Mini 1907: Oddrole Mafia IV (Game over)

[Creature]

Atleast I didn't become a Lich.

[Creature]

Well, no one seemed to make an interesting post, so I'll vote the one I think is scummiest.

VOTE: Almost50

[Creature]

Because his post seemed the scummiest from all and if someone made an interesting post I'd be likely townreading them.

[Creature]

I'm just asking, not throwing shade at you.

Desnecessauro.

[Creature]

By scummy I mean "what's more likely to come from scum than town"

[Creature]

When you posted that, did you expect scum to jump on you for it?

[Creature]

lol, are we discussing how many dead players we should have had?

[Creature]

"Congratulations, you're town for giving a good argument for why X players should have died"

[Creature]

Try to explain what a Planck looks like.

[Creature]

Let's try to push actual stuff.

VOTE: massive

[Creature]

The stuff I'm looking to push is scum.

[Creature]

Chickadee (1) [L-6]:

Desperado

GuiltyLion (1) [L-6]:

podoboq

podoboq (1) [L-6]:

boring

SnarkySnowman (1) [L-6]:

Rautherdir

Desperado (1) [L-6]:

GinghamDog

Almost50 (1) [L-6]:

TheBrie

I might vig one of the bolded players.

[Creature]

Vanity wagoners.

[Creature]

Do you think I am literally softing SK?

[Creature]

Is the vote on creature a serious vote? If so, maybe elaborate a bit?

Depends. Does he think my vote on GL was serious? His post is implying it, but maybe he's just being silly, instead of trying to force us out of RVS

Specify these pronouns, I don't know who you're referring here.

[Creature]

Since post 23 I haven't acted RVS-y.

[Creature]

I'm not telling that, I'm just suggesting a better discussion than "how many players should've been nightkilled".

[Creature]

VOTE: Chickadee

[Creature]

My reasoning is because it was a great opportunity to begin with a wagon.

[Creature]

I didn't feel JavaJoe24 would be a good wagon.

[Creature]

Or is there anything special about being the 4th voter rather than the 3rd?

Yes, 4-votes wagon > 3-votes wagon.

[Creature]

And we want to build wagons just because?

Otherwise players won't do anything and scum will easily blend in.

[Creature]

We need to find activity. Maybe we can find activity by putting non-active players under the threat of being lynched?

[Creature]

I believed you would eventually be sorted better without a wagon.

[Creature]

You notice something's wrong when someone has more scumreads than townreads.

[Creature]

Aaaaah, you're using "good content so far" to townread.

[Creature]

And yeah, don't claim if we aren't even planning to lynch you soon.

[Creature]

VOTE: Desperado

And this vote is different from my vote on Chickadee.

[Creature]

Right now explaining my scumread would mean telling scum what to do to get townread.

[Creature]

Maybe we could make everyone have posted enough so I can have enough things to work with (without thinking scum could've planned it) and so I could explain my reads.

[Creature]

I'm used to see Snarky hardly posting.

[Creature]

Great, I hate third parties, hopefully it's one that town doesn't need to kill.

[Creature]

Desperado is scum because if he were town he wouldn't let this game be like this.

[Creature]

Some players are wagoning you because you're an easier lynch and they're too afraid to join any other wagon.

[Creature]

Oh look, we're L-1.

[Creature]

Well, if jester wants to win, they could just claim and we wouldn't have any reason to not lynch them. Though, I doubt someone would let someone get such an easy win.

[Creature]

I wished we didn't have so many inactive players (though, maybe I just haven't paid enough attention).

[Creature]

How to win as jester:

Claim you're jester and keep stating you're serious about it.

Town won't lose anything (in fact it'll even help them) by lynching you.

[Creature]

UNVOTE:

[Creature]

I'll let Desperado prove he has these abilities then.

[Creature]

Also, no JavaJoe pls.

[Creature]

Maybe we could wagon massive who's literally ignoring everything?

[Creature]

As scum I am inactive compared to the other players. As town I am active compared to the other players.

That's the difference.

[Creature]

I haven't started working with townreads because I don't think I'd have enough of them.

[Creature]

Sure, I could go with Gingham.

VOTE: GinghamDog

[Creature]

Who's scum from the three of us then?

[Creature]

We could also all be three town who genuinely thought Gingham could be scum.

