Large Normal 204: BooneyToonz III - Calling All Cryptids!END

[Shinobi]

Howdy.
I refuse to read 138 pages.

What's going on and why is that guy getting lynched?

[Shinobi]

Yeah I checked his ISO.
I'm cool with him being lynched.

VOTE: sling

[Shinobi]

shinobi, read abr and ginngie
.and d2

If I did, what exactly would I be looking for?

[Shinobi]

Gee. Thanks.

[Shinobi]

Will do stuff tomorrow.

[Shinobi]

I'm around and reading.
Starting to think ABR is scum for his mediocre ISO and his lack of initiative, things that I found quite endearing from his normal town play are completely absent here.

Is there a reason why people are leaving him alone or nah? Still reading around and catching up but that was something that I didn't like out of what pisskop asked of me.

[Shinobi]

Also, I think Ginnie is town.
In-depth questioning and emotions on her sleeve make her an easy townread, imo.

[Shinobi]

(Who is now fykus, I know, but Ginngie was town which makes the slot fine.)

[Shinobi]

I don't follow how that leads to crush being a lynch candidate. Elaborate for me, please?

[Shinobi]

Urgh, it's Shinobi...

Hi.

I already scum read Crush in day 1 and I'm not risking lynching another pr so I'm against sling but crush and Whymafia are good votes to me.

But you haven't explained why crush is a good vote.
You posted a series of quotes that, to me, fails to explain why crush is mafia.
Again: why is crush mafia? Saying you scumread him before isn't valid.

[Shinobi]

UNVOTE:

[Shinobi]

I voted him because his ISO is mostly pointless one liners.
I don't see how in-depth I have to go because of that - his ISO is mediocre and anyone can see it.

The only issue I have right now is that I don't trust ABR.

[Shinobi]

I need to spend more time catching up before someone gets lynched, too.
I have maybe 3 or 4 reads and that's not enough at this stage.

[Shinobi]

I voted him because his ISO is mostly pointless one liners.
I don't see how in-depth I have to go because of that - his ISO is mediocre and anyone can see it.

If you're lynching a claimed PR, I expect it to be more in depth.
Who else is scum?

The only other scumread I have right now is on ABR - I believe I explained that a couple of posts in.
I remember talking to Tchill about crush and he simply never answered, so both of those players are currently part of my focus.

Considering you have a scumread on crush, can you explain why he's scum?

[Shinobi]

I don't know if I think tchill is scum or not yet.
Crush being scum is feasible but I'm going to spend some time looking over his ISO in a second anyway.

[Shinobi]

pisskop - getting better in my books but something still feels really shitty about this guy
Shinobi - town due to predecessor
Fykus - townread extremely waning here
PenguinPower - i think town
Lore - town
massive - town
WhyMafia - probably a shitty counterwagon used to protect waffles. probtown
jjh927 - gamma was meh at times and honestly i'm not sure how i feel about jjh. i was able to townread him IMMEDIATELY in our previous game. it's not the same here.
Tchill13 - town
SlingshotWaffles - probably scum
texcat - i still think town.
Albert B. Rampage - town
FourTrouble - probably scum at this point. strong play at the beginning can be faked but the mask wears off after completely lackluster play later on in the game.
Lapsav - town
Egg - town
Crush - scum and fucking lynch this
Vedith - town
Srceenplay - fairly certain town

What exactly is it that bothers you wrt pisskop? I've got a decent enough townlean on him.

@Vedith - I know I still have to look into crush but I haven't had time until recently. Doing so today.

[Shinobi]

dont worry, abr was town

but ill do you one better and say i have extensive Titus experience.

if shes a rotten scumbumble ill know it and words shall be had.
but shes not

That's not enough and you know it.
Talk to me more about this magical Titus read you have, because she's barely said anything of note and ABR was pretty scummy.

[Shinobi]

Side note, I really,

really

don't want to reread Crush.
I'm still aware that I need to do it but I'm probably going to put it off even more for the lazies.

[Shinobi]

Well I thought he was scummy, so I don't get it.

[Shinobi]

I think that was the most needlessly aggressive thing I've said in a long time lmao. Sorry.
On another topic, who is scum and why? I saw you have a rainbow list but I don't know why you want to vote the people you do and don't see you pushing them. What's up?

[Shinobi]

For starters, which of my reads aren't you sure on?

Pretty close to all of them.
If you're going to post a readslist, reasoning behind the reads rather than making them pretty works way better. I couldn't really find reasoning for much of any of them even going through a majority of your filter.

[Shinobi]

Tchill did you ever answer my question?

[Shinobi]

Btw, @Vedith whenever he has time/reads this:
Why is Penguin town?

[Shinobi]

Btw, @Vedith whenever he has time/reads this:
Why is Penguin town?

Lapsa

Tchill13

Transcend

pisskop

PenguinPower

Egg

Lore

SlingshotWaffles

jjh927

Shinobi

Titus

Fykus

FourTrouble

Srceenplay

massive

texcat

Crush

WhyMafia

Not helpful.

