@Gin I think it's pretty reasonable to think that
115 is implying that scumreading Korts would be "dumb"; don't think that it's strange to assume that you have read the thread before making the post or that you were responding to Tchill in particular - I didn't think you were but your post comes right after Tchill's so I can see how he might've thought that. Don't think it's completely unreasonable for Tchill to vote you if he wants you to talk more; his vote isn't a particularly good one but I'm not sure it makes him scum. What low-hanging fruit has he been going after? Why are you scumreading him aside from
209?
@Tchill I'm not sure why you don't engage with Gin on her response to your vote if your intent is to get her to talk more; haven't seen you talk about most of your reads which is what you need to be doing if you're town here - in particular I'd like to hear about your townreads because I've not really felt anything solid from you in that department so far. You seem to be townreading Robbnva for coming across as genuine; is there anything else about him that makes you think he could be town here? What changed between
200 and
326 to make you feel confident in a Ginngie scumread? I think your reasoning for scumreading Ari is pretty fair; not sure that the reasoning you've expressed is strong enough to warrant the kind of scumread you've displayed given Ari's meta; if you could walk me through your Ari read that would be pretty helpful.
You haven't commented on Monkey a great deal; he's produced enough content that I think you should be able to get a read on him a little more developed than what you've stated - don't think that scumreading him for questioning Gin's townread is particularly good reasoning and I'd hope that your read would have a little more than that; in 1920 your reads were pretty on-point but you didn't explain them a lot - we talked in the dead thread about approaching the game in a certain way and being an open book; I was looking forward to seeing how you might apply that but I'm not sure I've felt anything significantly different so far and you seem to have abanonded the idea altogether if
330 is any indication - where has your head been at as far as that's concerned? Agree with massive that you should be scumhunting on your wagon not expecting other people to do so for you; feeling a little uneasy that you suggested that in the way that you did.
@Assemblerotws what scummy habits are you referring to in
172? Not sure I understand your take here; you're saying that you noticed people behaving in a way that was scummy according to what other people in the thread had pointed out? That doesn't strike me as a particularly good way to go about sorting the board; could you clarify this point for me please? I think that your reasoning for scumreading Robbnva is pretty understandable; I'm not sure why Robbnva feels that this is null behavior even if it might be a little bit of a stretch; how strong is your scumread there right now?
@Robbnva I don't think Assembler is scumreading you for having a different definition of RVS; I could understand where you were coming from with your push on Persephone for the most part even if I didn't really agree with it; don't think that it's unreasonable to see that as you pushing for a lynch off pretty much nothing when your read on Persephone at that point seemed to be based on a misunderstanding of her content. Maybe you don't think that's the case but even if Persephone was justifying herself after the fact and behaving a little awkward overall I'm not sure why that means she should just be lynched; I agree that RVS reads are legitimate and Persephone was legitimately scummy but I don't think that your approach there has been particularly reasonable overall; I don't think that her OMGUS was scummy in any special way; I disagree that she hadn't been attempting to scumhunt or sort people - I think she was pretty clearly doing so? I'm a little worried you haven't really reevaluated on the replacement and I don't strongly get the sense that you really intended to in any meaningful way -
220 felt pretty genuine but you seem to have abanonded that take pretty summarily. Tchill isn't OMGUSing you - how does that affect your read there? Why are you scumreading massive?
@massive could you articulate your Tchill townread a little more clearly?
192 is pretty vague and I'm not sure I'm going to be able to get anything out of that. Going by
194 you seem to be scumreading him or at least unwilling to townread him because you believe that he could be playing the way he's playing as scum; don't think this is good reasoning at all for maintaining a scumread even if it's pretty understandable to want to nullread him for it; by
222 he's clearly a townread - walk me through your progression there? I agree that he feels a lot like he did in 1920; not sure whether that means he's town here but I haven't seen his scumgame either - what do you think of his early interactions with the Persephone wagon? I feel like he would be talking about his reads more if he was town here; he seemed to have a pretty good grasp of his reads in 1920 and I'm not really feeling like that's the case here - he's talked about his reads a little but I feel like in all of his posts there he was solving and pushing the gamestate and he feels way more on the back foot here; even when he has been pushing scumreads I haven't strongly felt like he's arrived there naturally so much as come up with a read that seems justified.
