Mini Normal 1946 | Classic Hits | Town Victory!

[Virtuoso]

VC 1.02

---

Lynching

humaneatingmonkey

(4): WhyMafia, Thor665, Mulch, BlueBloodedToffee

WhyMafia

(2): humaneatingmonkey, Robbnva

Not Voting

(7): Toranaga, Havo, fykus, MariaR, Chip Butty, Misère, Creative

With 13 alive it takes 7 to lynch

The day 1 deadline is in

: (expired on 2017-09-24 15:12:59)

Mod Notes

: Keep it fun.

Thor665 is V/LA. Stay safe!

[Robbnva]

Rob so you're saying my claim is BS bc of your experience with miller claims ... so it's a meta read.

Well it's more of a lynch all millers policy more than anything but sure whatever

[Robbnva]

Well hopefully you can't avoid it cause I'm going to make sure he's lynched

So you've decided to death tunnel me? I'm fine with that, but at least keep an open mind over others. I understand that you believe this is scum, but why wouldn't town!me claim?

Unless you somehow wow me with your play, yes. So far you haven't wow'd me

[MariaR]

80 posts already?...Oh boy

[Robbnva]

request replacement

I'm so sorry V. If you want I can explain via pm.

[Virtuoso]

Robbnva has requested replacement. Searching now.

[Fykus]

not caught up yet but about to start work again in a min so ill be posting from mobile from that point.

mulch, wm and toranaga are my town reads.

suss on rob and monkey.

VOTE: monkey

also just to note ive seen wm shoot his wad early when he had a d1 claimable role before so im inclined to think hes town here too.

[Mulch]

Robbnva has requested replacement. Searching now.

I hate to say it but I think that in all likelihood a chance of a town win just went up lol

[MariaR]

You're not wrong

[humaneatingmonkey]

Let's stop being mean.

Raise of hands: Who thinks WhyMafia is town?

[Fykus]

Me

[WhyMafia]

Me

[Toranaga]

toranaga thinks mafia is town

[Havo]

I think Why is town at this point.

[Toranaga]

vote: mariaR

[Toranaga]

monkey: we gain information by lynching anyone. there's no angle where lynching the claimed miller d1 is optimal play in this spot IMO.

[Virtuoso]

skitter30 replaces Robbnva. Please welcome her!

[WhyMafia]

Hi skitter

[skitter30]

Hi!!!

I'm in middle of a thing atm, but I'll be back in a few hours

@mod/everyone: Always v/la on Shabbat/Jewish holidays.

Noted. Thanks

[Fykus]

Skitter is scum: confirmed. Every game with me shes scum lol

[Misère]

I don't know if WhyMafia is town, but I'm not going to take claiming Miller as evidence that he isn't.

I think humaneatingmonkey is town for taking an unpopular (because wrong, but still) stance w.r.t. WhyMafia's claim, and refusing to soften it under pressure. If he were scum hiding behind policy I would expect him to just say "oh, good point" and back down when everyone disagrees with him.

VOTE: Havo

[Mulch]

You scum again Skitter?

[Toranaga]

I have zero experience with a Miller best I can remember. The site I used to play at never used them that I recall.

So Wiki says they are a negative role and usually used to counter or lessen the power of the town cop. And the correct play is to claim early although it's debatable.

And I think a good argument has been made by both sides or at least I can see both sides.

I would hate to have to resolve the slot in LyLo tho. But my gut says scum wouldn't do this on D1.
As the Wiki says the claim usually gets lynched or night killed anyway. Or maybe that was one of you guys that said it.

I haven't found any reasonable argument against openclaiming. I wouldn't do it with certain player fields that I am confident to read me well, and I can see an argument for not claiming if you're trying to keep cop equity and if your kill create cop hunt cleared town. The fact is, claiming miller on later gamedays isn't as believable, and claiming miller after getting peeked scum will get you lynched everytime. Certain players with certain fields in certain games can play it in a different way, but this is not the game for that.

I wanna say this post is a little scummy. Bare in mind this is extremely thin, and I don't want to out all the reasons for it. But this is too much commentary instead of adding something to the discussion. Your post is fine otherwise, I get where you're coming from etc. Just think it comes more from scum than town.

[Toranaga]

I don't know if WhyMafia is town, but I'm not going to take claiming Miller as evidence that he isn't.

I think humaneatingmonkey is town for taking an unpopular (because wrong, but still) stance w.r.t. WhyMafia's claim, and refusing to soften it under pressure. If he were scum hiding behind policy I would expect him to just say "oh, good point" and back down when everyone disagrees with him.

VOTE: Havo

this is a great read on monkey and I agree with it. this is such a good post I wonder if you got there from a perspective of actually knowing he is town.

[MariaR]

People have reads already? What the fuck. o_o I got nothing from these blur of 5 pages.