Mini 1924: Mountainish Mafia GAME OVER!!!

[Carcalilly]

I've never been so confused at the start of a mafia game

[Carcalilly]

VOTE: Dwlee

you don't know who I am but I know who you are

[Carcalilly]

VOTE: Dwlee

you don't know who I am but I know who you are

No thoughts on Zach? Or me?

you post too much
gimme a sec to read I just really wanted that rvs vote

[Carcalilly]

interesting vote

why the same person as vedith?

I think I have a theory

Shadow=dark=scary=evil=mafia

[Carcalilly]

Just saying

And how the hell do you have 30 posts on the third page

[Carcalilly]

who wants to talk about the fact that there's a single role that the victory of town depends on?

[Carcalilly]

who wants to talk about the fact that there's a single role that the victory of town depends on?

what are you hoping to get out of this?

Usually I get into nice fights when talking about mechanics

Like I can sense stuff going down already

[Carcalilly]

Anyway, this is Mountainish (no roles???) with an end-all town role and a mafia rolecop?????

[Carcalilly]

IDK I'm questioning the balance and the actual setup. It's closed so all we can do is speculate

[Carcalilly]

then let's fight

the mafia mechanic discussion is at least more pro-town if you really want to go the setup spec discussion because scum probably have insight to what it means while town doesnt

all we know is that we cant let the mysterious role die and thats all we really

should

know (unless you know what that role is??)

so why not discuss the godfather mechanic instead?

Oh yeah but how do we do that exactly? Doctors? No, it's mountainish? Claim before lynch? Now the mafia will get them.

Godfather mechanic is a lot less interesting Imo. :')

[Carcalilly]

Carca is an awkward player. She says stupid shit that makes her look like scum, or makes her an easy push.

You know me well <3

[Carcalilly]

Yeah but now we're talking and I've got a wagon behind me as always. \o/

Wait it's 9:4 holy crap

guys no I never wanted the role to be outted
that's the last thing we want

I just wanted a way for us to combat this somehow.
We're all uninformed to an extent. The mafia probably doesn't know who the end all role is. Only the person with that role knows, and I don't want it to be just them with the game on their shoulders.

I want to figure out a way for us to help them without outting them. Which is difficult considering that scum can read and see everything we say.
Which is why I wondered about other power roles. If they exist, they're hidden, and none of us know about it.
It's hard to think of a balance of privacy and working together. A gamble at this point is too risky, but if I'm alive later just maybe...

[Carcalilly]

Rip I skimmed through the thing and panicked again
Aaaanyway if Dunn can lynch scum day 1 I'll gladly hand the game to them.
And if they're actually scum, we can take care of that later, lynching a scum is great even if the wagon was made by scum.

[Carcalilly]

Spoiler: 113

carcalilly is town

Okay, I just need you to defend this.

Anyway, this is Mountainish (no roles???) with an end-all town role and a mafia rolecop?????

? Were you assuming, knowing that this was a closed setup, that since it appeared scumsided it was definitely completely scumsided and town was set up to lose? Just wondering. It doesn't make sense.

IDK I'm questioning the balance and the actual setup. It's closed so all we can do is speculate

Definitely an implication of closed setups... yes.

then let's fight

the mafia mechanic discussion is at least more pro-town if you really want to go the setup spec discussion because scum probably have insight to what it means while town doesnt

all we know is that we cant let the mysterious role die and thats all we really

should

know (unless you know what that role is??)

so why not discuss the godfather mechanic instead?

Oh yeah but how do we do that exactly? Doctors? No, it's mountainish? Claim before lynch? Now the mafia will get them.

Godfather mechanic is a lot less interesting Imo. :')

Again, are you assuming town has nothing to combat scum advantage? In what way is that logical?


And if you're assuming otherwise, what benefit does discussing it like this have? At all?


Please help me clarify BC scummy

Well one, I was confused because there are technically roles in a no-role mechanic. I'm pretty sure mountainish means all VT and goons but apparently not here.

So if town does actually have other PRs then it's not mountainish and Ari lied to us all.

OK so look at out confirmed information:
-Mafia has a ROLECOP
-Town has an END-ALL role
-The game is titled "mountainish"

So during the night, mafia can probably rolecop one player, then kill another. That's clearing out two. If that's all there really is then in must be easy for them to find that role.

Also, the benefits have already taken action.

