GreyICE is probably going to rant at me and say that these interactions are terrible and that it was imbalanced if he sees both the other two town roles claim though. Personal opinion: interactions are unusual and interesting, and have the potential to be really swingy, but are mostly balanced and if there's any bias at all, it's against the town. (The mafia having a full roleblocker is a bit much in my opinion and it was originally gated but reviewer decision was to bump it from gated to full as a compromise, so.)
I mean the game potentially ended on Day 2 with a town victory if we just lynched the miller claim and the scum didn't block or shoot the right people. I mean to recap, we lynch town D1, get a little lucky with power roles, and the game is unwinnable for scum. That's a bit much. I've been in a 13-player theme game that ended before day 2 began and I think it was less swingy (and broken) than this. You should also consider the power roles went quite badly for the town and we still had a mass of confirmed town for the scum to shoot through, so bad that they had to either take two confirmed town or Regfan+1 confirmed into LyLo. So it was swingy and unbalanced, simply a poor design.
Regfan
remains the best town player on site, bar none. The number of times that he's simply nailed a scumteam is impressive, and he is incredibly hard to argue against. Any town would gain a huge upgrade with him replacing in and this was no exception. I don't know why he think I'd get mad over the tchill lynch, it was kind of MMM>tchill=LMK day 1 for me, but it was all very close, and clearly all 3 dying was pro-town (no offense tchill). I know you wanted the Massive lynch day 3, and clearly from one perspective it was right, but from another FormerFish was much scarier to me as scum than Massive, which I think is worth respecting.
FormerFish:
Sorry dude. If it's any consolation the reason you were investigated night 1 was I legitimately felt you could carry the game for the scumteam if you were scum, and could do a damn good job as town if you were confirmed town. It's not like I was really scared that LMKGuy would be the scum mastermind who lived through LyLo, y'know? You absolutely fell into my philosophy as a cop - investigate someone you wouldn't mind claiming to save if they were town, and legitimately fear if they were scum. Once I got the result, I feel like I had to see it through.
Uzi:
I think you played alright, although you were a bit hyperactive and I don't understand day 2 at all. You've got to put your ego on the back burner sometimes.
Mulch:
Genuinely good play, got shot by scum, and I think you might have been shot eventually even without the clear.
Eevee/idany:
You were both very recognizably town, but I feel like you could elevate your play a bit. Dany, you did some decent analysis, but you tend not to reach out to other players. If you think someone is town try working more with them. You aren't locked into a read, and you need to work together to win. Eevee, I feel like you were just flying on gut most of the time. I think you could benefit from sitting back and reading things more.
tchill:
Sorry dude, you fit a lot of common scum patterns, and that last post was legit from one of your scum games. I feel like you were faking analysis as both scum and town.
GerryOat:
Obviously you played well, you got shot by scum N1 as a VT. Highest compliment you can get.
Arona
: I wish you contributed more, but for a PR it was fine.
![:]](./images/smilies/icon_smiling.png "Cheerful Smile"){kind=icon}
