Mini Normal 1908 - In The Web (Game Over)

[ThinkBig]

Official Vote Count

Gamma Emerald

(4): MortFeld, Tarkus, PenguinPower, Hikari Link

WhemeStar

(3): TwoFace, TwoFace, Ircher

BigYoshiFan

(1): MMM

Ircher

(1): MarioManiac4

Not Voting

(5): havingfitz, BigYoshiFan, RayFrost, WhemeStar, Gamma Emerald

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

Gamma Emerald is the leading wagon and is as L-3

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-05-16 18:21:03)

[Gamma Emerald]

VOTE: gamma

Why

[Gamma Emerald]

>Mort calls me scum
>PP naked votes me
I think I found a scum
VOTE: PenguinPower

[TwoFace]

naked votes aren't scummy.

what else you have other than omgus?

[MortFeld]

naked votes aren't scummy.

what else you have other than omgus?

What has PPslot even done other than vote GE, and call Transcend/Wheme town?

[havingfitz]

@TwoFace, Why not?
UNVOTE: fitz

He claimed FULL watcher. You do realize how op watcher is in general for town?

It's far more likely to be in scum hands than town.

What are you saying.. "ok watcher"? And town watcher is a fairly common role. I don't think I've ever seen a scum one.

You may not have been paying attention but in Eager snakes mini Normal the was a mafia watcher

I assume there have been. I just don't recall ever seeing any. My main point was that town watchers aren't uncommon. IMO at least.

[Gamma Emerald]

naked votes aren't scummy.

what else you have other than omgus?

The timing is

[Hikari Link]

naked votes aren't scummy.

what else you have other than omgus?

What has PPslot even done other than vote GE, and call Transcend/Wheme town?

Assuming he's ChannelDelibird (which I believe he is), he also placed a shit vote on me, then went V/LA. So not much, honestly.

[havingfitz]

Pardon the double post. I thought I'd hit preview instead of submit. Joys of phone posting.

[PenguinPower]

VOTE: gamma

Why

I was weighing whether or not Mort was scum - his posting is a bit different than the last game I played with him. He's reads mostly aligned with mine, so I'm going to treat him as town. We both don't see Wheme as scum here, you were the closet counterwagon, and I think you're scum.

Your reads don't align with mine and I think you have a pretty yucky ISO that is full of empty questions.

Here's where I'm at after a scan through.

{Hikari, Twoface, Mortfeld}
{Wheme, MMM, BYF}
{Tarkus, Rayfrost}
{Ircher, Havingfitz, Mariomaniac4}
{Gamma}

Sooooo.....yeah.

[TwoFace]

What has PPslot even done other than vote GE, and call Transcend/Wheme town?

nothing

[Gamma Emerald]

Having differing reads is grounds for a scumread?

[PenguinPower]

Because that's what I said.....

[TwoFace]

naked votes aren't scummy.

what else you have other than omgus?

The timing is

nah, sorry you need something more of remove the vote.

don't get me wrong I don't like what pp has done since replacing in but he isn't getting lynched based off your bad reasoning.

[MortFeld]

Having differing reads is grounds for a scumread?

[MortFeld]

UNVOTE:

[MortFeld]

Because that's what I said.....

Hm. But having similar reads is grounds for a townread?

How am I posting differently?

[TwoFace]

{Gamma}

post a case on gamma.

[PenguinPower]

Because that's what I said.....

Hm. But having similar reads is grounds for a townread?

How am I posting differently?

Last game was a newbie, and you had a lot more analysis in your posts than I am seeing here. And yes, similar reads lacking other information is a good start for a townread.

{Gamma}

post a case on gamma.

I don't do that.

[WhemeStar]

VOTE: Ircher

[MortFeld]

Ok, so lack of analysis. Yeah I'm pretty done with this particular game and possibly mafia in general. It's not AI.

[TwoFace]

I don't do that.

you are going to have to if you want anyone to take you seriously

[PenguinPower]

Ok, so lack of analysis. Yeah I'm pretty done with this particular game and possibly mafia in general. It's not AI.

Playing outside a typical playstyle can absolutely be AI. But, whatevs.

[Hikari Link]

Because that's what I said.....

Hm. But having similar reads is grounds for a townread?

How am I posting differently?

Having similar reads (especially on a replace) is actually a pretty good way to read someone as town, I feel. If you are reading a game and thinking "this guy's saying all the things I'm thinking" and you are town, then I think there's a good chance the person you are reading is town. Not to say that scum can't replace in and pick a player to blindly sheep.

It might be hard for us to tell which PP is and shouldn't be a towntell, but if he's town, then it's a reasonable stance from his perspective.

[MortFeld]

Ok, so lack of analysis. Yeah I'm pretty done with this particular game and possibly mafia in general. It's not AI.

Playing outside a typical playstyle can absolutely be AI. But, whatevs.

No I'm not saying the pattern isn't AI, I'm saying it's not AI for me.