Mini Normal 1920 (Game Over)

[gerryoat]

1) It's a NAI slip then
2) ???
3) So?
4) This literally is my explanation

VOTE: Mulch

Dumbo. I think your town too.

this post speaks to me sooooo much. Cause I can see myself saying that to someone I TR that votes me lmao. Mulch is still obvs town.

[gerryoat]

So MMM is scum?

Hmmm, do I commit a vote before even reading the rest of the thread? Well you only live once.

Actually I've been shot like 20 times playing mafia maybe that doesn't apply.

Vote: MMM

bad first post

[EeveeLution Army]

Where's your vote, LMK?

This THIS THIIIIIIIIIIISSSSSSSSSSSS is the worst post of the thread so far, my god. Just cause he catches up doesn't mean he needs to vote anyone. This seems so bad it literally pains me on the inside.

The read list he provided says otherwise.

Having reads doesn't mean you instantly have to put a vote on especially if you have two scumreads

[gerryoat]

hey i can read tonight, please dont end the day before i'm able to

I particularly don't care if day 1 is short or long. Day 1 is the worst phase of the game in my opinion but it seems like on this site people consider it "towny" to push for long day 1s. The longer the day 1 the more likely you are to catch scum and the shorter the day 1 the more likely a mislynch is. I'm not gonna debate this either way I'm just saying what I've been told over and over again. Seems to me gerry wants it to be known he wants a longer day 1. Yeah this might be a stretch but it stuck out to me.

VOTE: gerryoat

uhhh.. even if this wasnt on me, I'd say this is a very strange post. Maybe can you explain it a bit more? So because I could read later, and not have time to read at the time, makes me scum? What if i'm actually busy? Or are you assuming whoever can't read at the time but can post is scum trying to extend the day?

[gerryoat]

Actually for my sanity, could Eveee, MMM, and tchill talk about their mafia experience?

I forgot to answer this.

I started playing mafia around december 2015.
It's more fast paced then here.

I recently started playing here.

I'm glad to answer any follow up questions

From EpicMafia?

From PS!(pokemon showdown)

I've been there since late 2015/early 2016

omg. do you battle on there? i love pokemon showdown lol, we should battle sometime or something

Sure challenge me anytime

Back to the game - i do have a townread on formerfish it isn't a big one but its there.

I think fish is meh. But then again, I personally dont like the long posts quote a bunch style.

[gerryoat]

Where's your vote, LMK?

This THIS THIIIIIIIIIIISSSSSSSSSSSS is the worst post of the thread so far, my god. Just cause he catches up doesn't mean he needs to vote anyone. This seems so bad it literally pains me on the inside.

The read list he provided says otherwise.

just because he gave a reads list, doesnt mean he has to vote someone.

[EeveeLution Army]

How do you know they haven't been here? For all you know they are reading what we are saying right now and blatantly ignoring it

They have 3 out of the 242 posts in this thread. They haven't.

And if they're ignoring? Town can be lazy and not give effort. It's not AI.

I've already stated i just want him to contribute so i can get some form of read on him.

There are plenty of people contributing and creating content we can use, why do you care so much about the one guy who hasn't said much yet? Do you have reads set for everyone else and this is your lynch pin? Could finding out his alignment change everything for you?

Why don't you figure out who you think is town, see where they are voting and ask some questions. I noticed you asked for my opinion, then I give it, and you barely acknowledge my post. What was the point of asking my opinion, which your reasoning is suspect as well in that, if you aren't going to take that opinion and do something with it?

His reaction and questioning here seem more town motivated then scum

[gerryoat]

MMM - 5 (aronagrundy, massive, Lil Uzi Vert, Formerfish, GreyIce)

FINAL THOUGHTS

Based on my reread, there is no way in hell MMM deserved those votes on him, and we should really break that down.

Arona hadn't really read the game and had been prod dodging at the time.

massive also hadn't posted much and SR MMM for pointing out that he hadn't

LUV is very likely scum based on all his posts, and the awful post that seemed too forced to be real.

Former fish has been meh to me all game so far

GreyIce doesn't read and just votes the highest wagon at the time which was very weird.


