Mini Normal 1931 | Endgame
- MarioManiac4
-
MarioManiac4 Jack of All Trades
- MarioManiac4
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9179
- Joined: May 1, 2015
- NotTheRealPaul
-
NotTheRealPaul Mafia Scum
- NotTheRealPaul
- MarioManiac4
-
MarioManiac4 Jack of All Trades
- MarioManiac4
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9179
- Joined: May 1, 2015
so your townread on them is based on "i like the content" and a post filled with bullshit makes "a hell of a lot of sense"In post 2381, NotTheRealPaul wrote:Im kinda rethinking my mario read rn. Because I was looking back and I felt like too much of my reasons to tr him were based off others reads. And FL has begun to actually post and I like what content he has made.
This post made a hell of a lot of sense to mex Like it just kinda rang tru.In post 2350, Flavor Leaf wrote:I am starting to actually see a Mario, Thor, Una potential team by where all their pushes are going. They are trying to stay distant from each other, yet all their pushes push the same agenda without incriminating the others directly. Mario takes RB's side with Thor, but obviously something is keeping Thor from being lynched. Thor is setting a Dunker/Flavor mislynch chain up, which wouldn't give much information, while Una tunnels on Eddie, a player who was pushing Thor with Rb, but MM4 already has RB. They're controlling the whole game. It's why we're in this standstill.
VOTE: Mario
Okay.
So now you get to explain that.
VOTE: NotTheRealPaul- Thor665
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Thor665
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
@Mario - still looking for your definition of 'reachy'.
I find Eddie's attack on frog really weak, and I find frog's defense probably even weaker a bunch of 'yeah, maybe I'm doing this weak stuff BUT SO ARE YOU!' defenses are...meh at best whether or not they are true (and I would say easily half are true, but still - if someone is scum part of your issue with them SHOULDN'T be stuff you are also doing).
I still find frog clinging to his Eddie/Thor combo to be an odd position. It is either scum with a strategy or town filled with intense paranoia. I tend to lean the former due to the weird interlude where he was trying to browbeat me for not cooperating with Eddie to explain my scumreads to him - I don't think that behavior makes much sense at all for someone who claims Eddie and I are scum independently and also make sense as partners doing scum theatre because who bothers to try to help scum work through their theatre?
Literally the only thing stopping me from leaping onto the frog wagon at this stage is that Eddie's votes and reliability are about as functional as a forgetful goldfish, and also I will admit a slight bit of toe curling on the timing of Eddie's issues with frog.
That said, at this stage, I support seeing more votes on Dunker or frog.
I will note that LITERALLY THE BEST DEFENSE OFFERED FOR DUNKERS THUS FAR IS THAT SOMEONE HAS NO READ ON HIM YET.
Think about that for a moment and ask yourself why I'm having to field accusations of not accomplishing enough yet in this game.- Thor665
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Thor665
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
And hot damn, now we have a Paul vote too, it's like Christmas for Thor's scumreads! Someone should vote FL and give me options!- MarioManiac4
-
MarioManiac4 Jack of All Trades
- MarioManiac4
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9179
- Joined: May 1, 2015
- Thor665
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Thor665
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
Wouldn't then literally every act of scumhunting on town be reachy by your definition?- MarioManiac4
-
MarioManiac4 Jack of All Trades
- MarioManiac4
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9179
- Joined: May 1, 2015
Well, no. Most things make sense; even if they don't mean the person is Mafia, either there is a value to the point that makes the player more likely to be Mafia, or there is a point even if it isn't actually scum-indicative. But reachy things aren't to be accurate at all, because the player was reaching for something that would be scummy. Hopefully that makes more sense.- Thor665
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Thor665
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
Pushing something that lacks any functional evidence sounds pretty close to what you're describing - no?In post 2321, wavemode wrote:Only scum make reachy cases? Town always have definitive evidence of everything they push?- Thor665
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Thor665
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
Above is all @Mario - the wavmode quote is to settle a false dichotomy claim for myself.- NotTheRealPaul
-
NotTheRealPaul Mafia Scum
- NotTheRealPaul
- NotTheRealPaul
-
NotTheRealPaul Mafia Scum
- NotTheRealPaul
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1496
- Joined: March 26, 2017
- MarioManiac4
-
MarioManiac4 Jack of All Trades
- MarioManiac4
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9179
- Joined: May 1, 2015
- NotTheRealPaul
-
NotTheRealPaul Mafia Scum
- NotTheRealPaul
- MarioManiac4
-
MarioManiac4 Jack of All Trades
- MarioManiac4
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9179
- Joined: May 1, 2015
No, a lack of thought processes and saying "I like X" is scummy. Hence why I want you to explain why you like him and what about his case you agree with.