[Carcalilly]

What is this strange object

[Carcalilly]

In a setup where we're already weak, PoEing town's potential utilities and highlighting the one weakness we all know as a discussion point on mechanics is really... out there, to say the least.


VOTE: Carcalilly



Y not

Out there is how to play m9

[Carcalilly]

VOTE: Dwlee

you don't know who I am but I know who you are

That is a bit freaky.

On subject, I don't think carcalilly talking about the setup is a scumtell like people seemed to have reacted to it as.

I just remember playing a game with you on my alt like two years ago lol

Also that location

UNVOTE: Dwlee

Carca scummier anyway

I'm scummier than scum.

[Carcalilly]

oh crap

[Carcalilly]

Carcalilly, what are your opinions on being scum

I wish I was. It's fun.

[Carcalilly]

Y'all should be thanking me instead of voting me

[Carcalilly]

Sorry guys I might now be active today, I'm celebrating the independence of

Ame

ri

ca~

Anyway when I get back I wanna ISO and tunnel Zach because they confuse me.

Also I'm gonna believe Dunn for the time being so theyre conftown today.
Idk why but I get town vibes from Dwlee but I think that's a constant thing.
And Vedith chill <.<

Spoiler: heres a stupid pointless ramble

This counts for literally every mafia game I've played on this site but...
legitimately, Idgaf if I look scummy, because I know that all I do is state my opinions and everything on my mind when most relevant. Some of it arguably be useless but, what's the hurt of barfing up all the content you can before you die? Also I'd rather be lynched than NKed because you can at least do a VCA and stuff so I guess that's a random advantage.
I want to be the person to speak out with out-there stuff to start conversation. Y'all are too scared to be scumread from it. I don't care if you scumread me or even lynch me, at least I know I did something in the game to help the townwincon.

Ugh that feels so much better

[Carcalilly]

because it's the best way to describe it
I'm lazy rn and have guests over tho

[Carcalilly]

And since you and Gigga are jerking each other off on calling yourselves town

Vedith you're

killing

me


And ok vij
VOTE: gingham
Lynch the lurker and pray to the RNG gods.

[Carcalilly]

Vedith you're killing me

No, that's what I'm doing tonight.

O-oh...

Also people are sheeping you hard, Zach. *ahemdwleeandgiga*

[Carcalilly]

That sounds really early for a good scumread but I'll check it out...
It's a lot later a actually. A good case with motives. Tbh Vedith has contributed a questionable amount of content in a questionable manner. I want him to react first though.

I don't know about Dwlee now... Does feel kind of off but that isn't enough to put a scum label.

Your case on Vedith makes some sense, but I'm gonna wait to see what Dunn says, I'm massively curious.

[Carcalilly]

Does vedith always use a ridiculous amount of text emoticons and emojis when playing?

Yes.

[Carcalilly]

Also, just to bring another argument into light, sometimes misreping doesn't happen on purpose, and they just misunderstood what your post actually meant. I know this from personal experience. (duh carca stfu)

[Carcalilly]

wait is Dunn actually conftown? Technically they aren't

[Carcalilly]

i actually scumread carca's entrance but i wanted to sort zach first

but you guys are genuinely confusing

I fixed the broken quote for you!
- Ari

[Carcalilly]

In a nutshell what's the case on Vedith?

291
and then everyone sheeped

[Carcalilly]

Why is your vote on me

I sheeped vij 286
I like you though and you're not really lurking anymore
UNVOTE:

[Carcalilly]

Who do you think is scum, Carca

I only have gut reads right now with Zach and Dwlee.

I hate Day 1 shenanigans. I need something to actually work with.

I need to know which members here refuse to vote certain members here Day 1.i want to know who you think is off the table no matter what for now.

I personally disagree with the vedith wagon. My vote won't be placed there anytime soon.

