Mini Normal 1920 (Game Over)

[aronagrundy]

[meme]

[aronagrundy]

VOTE: MMM

[aronagrundy]

I think mulch is manic town

[aronagrundy]

VOTE: MMM

[aronagrundy]

RVS is the worst thing on this site by far

Not necessarily, RVS can be used to get reactions, get motivation, and can be used to synchronize town.

I don't think I've ever played in a game with a town that was anything close to synchronized

[aronagrundy]

I came in to low key prodge bc I won't really have time to read this til the weekend but I'll answer your question.

Both votes were serious to an extent. I thought MMM's tone seemed forced (which is why I voted them the first time) and then I didn't like their lmk vote. I read it as a serious response to lmk's gamma vote. I wasn't very clear with my reasoning because I wasn't really taking the game that seriously yet

[aronagrundy]

Prod received

[aronagrundy]

Aka reading now

[aronagrundy]

Want to apologize--I'm halfway through the thread now, probably should have v/la'd through the weekend and I was just as busy yesterday.

I have no idea what y'all are talking about now but the 3 biggest things I'm thinking now are that bomberman is scum, mmm's self vote felt forced but so was luv trying to end the day early and I doubt theyre both scum, and gamm sounds like an oral disease.

[aronagrundy]

Oh mmm replaced out. Hm

[aronagrundy]

Hey yinz I'm back

[aronagrundy]

Why is lmk getting pressure and not me lol

[aronagrundy]

unvote

[aronagrundy]

I actually get town vibes from a lot of y'all so I guess I'm PoEing

Town: luv, mulch, eevee, chick, (this contradicts myself but...I changed my mind lol), gerry
Null town: grey, ff

[aronagrundy]

did tchill bring himself to l-1 lmao

[aronagrundy]

hey luv you're probably town and i basically just skimmed the game

want to summarize the wagon/case for me plz

[aronagrundy]

oh uh i meant the tchill wagon

also tchill why did you do that...?

[aronagrundy]

Hello. I need everyone to participate in an exercise. It has two steps:

1) Post whether you used an action that might have roleblocked me last night
2) Do not comment as to why I might ask this.

I may have a reason, if you don't like it after then lynch me. It's start of day 2, you play this game.

you're silly

but no, i did not

[aronagrundy]

arona, who's scum?

not sure. my thought process was mostly poe when the day ended. The tchill wagon should help.

bomberman was coming off as scum to me throughout the thread but i'm not sure about his replacement

my gut tells me that there's 1 scum in danyboy/massive due to activity.

[aronagrundy]

VOTE: formerfish

[aronagrundy]

oh wait

unvote

don't want to kill discussion if ff hammers himself (i doubt he would though)

[aronagrundy]

Doesn't yours just mean chick isn't a vt tho

[aronagrundy]

Also loyal = can only target your own alignment, I believe

[aronagrundy]

Mulch, chick claimed vt

[aronagrundy]

I realized she said she claimed d1 and I found it

[aronagrundy]

VOTE: formerfish

[aronagrundy]

L-1 obviously

I can't see luv and grey both lying. If ff flips town, this should confirm luv

[aronagrundy]

can we just lynch formerfish already?

he's flailing. His words are indignant but keeps on acting like greyice might not be scum after all...? Like his vote on greyice and he said he was 1V1ing him. Grey should be confirmed scum to him. His attitude makes no sense for town here.

[aronagrundy]

my gut tells me that there's 1 scum in danyboy/massive due to activity.

Can I just ask what, and I'm quoting The Rock here, IN THE BLUE HELL would make you post this about either of us when both of us have more posts than you?

To be fair I'm usually more active than this. It's mostly that in every game I've played with 2+ scum I feel like there's at least one scum that just lurks in the background and both you and dany fit the bill. I know my activity level has sucked this game but it's not like I can suspect myself.

[aronagrundy]

How could he be manipulated town?

[aronagrundy]

Well my problem is that you seem to be operating under #2 even though you claim to be considering #1. If that makes sense.

I mean, if you're town, sorry, but there's no way this day doesn't end with your lynch.

[aronagrundy]

Hold on lol

Wasn't that the point of grey's first post this day phase?