- Thor665
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Thor665
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
What is your take on frog's Eddie/Thor pairing- do you find that reachy?In post 2412, MarioManiac4 wrote:Not really. There's no conclusive evidence in most points, but there's always a possible stream of thought, and it's always considered somewhat of a likelihood. Reachy cases are more based on far-flung possibilities while acting like they're actual cases? Idk it's hard to define.
You seem to not find him scummy nor to town read me or Eddie currently, but I find his case to require a lot of squinting to go with.- Thor665
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Thor665
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
Like, when frog is asked why the pairing he's arguing for makes sense and his response every time is 'why don't they make sense?' it makes *my* toes curl, why doesn't it curl yours?- NotTheRealPaul
-
NotTheRealPaul Mafia Scum
- NotTheRealPaul
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1496
- Joined: March 26, 2017
i had thoughts. u simply didnt think they were enough.
idk how else to really put it except that i liked flavours case and it made sness to me. llike the part about the scumteam kinda keeping the gamestate standstillush/preventing any real lynch from happening just clicked(?h
I like him because his content makes sense. WHAT ELSE DO U WANT FROM ME. I didnt dislike him before he started content I was mostly nullreading as he hadnt pisted much. But recently he has been more active and his content makes sense.
like do u want me to go post by post saying "i agree with this" "this makes sense" etc?
why does gr get a free pass on this though?- NotTheRealPaul
-
NotTheRealPaul Mafia Scum
- NotTheRealPaul
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1496
- Joined: March 26, 2017
- MarioManiac4
-
MarioManiac4 Jack of All Trades
- MarioManiac4
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9179
- Joined: May 1, 2015
- Thor665
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Thor665
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
By the thin logic that anyone making a claim is the one obligated to back it - frog has made the claim that what we did could be scum theatre.
Shouldn't he then be obligated to back that up?- Thor665
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Thor665
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
Like, this is his case.In post 2392, frog wrote:
I think it could well have been. Make town despondent by having two players argue inconsequentially and distract from discussion that might be productive. Certainly there is nothing to say they cannot be scum together.In post 2274, NotTheRealPaul wrote:u think thor vs eddie was scum theatre?
Thor: "Hey, Eddie, let's you and I argue to make town sad!"
Eddie: "Okay, I'll make up stuff on you and have town believe it, and only *after* town starts believing it should you bother to point out that it's stupid violently enough to actually get everyone to start ignoring my pushes, because that will help our chances by distancing us from each other yet destroying both of our credabilities for town!"
Thor: "Fucking brilliant!"- MarioManiac4
-
MarioManiac4 Jack of All Trades
- MarioManiac4
- Jack of All Trades
- Jack of All Trades
- Posts: 9179
- Joined: May 1, 2015
Not really? That's the default state; of course, there's a chance both you and Eddie rolled scum, and if someone wanted me to remove that possibility, I'd certainly need evidence to make me do it.
pedit: I don't feel like he's actually making any associative case here. He's just not ruling anything out. I could argue that position with you but then I'd be defending an argument I don't really agree with; in any case I don't think it's scum-indicative.- Thor665
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Thor665
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
You consider the default state for all players to be scum and anyone making a non-scum argument to be the one obligated to make a case?- Thor665
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Thor665
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
What about my point about his interactions with me and Eddie later in the game?In post 2422, MarioManiac4 wrote:I don't think it's scum-indicative.
I consider that scum indicative, do you? - Thor665
Copyright © MafiaScum. All rights reserved.
- Thor665
- MarioManiac4
- Thor665
- Thor665
- MarioManiac4
- NotTheRealPaul
- NotTheRealPaul
- Thor665
- Thor665
- MarioManiac4
- MarioManiac4
- NotTheRealPaul
- Thor665
- Thor665
- MarioManiac4
- Thor665
- MarioManiac4
- Thor665
- Thor665
- MarioManiac4
- MarioManiac4