[Carcalilly]

wait WTF

[Carcalilly]

you can't fuckin hammer while I'm asleep

[Carcalilly]

I'm a Truthful Bulletproof Accelerator Cop

I got a guilty on carcalilly and an inno on lycanfire

VOTE: Carcalilly

This is actually bullshit
What kind of game are you playing boi

[Carcalilly]

lmao OK y'all asked for it

[Carcalilly]

Since your 100% red flipped VT I'm gonna go ahead and say Blanche did not hardbus Vedith day one and they are town, Dunn. Be careful how you "steer"

Don't tell me how to drive

^^^^^^^^^^^^ yo damn wrong

[Carcalilly]

I'm a Truthful Bulletproof Accelerator Cop

I got a guilty on carcalilly and an inno on lycanfire

VOTE: Carcalilly

This is actually bullshit
What kind of game are you playing boi

Like how the actual hell is this a thing
Are you kidding me

[Carcalilly]

I didn't fucking guilt claim where the hell did I do that

[Carcalilly]

dwlee is 100% town
Gamma is scum
Zach is scum
Dunn is a really shitty town
Blance in town
Nos is town
Jj is town
I don't remember anyone else

[Carcalilly]

UH YEAH THEYRE LYING

[Carcalilly]

policy lynch Dunn tomorrow plz

[Carcalilly]

they prob ain't even the special townie
That play is too reckless

Uhhhhhhhh y'all are so reckless you know
Don't fukin quicklynch
You're all really damn lucky I'm not the end all town role

Also yeah ik I'm scummy I take pride in it so problems on you

[Carcalilly]

kk here's my lynch order
-gamma then -zach

ez game

Pedit: \o/ hullo dawn

[Carcalilly]

Yeah but I don't believe their claim at all at all
Dunn I know u know ur pulling bullshit

[Carcalilly]

Dunn wouldn't guilty claim on you if you were town and he was scum. Nice try buddy.

I would do that

Tbh I wanted to counterclaim the same thing to save my ass but y'all went and massvoted me

[Carcalilly]

Um.... yeah....






You didn't do anything yesterday except commit to a hard Vedith townread for no reason and votepark Gamma's slot. Are you wondering why I considered that scum play? I'm wondering how you place me as scum



Pedit ok, lynch the fuck out of this

do you really think I would've made it that obvious

[Carcalilly]

I'm sorry idk vedith that well

[Carcalilly]

actually nvm Zach is town and vij is scum

[Carcalilly]

Or they're both scum

[Carcalilly]

IK what wifom is they're my best friend
But the thing you missed is that it worked lol ^

[Carcalilly]

Dunn wouldn't guilty claim on you if you were town and he was scum. Nice try buddy.

I would do that

Tbh I wanted to counterclaim the same thing to save my ass but y'all went and massvoted me

Is this not a scum claim

It clearly ain't

[Carcalilly]

Yeah cuz I know he's lying

[Carcalilly]

^ town

[Carcalilly]

e.e why are we still playing

[Carcalilly]

kk here's my lynch order
-gamma then -zach

ez game

Pedit: \o/ hullo dawn

The fuck is this

The truth

[Carcalilly]

^ he knows

[Carcalilly]

damn I think I actually did just nail two scum

[Carcalilly]

Idfk but it looks pretty clear to me

[Carcalilly]

So I'm not going to say it until after we put town in autoloss and win

TBH I probably read this wrong but it sounds like scum talking

[Carcalilly]

<-- Zach is the rhino and they guy is town

[Carcalilly]

Alright

I'm

mafia, good to know

FTFY

[Carcalilly]

<-- Gamma as we're onto them being scum

[Carcalilly]

<-- Dunn and his ""cases""

[Carcalilly]

I'm a Truthful Bulletproof Accelerator Cop
I got a guilty on carcalilly and an inno on lycanfire
VOTE: Carcalilly

whoah look at the intense scumplay here
manipulates the whole town
insane mechanics
masterful outplay
scummies tier play here

exactly!

[Carcalilly]

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[Carcalilly]

Who hammers at 4am!?!?!?

[Carcalilly]

This game tho

[Carcalilly]

OH MY GOD I THOUGHT BLANCHE WAS JUST A NORMAL SCUM

IM DYING

[Carcalilly]

OH MY GOD I THOUGHT BLANCHE WAS JUST A NORMAL SCUM

IM DYING

You already died tho

THIS IS UNACCEPTABLE

VOTE: ARI

[Carcalilly]

I feel it would have been legendary and hilarious if scum figured it out.
I didn't even question the Godfather mechanic.

There's actually no way I would've figured it out
Like wow

[Carcalilly]

No it was fun

for you!!

Nah man I'm grinning like an idiot rn even though we lost

[Carcalilly]

Sometimes

Bussing is too good to pass up

[Carcalilly]

Well it's easy when Carcalilly literally signs up to be bussed