[Shinobi]

Actually it seems like I scum read Crush on day 1 because I disagreed with his stance on Pmysterious who has since flipped town. So while he still comes off as scummy to me he's not as scummy as I used to believe. From me personally.

So why is he scum?

[Shinobi]

Not helpful.

Why?

Because you've explained nothing.
Rainbow lists are pointless.

[Shinobi]

The part where I asked why Penguin was town.
You know, the bit that you quoted and then didn't answer.

[Shinobi]

The part where I asked why Penguin was town.
You know, the bit that you quoted and then didn't answer.

Because he's splurting his town goodness all over the thread.
Why do you think he's not town?

Because he doesn't trust the ABR slot in yet followed Titus with conviction after Titus voted Transcend, despite Titus doing nothing to warrant that kind of trust.
What town goodness have you been seeing? Because I 100% don't see it.

[Shinobi]

Your last three posts.

[Shinobi]

No. Rainbow lists are stupid.
I'm still looking over it and it just seems so asinine to me. Like, there's NOTHING in his ISO in yet he's acting like Transcend is such a sure thing after Titus votes him over nothing.

It makes absolutely no sense to me.

[Shinobi]

Why is he town?

[Shinobi]

Yeah good luck with that one.
Tell me why he is town, please.

[Shinobi]

Man fuck you.

[Shinobi]

VOTE: Transcend

Let's go gamesolving.

VC please

Oh, great. My gray read...

I'm gonna need something, T.

Here.
It seemed stronger when I was reading it but now I feel less confident.

[Shinobi]

Just forget it.
I thought it was something but apparently he just said something in an awkward way.

[Shinobi]

No, I don't really want to talk to you anymore.

[Shinobi]

No, I don't really want to talk to you anymore.

Then don't pretend to care about my reads.

I do - you're just being a condescending ass again and it's pissing me off.

[Shinobi]

Yeah, I'd rather pick this back up later.
I'm a little frustrated and I'd like to step away for a bit.

[Shinobi]

Just lynch Waffles if both him and Tchill are alive tomorrow, thank you. Good game guys, sorry for not putting in enough effort.

This post stands in stark contrast to a L-1 post I've seen from Crush elsewhere. Besides that, this lynch should give town some information either way.

VOTE: crush

thats hammer.

Not a terrible hammer at all.
Hope I was wrong on penguin and we hit scum. /shrug

[Shinobi]

Shouldn't have let Vedith talk me off the waffles wagon.
Alas.

[Shinobi]

I want pressure on my vote

Why? I don't think you've posted a reason for voting this slot.

I want pressure on my vote

You seem a little scummier because you made a good case on crush then like Shinobi said you talked him off the waffles wagon but you're not scummier than Whymafia. From what I can tell scum didn't know waffles was scum anyway.

I said that about Vedith, not Transcend.
I ignored almost everything Transcend said about everything yesterday except for his read on like one person.

[Shinobi]

I just think he could be a good lynch but wm is also fine

This tells me nothing. Why is he a good lynch?

Sorry Shinobi. No I haven't made a case yet.

??? What are you talking about?
Also, I still have no idea what you were doing on the crush wagon. I questioned you about and you basically said "yeah I don't have a good reason for being here" and then never reevaluated your position or came up with new reasons.

[Shinobi]

I don't have a case lol

I just think he might be a good lynch lol.

Sorry about saying transcend said something that vedith said. I haven't made a case on Whymafia yet. I also doubt I'd get killed but if waffles was supposed to clear someone do you think his own mafia team killed him? That way he wouldn't get the clear wrong?

You two make absolutely no sense.

[Shinobi]

I still want to lynch Penguin ftr.

[Shinobi]

To be fair I think transcend is gonna be aware the person that modded the game he did that is playing this game and he's not gonna try the same exact thing. I could be wrong though.

Really don't need to be saying stuff like this, ftr. The thread is clogged up enough as is.

[Shinobi]

Transcend were you actually planning to do anything outside of have Fykus claim not VT or no?

[Shinobi]

Transcend were you actually planning to do anything outside of have Fykus claim not VT or no?

i think it was obvious to everyone in this game that one of my nonvts was Fykus. the other one i might toy around with a bit

I'd rather you just told us who it was.

[Shinobi]

I am 5 pages in and I saw so much fluff I want to take my eyes out.

Ok

Welcome to 204.

Can someone tell me where's the case on me so I can actually you know, defend myself

Can someone point this out to me as well? I feel like this kind of happened with crush yesterday too and it's getting really annoying.

[Shinobi]

Can someone summarize what the case on WM is? I asked once and got a half answer from Egg that didn't really convince me at all, and it doesn't explain why everyone else is on him.

[Shinobi]

Srceen who's your alternative?

[Shinobi]

Can we lynch Egg or Shinobi yet?

