Mini Normal 1920 (Game Over)

[Formerfish]

And you vote me but your scum pool is massive and Eevee?

You don't even mention me in that post?

Because you have a guilty on you, there's not much to add to that.

And answer the question, you think that as caught scum I spearheaded the lynch of my partner in Chick, right?

[iDanyboy]

Then why not push this yesterday?

Because I can push it today.

And answer the question, you think that as caught scum I spearheaded the lynch of my partner in Chick, right?

You never Uzi did.

@Massive It doesn't drive me nuts. I also mentioned it yesterday before I 'knew you were right'.

[Formerfish]

Reread that exchange again. I'm the first vote on the train that lynches her. I get Uzi back on the lynch bro.

[Formerfish]

VOTE: Unvote

VOTE: Chick

This is the right vote Uzi.

VOTE: Chick

[iDanyboy]

Reread that exchange again. I'm the first vote on the train that lynches her. I get Uzi back on the lynch bro.

There were two guilties and you voted the one not you :shocked: There's nothing you could say to make me unvote you since you have a guilty on you.

[Formerfish]

Oh for fucks sake. What possible fucking motivation could I have as scum to actively push her like that?

[GreyICE]

Okay, moving on:

Also any particular reason you read massive?

Not enough content.

Spoiler alert: I am generally a low-content poster as both alignments. See, oh, any game I've played in the last two years where some scumbum always feels the urge to mention this. Activity is NAI. But trying to play it like it is is the oldest (and most transparent) trick in the book.

VOTE: MMM

VOTE: MMM

1. I'm not the first person to mention this
2. If you had actually read my fucking reads post you'd see it's not even a major indicator for my reads since my actual scum leans based on actual content are actually listed in the scummy section compared to people like you who simply haven't posted enough to warrant an actual read

1. Please quote who else has mentioned this.
2. That's a lot of anger for one vote mate.

This is pretty good indication to me that Massive/MMM are probably not scum together. Bussing happens, but bussing tends to not happen like this. MMM's reasoning was bad, Massive rightly votes him for it, MMM goes "why me?"

Why me = fry me FYI. That's a good rule of thumb in mafia.

[GreyICE]

I still like AronaGrundy, although review shows his activity is mostly null. Lots of townie-sounding stuff around votes at non-critical times, not a lot of moving the game forward during decision points. It's a bad combination. I'd be fine with him hanging, although I don't know if it's a scumflip.

Mulch remains psychotic town.

I'm starting to feel a lynch order of:

Fro99er (general principle - this level of not playing mafia is not acceptable, and gosh I wasn't impressed by LMK's 4 scummy posts. Do you really want this guy of all fucking players to be the scum who wins the game? I'd rather give it to literally anyone)
If game still ongoing: Eevee
If game still ongoing: Arona

[massive]

@Massive It doesn't drive me nuts. I also mentioned it yesterday before I 'knew you were right'.

Well, you're definitely the first to complain more about the methods than the result, but OK. You do you.

[Fro99er]

Hey y'all I'm here. You lynched while I was on V/LA. Going to catch up now.

[Fro99er]

Off of my having skimmed

most

of the game, here's what I feel so far (I don't have a handle yet on replacements and such, just that I replaced MMM, so mind the names if they're wrong):
LUV town
Mulch scum
Eevee Town

I don't have my notes in front of me right now, so more to come later.

Mulch, you voted me based off my read list, know that I have not fully caught up yet? Not a very towny move. I promise to ISO you a bit when I have properly caught up though to get a better look at you one way or the other. However, you understand that I can't just take your word on this being your best towny game. It just seems to me that you're doing a lot of awfully anti-town things for this being your best towny game.

Mulch is town. That's not a scum-scum interaction. A cross-bus would Chick would more likely be calling Mulch scummy than anti-town and "not towny" and the promise to come back and look at you is so fake.

[Fro99er]

FF is prob town for pushing the Chick lynch, while Chick was just half-assed about the FF lynch.

If it was two caught scum, I'd expect both to be either bussing hard, or half-assing votes on each other once two scum guilties were outed.

