had no choice, right?! But I haven't tunnelled you and I have no confbias on you.
What is interesting is your posting on Loopdan. "lack of meaningful posts" does strike a chord. But depending on how you develop the read it may mean different things.
VOTE: Mariomaniac