[aronagrundy]

Though, it's not like a scum rb would out themselves

[aronagrundy]

I don't think mulch is scum. He comes off as confused town here

[aronagrundy]

(content)

ok idk about you but the idea of scum!grey and scum!luv deciding to claim guilties on town and their partner respectively is a little out there lmao

<<< Added "(content)" to the quote in order to repair the quote tag. >>>

[aronagrundy]

Ok well that's a new way to fuck up a quote tag

<<< When quoting a post and removing content from the quote, you must leave SOMETHING inside--it can be a single character, but it must exist. (Quote)(/Quote) will break; (Quote).(/Quote) will not. (Thus why when I cut content out, I place a comment to the effect of "[-snip-]" in there.)

Fortunately the mod is here to fix broken tags, and thus, I have given the appropriate remedy. >>>

[aronagrundy]

Aronagrundy u seem to be lurking

i'm like the fifth most active person today after ff, grey, luv, and you lmao

a lot of it is just that formerfish is the best lynch here and i'm getting a headache reading this all

[aronagrundy]

Ok here's the thing. We have two claimed guilties. One of them is getting lynched.

I refuse to have the WIFOM claim bullshit going on with a claimed cop last for more than this day. We figure out if the CLAIMED COP is lying today

[aronagrundy]

I feel like Formerfish is town through tone and actions

no, he's not

[aronagrundy]

Ok here's the thing. We have two claimed guilties. One of them is getting lynched.

I refuse to have the WIFOM claim bullshit going on with a claimed cop last for more than this day. We figure out if the CLAIMED COP is lying today

Lil Uzi is a stronger claim

how?

[aronagrundy]

if you think they're both lying why does it matter lmao

[aronagrundy]

oh my god mulch you just said that they're both scum

[aronagrundy]

1618 Arona.

what happens if chick flips town?

[aronagrundy]

mulch i don't understand your thought process at all

[aronagrundy]

Uzi Greyice team confirmed

how would they both be telling the truth if they're both scum?

[aronagrundy]

ok.

a lot of my thought process right now is that formerfish really came off as caught scum to me, hence i want to lynch him

[aronagrundy]

i want to hear from everyone else since it's just like 5 of us

it's not the end of the world if we lynch chickadee, but i would still prefer ff by far

[aronagrundy]

I'm on the same wavelength with replaced in re: grey here.

Grey is almost confirmed town to me at this point

[aronagrundy]

If chick is the lynch that's fine tbh

[aronagrundy]

This day needs to end. Any objections to me hammering?

[aronagrundy]

Hey grey what did you do last night

[aronagrundy]

VOTE: formerfish

kk!

[aronagrundy]

frogger please reread my day 2 posts to get a better idea of my thought process. I didn't really say it too clearly but I favored formerfish because I strongly townread greyice due to the way he claimed. I also explained how I felt like formerfish was flailing. Toward the end of the day phase I became more ok with lynching chickadee, especially because she was acting guilty too.

my vote is on formerfish rn because a cop is claiming a guilty result on him.

[aronagrundy]

if you think they're both lying why does it matter lmao

oh my god mulch you just said that they're both scum

frustrated scum is frustrated that mulchy is considering that the Chick guilty is a solid guilty, while the FF guilty could have a roleblock.

i was more frustrated with mulch suddenly touting the idea of a grey/luv scumteam

[aronagrundy]

also why the hell are we claiming that formerfish is town for pushing chickadee? What else was he supposed to do? The fact that luv guiltied her before formerfish said anything about her negates any talk of intiative tbh

and let's not forget that his first instinct was to 1v1 greyice...

[aronagrundy]

can we just lynch formerfish already?

he's flailing. His words are indignant but keeps on acting like greyice might not be scum after all...? Like his vote on greyice and he said he was 1V1ing him. Grey should be confirmed scum to him. His attitude makes no sense for town here.

I explained formerfish flailing here^^

[aronagrundy]

@arona -- and you're just willing to go along with the result instead of figure out if the result is valid or not?

how was FF flailing? Just because you townread GI means he's got a confirmed guilty? No. Chick was far more a confirmed guilty. Claimed VT, LUV's result said not VT. So unless you thought LUV was scum gambiting to get Chick lynched, then you fail there. And that wasn't the push you made.

how do you suggest figuring it out?