VOTE: Lil Uzi

^This needs to be lynched today, and when it flips scum, I think I have a good idea of who the others could be. I don't wanna say yet, since I want to see how some things play out before i do.

[gerryoat]

How do you know they haven't been here? For all you know they are reading what we are saying right now and blatantly ignoring it

They have 3 out of the 242 posts in this thread. They haven't.

And if they're ignoring? Town can be lazy and not give effort. It's not AI.

I've already stated i just want him to contribute so i can get some form of read on him.

There are plenty of people contributing and creating content we can use, why do you care so much about the one guy who hasn't said much yet? Do you have reads set for everyone else and this is your lynch pin? Could finding out his alignment change everything for you?

Why don't you figure out who you think is town, see where they are voting and ask some questions. I noticed you asked for my opinion, then I give it, and you barely acknowledge my post. What was the point of asking my opinion, which your reasoning is suspect as well in that, if you aren't going to take that opinion and do something with it?

His reaction and questioning here seem more town motivated then scum

Okay, I'll ISO him in a bit and give him a look.

[gerryoat]

Also MMM's replaceout is NAI, btw. could do that as scum or maf. But, personally I think his posts were townish despite like 1 or 2

[EeveeLution Army]

Gerry makes good point and tbh i have to agree in this that the best vote here is

VOTE: lil uzi

After looking through the evidence he is scummier then the rest of the pl other then people who haven't talked as much but thats NAI

[gerryoat]

Town: Mulch, Eevee, Dany
Maybe town: MMM slot
Everyone else
scum: LUV

[gerryoat]

i lied there is ppl i think that are scum in the everyone else, but it would really ruin what i think is gonna happen next

[EeveeLution Army]

Interesting concept here gerry

[EeveeLution Army]

Any reason you townread mulch? I find him more null

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Where's your vote, LMK?

This THIS THIIIIIIIIIIISSSSSSSSSSSS is the worst post of the thread so far, my god. Just cause he catches up doesn't mean he needs to vote anyone. This seems so bad it literally pains me on the inside.

The read list he provided says otherwise.

Having reads doesn't mean you instantly have to put a vote on especially if you have two scumreads

Voting is one, if not, the most the powerful tool town has at their disposal because it helps discern information about players and actually lynch scum.

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Where's your vote, LMK?

This THIS THIIIIIIIIIIISSSSSSSSSSSS is the worst post of the thread so far, my god. Just cause he catches up doesn't mean he needs to vote anyone. This seems so bad it literally pains me on the inside.

The read list he provided says otherwise.

just because he gave a reads list, doesnt mean he has to vote someone.

It's about the strength of the reads he gave in that list. Why are you avoiding talking about that?

[Lil Uzi Vert]

MMM - 5 (aronagrundy, massive, Lil Uzi Vert, Formerfish, GreyIce)

FINAL THOUGHTS

Based on my reread, there is no way in hell MMM deserved those votes on him, and we should really break that down.

Arona hadn't really read the game and had been prod dodging at the time.

massive also hadn't posted much and SR MMM for pointing out that he hadn't

LUV is very likely scum based on all his posts, and the awful post that seemed too forced to be real.

Former fish has been meh to me all game so far

GreyIce doesn't read and just votes the highest wagon at the time which was very weird.


VOTE: Lil Uzi

^This needs to be lynched today, and when it flips scum, I think I have a good idea of who the others could be. I don't wanna say yet, since I want to see how some things play out before i do.

Could you explain which posts of mine are scummy and why?

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Gerry makes good point and tbh i have to agree in this that the best vote here is

VOTE: lil uzi

After looking through the evidence he is scummier then the rest of the pl other then people who haven't talked as much but thats NAI

What's changed from 279?

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Right! Well that happened quickly! Apologies for the afk, long story short Thursdays = busy af and today was report writing day (im a teacher).

Onto the good stuff:
I have read through the thread and my initial reactions are:
Mastina: coolest mod. Makes shit so organised and easy!