[Creature]

I won't understand Desp's role well until I see somewhere how that role works (if it is somewhere).

[Creature]

Who was your target again?

[Creature]

VOTE: Almost50

[Creature]

We got to 4 days left so quickly and yet it feels we haven't done much.

[Creature]

Both Almost50 and GinghamDog look good to go.

[Creature]

1. Despe

rado*

(half strike)

2. Beethoven0203 TheBrie*

3. massive*

4. SnarkySnowman*

5. Creature*

6. Joey_ Almost50*
7. Rautherdir*
8. boring*

9. Javajoe24*

10. GinghamDog*

11. podoboq*

12. GuiltyLion*

13. Chickadee*

[Creature]

Who would you wagon from the striked?

[Creature]

Yes, so did Snarky.

[Creature]

Okay, maybe I could consider Chickadee.

What could be the case for Chickadee?

[Creature]

Chick!scum.

Unless you think you can towncase Chick.

[Creature]

Never understood how Snarky wagon started.

Do you think scum are pulling counterwagons to scum!Chickadee? Who are these scum pulling counterwagons?

[Creature]

podoboq, I guess you know scum!Chickadee well.

[Creature]

If all these Desp, SS, Chickadee wagons were town, then basically we gotta look who seemed to be enjoying the situation.

[Creature]

Hmm, maybe someone who opposed one or two of them yet didn't try to find somewhere out of that circle?

[Creature]

Oh right, I forgot, what happened during Night 0?

[Creature]

Yeah, maybe activity isn't the greatest way to sort me, still there are other ways to sort me (though you'll have to find out).

[Creature]

My main page on the wiki needs to be remade, but I'm sorta lazy to do it.

[Creature]

It's starting to feel like someone WANTS us to no-lynch.

We've got almost two days, and massive is l-2. Calm down.

Still, we gotta have a backup incase we decide to not lynch massive.

[Creature]

idk, massive wagon was ok.

[Creature]

Just in a few occasions I stop wagoning someone I think is scummy just because of the wagon.

[Creature]

(even though I'm not voting in the wagon, I support it a bit)

[Creature]

What a productive Day 1 we had...

Hopefully we get lucky tonight...

[Creature]

I'm not mad at Rauther because I know what he's doing.

[Creature]

If Rauther is town, I feel like atleast two or three scum joined in, though, likely one of them were the first to push.

[Creature]

Hopefully we get lucky tonight...

You have a date????

Wished I did.

[Creature]

So this is literally the "you better not die as town" game.

[Creature]

It must suck to be town and die when there's a black goo around.

[Creature]

Black Goo (cult; super-rare; 4+ players): Whenever a player targets you with an action, they will join your cult as another black goo.

[Creature]

I think we could make the Black Goos claim (if they have more than one) and we all target them.

[Creature]

I won't bother black goo hunting for today.

[Creature]

Well, we could lynch mafia instead, they're nearly taking majority.

[Creature]

Did massive claim anything?

[Creature]

Hey, I could wagon Javajoe.

[Creature]

Also, why is Chickadee scum again?

[Creature]

Huh, well, now that Java claimed, it makes me think scum is in Desp, SS and Chick.

Did anyone receive Desp's CPR?

[Creature]

I thought we were talking about in Rauther's wagon.

[Creature]

Why are you saying desp is scum over A50, who confirmed that he received the ability that desp gave him.

Did not know.

[Creature]

Also, where am I defending A50?

[Creature]

but indirectly by not bringing them up

-_-

[Creature]

A50 isn't even happening rn -_-

[Creature]

Players are talking about A50? Where?

[Creature]

Also, I was looking at the Rauther wagon (A50 isn't there). SS and Chick seemed town, so that left Desp.

[Creature]

Javajoe's role is more buyable than Desp's role.

[Creature]

VOTE: Almost50

[Creature]

We might as well massclaim.

[Creature]

I'm tired of this fight to get a wagon to near lynch and then we have to worry about claims.

[Creature]

Na, but rn let's see if we get lucky.

[Creature]

Question directed to anyone who played with SnarkySnowman a decent number of times, if you didn't it's likely you'll be ignored

What do you think about SnarkySnowman?

[Creature]

Census Taker could still be mafia-aligned, why are players townreading TheBrie?

[Creature]

Hint: Chickadee's PoE isn't horrible at all.

[Creature]

How am I "absolutely not town"?