[Fro99er]

Twenty-ninth Votecount

:

(First Votecount D3

)

Formerfish - 2 (GreyICE, aronagrundy)

Not Voting - 7 (EeveeLution Army, Fro99er, ReplacedIn, iDanyboy, Mulch, Formerfish, massive)

arona why are you voting FF?

[Fro99er]

Doesn't yours just mean chick isn't a vt tho

Mulch, chick claimed vt

realizes chick isn't a VT despite claiming VT, yet pushes for a FF lynch because...

Ok here's the thing. We have two claimed guilties. One of them is getting lynched.

I refuse to have the WIFOM claim bullshit going on with a claimed cop last for more than this day. We figure out if the CLAIMED COP is lying today

Makes no sense. What does figuring anything out about the claimed cop have to do with this. What about the macho Neapolitan? This isn't even a reason to go for FF, yet today arona is back on the FF train after actively trying to push for former for reasons that aren't even reasons.

Just conveniently ignores the whole Chick got caught claiming VT, yet can't be VT thing to push the other guilty for a worse reason.

VOTE: Arona

[Fro99er]

if you think they're both lying why does it matter lmao

oh my god mulch you just said that they're both scum

frustrated scum is frustrated that mulchy is considering that the Chick guilty is a solid guilty, while the FF guilty could have a roleblock.

1618 Arona.

what happens if chick flips town?

Pointless.

If chick is the lynch that's fine tbh

This day needs to end. Any objections to me hammering?

Then is suddenly half baked about a chick lynch and asks to hammer when it's inevitable

[Fro99er]

I doubt GI is scum here faking a guilty on FF though.

If he's scum he just says he was roleblocked as loyal and fakes a guilty, but then his doubt about being roleblocked today just to say he successfully targeted iDanyboy today makes no sense if he's continuing on a scum gambit. He'd just reinforce he was roleblocked D1, but now he's considering he might not have been. It's too paranoia-ish to be scum.

Maybe scum has an odd-night or non-consecutive roleblocker?

[Fro99er]

massive is scum too

Pushes MMM, but then says "they've given enough" of chicks slot. If you think they are scum, push that harder. Convince others. Do something.

Then the guilty on Chick happens and suddenly no vote, but starts asking LUV if he breadcrumbed and "WIFOM" in my head.

Gonna vote FF because I feel like I know what GreyICE gambits look like but I also feel like there's gotta still be other things to do today.

never follows up on this.

There's no desire from massive to find scum, period.

VOTE: massive

[GreyICE]

Okay change "lynch Fro99er" to "strongly recommend on all levels"

[aronagrundy]

frogger please reread my day 2 posts to get a better idea of my thought process. I didn't really say it too clearly but I favored formerfish because I strongly townread greyice due to the way he claimed. I also explained how I felt like formerfish was flailing. Toward the end of the day phase I became more ok with lynching chickadee, especially because she was acting guilty too.

my vote is on formerfish rn because a cop is claiming a guilty result on him.

[Fro99er]

lol that's all it took?

GI -- talk to me about FF vs. Chick interaction. I don't see that as scum v scum.

pedit: hi arona

[aronagrundy]

if you think they're both lying why does it matter lmao

oh my god mulch you just said that they're both scum

frustrated scum is frustrated that mulchy is considering that the Chick guilty is a solid guilty, while the FF guilty could have a roleblock.

i was more frustrated with mulch suddenly touting the idea of a grey/luv scumteam

[Fro99er]

@arona -- and you're just willing to go along with the result instead of figure out if the result is valid or not?

how was FF flailing? Just because you townread GI means he's got a confirmed guilty? No. Chick was far more a confirmed guilty. Claimed VT, LUV's result said not VT. So unless you thought LUV was scum gambiting to get Chick lynched, then you fail there. And that wasn't the push you made.

[Fro99er]

arona thoughts on massive please.

[Fro99er]

I just see massive and arona yelling at each other about activity, but no attempt to actually sort each other.

[aronagrundy]

also why the hell are we claiming that formerfish is town for pushing chickadee? What else was he supposed to do? The fact that luv guiltied her before formerfish said anything about her negates any talk of intiative tbh

and let's not forget that his first instinct was to 1v1 greyice...