:S i feel like this is lynch the newbies game.

Considering your hysterically bad track record with reading me, I'd love to see how you try to justify it this time.

[Shinobi]

Gonna hafta go vla kiddies.

Work picked up, I got a new job looming, volunteer for references, etc.


I glanced at the game;

The reason why I have harped on meta in this game has more to do with my own awareness of what I do in a game than using it as the sole basis of scumhunting. Yall know Im a goofball in the best of times, and as scum I ....

well, meta me and find out, but this nonsense where Im catching flashes of shade makes me ensaddened.


whymaf is scum because his postings have been bad since D1. We keep wagoning people who nobody can agree on.

OR, rather, we keep wandering around with halfass wagons. Get a real counterwagon going of stfu. Make the case.

No, this isn't anything. Tell me why his posting is bad and why it makes him scum.
It only makes it harder to lynch him if he actually is mafia and everyone keeps posting half-assed reasoning as to why we should lynch him.

[Shinobi]

Titus case is trash, no surprise there.
Moving on:

I'm too tired to comprehend anything. Next full night of sleep is saturday.

ISO'd lore and waffles to see what they say they did last night. Looks like we didn't get much info out of it. Lore might be telling the truth though because pmyst as a shot from scum doesn't make much sense.

why does PM make sense as a "Vig" shot but not scum? He softed as pr. I would think town vig might be apprehensive about shooting a pr but scum wouldn't be.

When I posted that, I hadn't seen anyone point out that pmyst apparently softed a power role. If scum picked up on that, then maybe they did actually shoot him.

Whymafia,
-On the theta case, you started off with being unwilling to call theta town but still defending her under the logic that there are other options (obviously true with any case) and anyone can make one bad post. Then you sheeped fourtrouble's case while still giving things you disagreed with. All in a span of just a few posts. It didn't feel natural.
-Gut is hard to explain but I've already tried multiple times so at this point you probably just aren't reading.
-You are right that OMGUS isn't a universal tell, but it was the way you did it with vedith that seemed like scum OMGUS.

Shinobi, if you felt my whymafia reasoning was a "half answer", I don't really know what you were expecting. I understand if it didn't convince you, but a half answer? Really?

They both have coasted doing nothing.

You caught me. As town I'd be calling in to work until the game is over.

The bottom line is that I don't like your case.

[Shinobi]

Yeah I'm looking but I don't see one that I can post a strong case on either.

[Shinobi]

Yeah I'm looking but I don't see one that I can post a strong case on either.

Do you have a strong gut read?

No, because gut reads are pointless.
The person I was pushing on before was PP for reasons that I deemed weaker on a second look. I'd consider it again based on the fact that PP basically just voted crush all of yesterday and was content doing little afterwards as long as he wasn't being talked about, iirc.

[Shinobi]

Actually:
VOTE: penguin

Let's talk about this because I feel this needs to be brought up again.

[Shinobi]

I can't remember why I said that.
Sorry.

[Shinobi]

Ok
Someone tell me how Fykus is town

I think Ginggie was a stronger scum player
I'm on a phone, so it's hard to multi-quote

Okay, seriously.
Why do people keep doing this?

[Shinobi]

Maybe WM is just mafia and I'm overthinking this.
This Fykus read is pathetic and isn't doing him any favors.

[Shinobi]

Maybe WM is just mafia and I'm overthinking this.
This Fykus read is pathetic and isn't doing him any favors.

What's pathetic about it? Statements like that don't really do much .. what do you want to know? How may I oblige?

Explain anything about your read.
We've asked you about Fykus several times and you've essentially said nothing about it.

[Shinobi]

Yeah I saw that too Egg.

Tchill: here I got you. Tchill your reads are horrible.

Why are they horrible though? I mean I was wanting to hear from Shinobi specifically because he called out Whymafia on his read of Fykus rather than mine.

Two reasons:
1) WM is getting lynched and you aren't. WM should be vested in saving his skin, in yet isn't for whatever reason.
2) I already think you're sort of towny, so I don't really care what you think of fykus in terms of perusing your quality of argumentation.

[Shinobi]

WM really shouldn't be going dark with such a large wagon this close to deadline.
I can't really imagine a townie would just sit there and get lynched on such faulty reasoning here.

[Shinobi]

Why is this game so quiet?

I keep giving WM time to post even though it's way more than he deserves at this point.

[Shinobi]

VOTE: wm
Penguin needs to be lynched tomorrow regardless of what wm flips. Pp's top scumread is getting his lynch and penguin doesn't care at all, and simply hasn't put a lick of effort into getting transcend lynched anyway.

Wm's play is so spotty here that I can't imagine a townie would just crumble under such basic questioning.

[Shinobi]

VOTE: WhyMafia
Lost all motivation. This was a doomed slot. Sorry Boon
Gl town

I gave you an ear and plenty of days to talk.
If you end up being town I will be quite disappointed.

[Shinobi]

gg