Mini Normal 1908 - In The Web (Game Over)

[ThinkBig]

Official Vote Count

Gamma Emerald

(3): BigYoshiFan, MarioManiac4, PenguinPower

BigYoshiFan

(1): RayFrost

Not Voting

(5): Kelvin Smith, MMM, Priscila, Gamma Emerald, Ircher

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-06-04 15:48:38)

[Priscila]

This mass claim would not even happen if not for me. I want everyone's reads on me, right now.

Lean-town.

There were some things I didn't like regarding you.

I am genuinely confused as to how I can come out with my first content as a tier list and a vote and people call that opportunistic?

Here, it felt like you were playing the innocent and naive card.

How is that innocent and naive? Let's say I was playing some card - is there some reason why you think that post is not genuine? The tone? What?

Your surprising attention to detail during RVS threw me off

Threw you off? How? Why would attention to detail throw you off?

but your catchup later pretty much nullifies this.

Was there not attention to detail in my catchup?

I didn't particularly like your townread on me for "keeping the peace" per se, because it seemed like a pretty shallow read and I'd probably do it whether I was scum or not, because conflicts like that don't create a fun or cormfortable atmosphere.

That is one small part of my read on you, and my read on you is not a townread. You are nitpicking.

[Priscila]

I really dislike the tone. I owe her nothing.

You are hiding your read because you dislike me...?

[PenguinPower]

No. I'm not going to respond to your demand.

[Priscila]

It wasn't a demand.

[PenguinPower]

"Right now"

[Priscila]

An urgent request?

[PenguinPower]

Bull. The emojis don't help.

[PenguinPower]

VOTE: Priscilla

I don't like anything about your play this game.

[Priscila]

lol

[PenguinPower]

olo

[BigYoshiFan]

This mass claim would not even happen if not for me. I want everyone's reads on me, right now.

Lean-town.

There were some things I didn't like regarding you.

I am genuinely confused as to how I can come out with my first content as a tier list and a vote and people call that opportunistic?

Here, it felt like you were playing the innocent and naive card.

How is that innocent and naive? Let's say I was playing some card - is there some reason why you think that post is not genuine? The tone? What?

Your surprising attention to detail during RVS threw me off

Threw you off? How? Why would attention to detail throw you off?

but your catchup later pretty much nullifies this.

Was there not attention to detail in my catchup?

I didn't particularly like your townread on me for "keeping the peace" per se, because it seemed like a pretty shallow read and I'd probably do it whether I was scum or not, because conflicts like that don't create a fun or cormfortable atmosphere.

That is one small part of my read on you, and my read on you is not a townread. You are nitpicking.

1. Because it seems like you're saying in any circumstance where you come out with a tier list and a vote, people can't call it opportunistic. I sure think you can. Your join date is quite recent, and the tone, especially when you say "genuinely" didn't rub me the right way.
2. The emphasis I was intending was not that it had attention to detail, but that it was regarding RVS, if that makes sense. Asserting reads largely based on RVS and the early game, as it seemed like that when I had comforted you on this, isn't very helpful.
3. What I mean by this is that you begin to incorporate the other parts of the game into your reads.
4. I am nitpicking. I'm just mentioning it because it is something that I didn't like and it specifically pertained to your read on me. I was expecting from this; however, a little more.... analysis? Like, maybe some of your thoughts on how I interpreted your read on me. Your response to this in particular seems quite defensive and I'm not sure I like it.
Also,

Tier list

Kelvin Smith, MarioManiac4
PenguinPower, MMM, BigYoshiFan
Ircher
Gamma Emerald, RayFrost

Does this mean I'm just null then?

[BigYoshiFan]

In 2, comforted = confronted. Typos make me cringe. *cringe*

[BigYoshiFan]

VOTE: Priscilla

I don't like anything about your play this game.

Is there anything besides the tone you can elaborate on?

[Priscila]

Tier list

Kelvin Smith, MarioManiac4
PenguinPower, MMM, BigYoshiFan
Ircher
Gamma Emerald, RayFrost

Does this mean I'm just null then?

That tier is town leans. It should be clear from my content that I have off-site mafia experience, I hope. I came to MS to see what people were talking about.

[BigYoshiFan]

That is one small part of my read on you, and

my read on you is not a townread

. You are nitpicking.

But. So a leantown does not qualify as a townread to you?

[RayFrost]

I'd like to state that I do not find priscila's play this game to be scummy and am therefore unwilling at this point in time to vote for her. What even is the case?

[RayFrost]

While we're at it, what's the case for voting gamma?

[Priscila]

That is one small part of my read on you, and

my read on you is not a townread

. You are nitpicking.

But. So a leantown does not qualify as a townread to you?

A townread is a player I have no real concerns about for their alignment. For instance, I would put MMM as a townread, but there are one or two niggles that make me hesitate on my read there, and now I am waiting for a claim from that slot. Penguin was also a townread before his EoD interaction with Wheme's wagon.

[Priscila]

While we're at it, what's the case for voting gamma?

I stated a few things in my catchup, but something more recent is that he has stated that he has no scum reads. This feels to me like scum who does not want to give off partner tells. I'll establish proper cases on my suspects once we have finished massclaim though.

[Gamma Emerald]

I personally don't care to make reads now since it's p much autowin for town.

[Priscila]

It is once the massclaim is over, yes.

[RayFrost]

I find it more likely that scum would make something up / sheep someone else to try and shift things away from them rather than express a lack of scumreads.

[RayFrost]

I dislike the view that a confirmation of not being a gun holder is confirmation of not-scum 100% of the time. It's possible for someone to be investigation immune.

For the time being

, I'm willing to see MM4 and Penguin Power as town based off of my results, but that doesn't mean we can blindly ignore anything suspect that they do.

[Priscila]

I find it more likely that scum would make something up / sheep someone else to try and shift things away from them rather than express a lack of scumreads.

It is probably ultimately playstyle and therefore null.