Seriously though, there has been a fair amount of posting so going to do my best to address what I can. If i miss anything just hmu

Arona: Nuffin to say, hasn't posted in the last 2 days.
Gerry: Pretty useless posting, troll votes on mod, silly statements, but to be fair to him, most of these were start game stuff and he has promised to catch up. Verdict still out
Bomber: I like his early comments but the stuff about his gameplay/style irks me. It seems like an attempt to distance himself and be able to use this as an excuse to back up or withdraw from comments he has/will make. He has done a bit of pushing and resisting to comments made, which I like. I feel like as scum, he could have buddied with Mulch without too much suspicion, rather than "poking the beast" so to say. This doesn't make him town, but i will hold my verdict until he reveals to use his magical play style that he has been training off site for all these years
Danny: His posts are wierd. Idk just from re reading his ISO I can't really get a clear idea from him. He has posted throughout the last two days, but hasnt really contributed to any of the major ideas being thrown out there. Seems to be more focused on himself and trying to keep a low profile, whilst still being active.
Mulch: obviously the big dog in town. He has thrown himself right out there and is doing his best to scum hunt (or at least put on a show of doing so). I'm weary of him as his play style is very similar to the last scum team I versed. Basically go out guns blazing, try get as many people to lock you as town and go from there. For the time being I guess he is my strongest Townlean, not because of what he is saying, but rather the way others are reacting to him.

Fish: Very early buddy attempts with Mulch. The way the game has progressed, I highly doubt both of these guys are scum. IMO either one is scum (therefore other is town) or they are both town. I feel as though Fish is focusing on the content of posts and using this to inform his votes/opinions, which I really like.
Uzi: His early game is an attempt to blend in, his mid posts are all focused on him and then his later posts seem to be focused on moving attention away from himself. I don't really like this progression at all and it feels slightly scummy to me.

Tchill: Seems pretty neutral to me so far, just going with the flow, will have to see what he comes up with before I can make a serious judgement.

MMM: The wagon we have going so far. His early posts seem genuine, but not the biggest fan of his mid/later posts. He seems to be employing a similar strategy to what i mentioned about Mulch, and at the moment it seems like a bit of a dick measuring contest between Mulch and MMM. Do I think he is scum? Maybe, but not my strongest scum read at the moment.

Massive: Okay Mr "low-content poster as both alignments". I don't mind if this is the case, but would like an insight from you here. I do believe post count is NAI, but so far don't have too much from you, so would love to see more.

Right that covers my reads list so far. Will make sure I stay on top of the game from here on out. Like I said, let me know if you have any questions.

I think the bolded are good enough reasons to have put a vote down.

[EeveeLution Army]

Gerry makes good point and tbh i have to agree in this that the best vote here is

VOTE: lil uzi

After looking through the evidence he is scummier then the rest of the pl other then people who haven't talked as much but thats NAI

What's changed from 279?

Alot of rereading, rethinking and 200 posts are you saying reads cant change

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Gerry makes good point and tbh i have to agree in this that the best vote here is

VOTE: lil uzi

After looking through the evidence he is scummier then the rest of the pl other then people who haven't talked as much but thats NAI

What's changed from 279?

Alot of rereading, rethinking and 200 posts are you saying reads cant change

I didn't say that.

I said what's changed. I see that you agree with Gerry's reasoning. Which posts of mine have made you look at them in a different light and why? Why are they scummy now?

[Lil Uzi Vert]

Gerry makes good point and tbh i have to agree in this that the best vote here is

VOTE: lil uzi

After looking through the evidence he is scummier then the rest of the pl other then people who haven't talked as much but thats NAI

What's changed from 279?

Alot of rereading, rethinking and 200 posts are you saying reads cant change

I didn't say that.

I said what's changed. I see that you agree with Gerry's reasoning. Which posts of mine have you looked at in a different light and why? Why are they scummy now?

EBWOP.

[EeveeLution Army]

Not really. Is there someone you want me to sort right now?

So if you haven't been actually sorting anyone, what have you been doing? How have you been helping the town?

And why are you asking your scum read who to sort?

What do you mean by sort here

[Mulch]

Woah, I see some hard-core pocketing of me by goat