[Creature]

A50 has confirmed Desp's role

idk, I believe Java's role. While I don't think Desp is fakeclaiming, I'm still paranoid of him.

[Creature]

Are you scumreading her? Or are you just asking this question to throw shade?

I'm wondering, because it seems pretty easy to just townread TheBrie out of her role.

[Creature]

If A50 flips town, scum might win with Desp's CPR.

[Creature]

If A50 flips town, then I'll consider Chickadee as scum.

Though, I still think her PoE was good.

[Creature]

Oh right, A50 probably shot one of podo/Gingham. Either he shot podo (aka he's goo) or he shot Gingham (and then I wonder why he thinks I'm town who killed podo and became goo).

[Creature]

I believe he thinks you were goo and Podo targetted you last night before getting killed by scum.

I thought only who targeted podo would be recruited.

[Creature]

The most likely explanation given Brie's census is that podo targeted goo and became goo on the night he died

-_-

[Creature]

What does it have to do with podo/other goo targeting and making me a goo?

[Creature]

Normal meaning:
Absolutely = Completely, totally, the most positive possible

Mafiascum meaning:
Absolutely = Probably wrong

[Creature]

Well, idk, I don't see myself instantly assuming that's a scumclaim.

[Creature]

No need to run and hide
It's a wonderful wonderful life
No need to laugh and cry
It's a wonderful wonderful life

[Creature]

Chickadee probably has no idea on how to find the goo (if there's one).

[Creature]

Oh man....

[Creature]

Is there a possibility Java is the scum version of the role he claimed?

[Creature]

idk, the game shouldn't be too predictable, specially if it's role madness.

[Creature]

Town must have got plenty of night actions and a bunch of weaponry against the black goos.

[Creature]

Also, I'm aiming for the scum that can't recruit town and has nightkill power.

[Creature]

Who's more likely mafia (not goo, mafia)?

[Creature]

I guess TheBrie also played with Chick (and actually paid more attention to me) during Micro 700.

[Creature]

idk, this game seemed antitownsided, not sure why mod would screw town even more.

[Creature]

Massclaim time?

[Creature]

Okay, I think it's Snarky or massive.

[Creature]

idk about black goo.

[Creature]

I am not goo

nor am I.

[Creature]

massive?

[Creature]

I guess we'll have to lynch Desperado if only no one else claims goo.

[Creature]

massive, are you goo or not?

[Creature]

Yeah, Desperado likely got goo.

[Creature]

Oh lol

[Creature]

SnarkySnowman, role?

[Creature]

I'm feeling tempted to just "fuck it" vote.

[Creature]

Is it possible to use it now?

[Creature]

Cephalopod. It's some kind of JOAT.

[Creature]

N1 I did nothing
N2 I hid (it's basically commute, except I can still be targeted by other actions)
N3 I watched TheBrie - No visits

[Creature]

Nothing either.

[Creature]

Joe was a cephalopod on N1. It seems a little surprising have both a weird morphing role and one of the roles it can morph into.

I treated him as pretty much town because I thought he morphed into my role.

[Creature]

Vote the one I think is scum the most without hesitating.

Though, right now I'm starting to hesitate.

[Creature]

Why can't you be scum?

[Creature]

I felt like you were most likely to be targeted, and atleast I would know whether the last scum got ninja or not.

[Creature]

Why are we analysing the black goo cult rather than the flipped mafia?

[Creature]

Not hammering.

[Creature]

Also, this time I'm not pulling a Newbie 1794 where I cautiously say "not hammering", someone unvotes and I gotta wait until someone is brought to L-1 again.

[Creature]

Okay, I'm checking that revive.

[Creature]

What did Chickadee claim again?

[Creature]

Oh nvm, you mean't Gingham.

[Creature]

Well, that's basically it.

VOTE: Snarky

[Creature]

It's gonna be less painful if it turns out TheBrie was scum but had revive.

It's gonna be more painful if I failed to realise a detail.

[Creature]

That would be the first time I would win a 3p LyLo.

[Creature]

Oh nice, now I have to deduce who's trolling...

[Creature]

Do I count this as win or draw?

[Creature]

The reviver literally (and indirectly) won us the game.

[Creature]

Good thing I didn't notice that clear.

[Creature]

When did you become Goo, Creature?

I became goo the night massive died, when I tracked him.