Mini 1904: Rad Idea Mafia! (Endgame!)

[xSoniaNevermindx]

Do we know if RR was basically a traitor for any amount of scum team or was he on a scum team to begin with? Cause his role seems pointless

[Rautherdir]

We all picked our role based on cards we received at the beginning of the game.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

Yeah I know that I'm just confused on if RR's role means 2 scumteams or he was just a glorified traitor

[Rautherdir]

I think his alignment was like... A survivor who cannot win with town?
That's what I got out of it at least. And we almost definitely have multiple anti-town factions.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

Thanks I'll re read tonight/tomorrow

[SlySly]

Does anyone find Riley scummy?

[gerryoat]

Hi morons losers bitches and all other insults I can't think of atm.

ew

[gerryoat]

Alright so, I'm gonna reread Rat and get back to you guys later. i'm guessing he had some thouhgts about who he could think was mafia

[McMenno]

hey 1svt you do realise rr was essentially a universal traitor and didn't know any other scum... flushing your entire speculation down the toilet

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

Yeah that made me sad...
But that's not everything I've been looking at.

[SlySly]

I WAS YELLIN' AT HIM FOR TRYIN' TA MISLYNCH CHICKADEE WHEN HE WAS SCUM TRYIN' TA DO IT AND NOW HE'S TRYIN' TA CHANGE THE SUBJECT!!!!!

Where were you yelling at me about me trying to mislynch Chickadee? Quote it. You can't. The only time you mentioned my name was AFTER the lynch. Now who's the liar?

[SlySly]

Reads people, I want SRs from everyone.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

no ty

[SlySly]

Here's where we are at people.

Town: being frickin stupid
Scum: lurking right along

This game needs a red bull, and I just happen to be it.

SRs or I will dayvig however I see fit.

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Wait a moment. What is the argument for me being scum again?

You essentially claimed scum earlier and you haven't been scum hunting.

If you mean the first time from Rauth then I must disagree here that he claimed scum or even came close to it. In fact it was only a town claim with what looks to be forgetting the revealed role.
If it's a different post refresh my memory.

Also, lack of effort / scum hunting doesn't mean scum. Anti town yes, but that doesn't warrant a lynch day 2.

I don't understand what you're referring to in the first part of this post.

As for your second point, yes, effort is NAI. However I'm not judging the quality of his scum hunting, I'm concerned about where is it and why is he doing other things that appear like he's scum hunting. The times he's been active, he has seemed more focused on helping fuel the setup speculation that dominated a majority of the early game rather than trying to sort people.

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Wait a moment. What is the argument for me being scum again?

You essentially claimed scum earlier and you haven't been scum hunting.

Where did I claim scum?
Also I'm working on it.

Sorry for the confusion, this is why I should read before posting.
This is what RR said, not my views.

Okay that makes sense now.
I was kind of confused by that.

119.

There is no reason to deny that you drew 3 town cards unless you lied originally. If so, why did you?

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Here's where we are at people.

Town: being frickin stupid
Scum: lurking right along

This game needs a red bull, and I just happen to be it.

SRs or I will dayvig however I see fit.

[1 Shot Vanilla Town]

I don't understand what you're referring to in the first part of this post.

As for your second point, yes, effort is NAI. However I'm not judging the quality of his scum hunting, I'm concerned about where is it and why is he doing other things that appear like he's scum hunting. The times he's been active, he has seemed more focused on helping fuel the setup speculation that dominated a majority of the early game rather than trying to sort people.

You can jazz it up, but regardless you have him as scum here for either of the following reasons.

-Claiming to not have a town card - This is incorrect, and actually claimed to have all 3 of the same alignment. If you read into this correctly, you would have an opinion of town on this information alone.
-Not scum hunting - You said yourself this is NAI so that's already out of the window.
-Setup spec - This again is NAI. You find this from either side.

Now, you seem to be pushing as a combo of not scum hunting and doing spec setup. But then Why Rauth over players like Tip, Snarky and Riley??
And even myself, I spent most of day 1 setup spec and I haven't provided any scum hunting today to your knowledge.

Going by your argument, the reasons in question actually push Rauth more as town than anything, so I think you need more than that.

[Lil Uzi Vert]

I don't understand what you're referring to in the first part of this post.

As for your second point, yes, effort is NAI. However I'm not judging the quality of his scum hunting, I'm concerned about where is it and why is he doing other things that appear like he's scum hunting. The times he's been active, he has seemed more focused on helping fuel the setup speculation that dominated a majority of the early game rather than trying to sort people.

You can jazz it up, but regardless you have him as scum here for either of the following reasons.

-Claiming to not have a town card - This is incorrect, and actually claimed to have all 3 of the same alignment. If you read into this correctly, you would have an opinion of town on this information alone.
-Not scum hunting - You said yourself this is NAI so that's already out of the window.
-Setup spec - This again is NAI. You find this from either side.

Now, you seem to be pushing as a combo of not scum hunting and doing spec setup. But then Why Rauth over players like Tip, Snarky and Riley??
And even myself, I spent most of day 1 setup spec and I haven't provided any scum hunting today to your knowledge.

Going by your argument, the reasons in question actually push Rauth more as town than anything, so I think you need more than that.

What? He said he didn't quite word it that way when I mentioned to Chi that he also drew 3 town cards. Why would he feel a need to correct me if he actually did?

Effort is energy used to do something. He hasn't exhibited any energy to scum hunt which is why I said I'm not judging the quality of his scum hunting. I'm more curious and suspicious as to where is it. He even just told me he's working on it.

I'm not scum reading him for setup speculation.

As for the players you've mentioned, I have no reason to scum them as this time. Tip has made not only clear and concrete stances, but he made them when he had no reason to. Nothing that can't be faked but none of his content has pinged me so far. He also attempted to scum hunt a bit when called out for his vote on Ircher.

Snarky has 4 posts and just flat out hasn't been here. He'd be a policy lynch at best at this point.

Riley I have to look into a little more. I approach her with caution as many players tend to scum read her for play style rather than looking at the logic and motivation of her posts. I don't recall her doing any setup speculation though. I did like how she challenged me on my reasoning for scum reading Chi and I want to see where she goes with her Sly push.

[Rautherdir]

Alright, I am only going to explain this once:
Everyone else who had claimed all 3 town draws up to that point explicitly stated they drew 3 town cards:

I received 3 town roles.
But given if I confirm them before others both of my hidden roles are unique.

Since Radical decided to out me, I drew the following cards:

1) VT
2) Town 1-Shot Commuter
3) Town Compulsive Vigilante

I, on the other hand, never once in my post explicitly said my cards were town. It would take one more step - knowing my discard was town - to deduct that I drew all town cards. Also, that post actually says something else I did not intend for it to say: It could also be taken as me having all cards that a given alignment had; in other words, that I was claiming to have the survivor card or both of the cult cards.

I know that I for one drew all cards of the same alignment.
Also, you can't get town compulsive vig without also having another town card to serve as the alignment

[Rautherdir]

Reads people, I want SRs from everyone.

Give me a few hours and I will.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

I'd love to see Sly try and digvig me oh wait he won't
(reading tonight)

[TiphaineDeath]

Sonia bothers me, I could see lynching her, or maybe LUV, they are way different than when they were town in my last game.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

Sonia bothers me, I could see lynching her, or maybe LUV, they are way different than when they were town in my last game.

Don't try to meta me people have tried and it doesn't work, Unless you're asking for another reaction test

[JerryArr]

x