[aronagrundy]

Also I null read massive. I still have a gut feeling about scum lurking, but his posts do seem genuine

[aronagrundy]

<<< Additional note: A prod is outstanding on LmkGuy. He may no longer post in-thread obviously, but should he fail to respond to the prod via PM, we will be replacing him. There will be no need for a deadline extension/pause as we have a replacement lined up in the case where he fails to show up. >>>

If lmkguy was wolf mastina wouldent mention the part about responding to the prod


VIA PM

They woild just post in wolf chat


Also, the odds of mastina THINKING about him responding to it as pm means they are subconsciously thinking he's a villager

You can still make them pm you. I think I did this my first time modding so that players wouldn't make the assumption you're making lol

[aronagrundy]

alright i have some explaining to do

[aronagrundy]

i claim weak doctor

I targeted mulch n1 and grey n2. This is why I wanted to lynch ff so badly yesterday. Because if he flipped red, grey was confirmed town and I could protect him. Obviously I didn't die, but if there's a loyal cop, macho Neapolitan, and weak doctor uhhhhh there has to be a scum rb

This is also why I entered the day phase the way I did. Because at first I was excited because I thought grey was confirmed town but then I began to doubt

[aronagrundy]

I was trying to lay low but it's getting to the point where I think it's negatively impacting the town, so

[aronagrundy]

if there's a rb I really, really doubt I was blocked n1 so mulch is confirmed town btw

[aronagrundy]

yeah but why would they not block grey n2?

Obviously if grey is scum I was blocked n2, but I'm not sure if that's very likely

[aronagrundy]

i kind of feel bad because the last game i completed had all the PRs claim spontaneously for shits and gigs (cough frogger cough) but the wifom was making my head hurt...and if I was blocked n2 I was probably going to be killed tonight so I figured might as tackle the WIFOM head on

[aronagrundy]

actually i was leaning protecting ff n1 because I had doubts on my town read on him but no one would understand my crumb (look up pittsburgh dialect lol):

Hey yinz I'm back

I targeted mulch that night because I was confident he was town. I threw this quote out d2 in case I was killed and people wondered who I targeted n1:

I don't think mulch is scum. He comes off as confused town here

This was my crumb for grey:

I'm on the same wavelength with replaced in re: grey here.

Grey is almost confirmed town to me at this point

[aronagrundy]

I wasn't too concerned about screaming that mulch was confirmed to me because he was reasonably townread

[aronagrundy]

@grey

well yes, but they run the risk of the cop getting a guilty

[aronagrundy]

Like what about the wifom? they rb grey and he's like "oh lol didn't get a result again" and we're stuck wondering if grey is even telling the truth and can't figure out if we should believe his results

[aronagrundy]

No wait for massive

[aronagrundy]

unvote

Want Mulch's info, he's obvtown but let's do it right.

Nah, let's make this interesting.

VOTE: Former

UNVOTE:

[aronagrundy]

I'm basically waiting for mulch to claim

I think frogger is town tbh. He pushed me for admitted inconsistencies and even when he started by voting me I was responding by townreading him.

Also I don't think ff and frogger can be scum together

[aronagrundy]

Eevee is a player I need to get a better read on. Same with massive.

[aronagrundy]

hm...for the record, I'm still hesitant to treat grey as confirmed town.

Like. A weak doctor, loyal cop, and macho neapolitan is a ton of investigative power. Yeah the results leave a lot of room for roleblocking WIFOM, but it's still a lot. If there's a scum rb, why didn't they target grey last night? It just boggles my mind.

That said, if formerfish flips red, grey is definitely town. In no world does scum!grey decide to bus their partner like that lol

[aronagrundy]

Like let's say grey is scum...and there's a roleblocker. Grey claims to draw the other investigative role out, with grey's role leaving room for a poor result.

Thing is, that's a wild play and even though grey is experienced enough to pull it off, there's no way he could explain why he doesn't die at night eventually. And it's just less likely than--if formerfish flips green--grey simply being roleblocked.

This is mostly paranoia. Grey is most likely town.

[aronagrundy]

VOTE: formerfish

Heads i target grey
Tails i target replacedin

[aronagrundy]

wait mulch why the hell did you soft claim pr day 2

[aronagrundy]

my bad, thought it only applied to investigative roles

Ummm tails I target eevee

[aronagrundy]

Hm oh actually that makes sense. Should've thought more about night action resolution.

[aronagrundy]

And yeah I really doubt Grey is scum. I was just thinking it through

[aronagrundy]

I targeted grey last night so yeah there's a rb (agree with replacedin that it's odd night...otherwise grey wouldn't have gotten the result he did n2). On the bright side, this 100% confirms mulch and dany.

I'm going to reread, obviously looking at the 4 possible scum. Now that the WIFOM is cleared up I should be able to look at this with a clear head