Dance of the Title Fairy: Accepting Applications

[Alisae]

It's a trash forced meme that originated from complaints about another trash forced meme being suggested for a title. Please don't.

[Errantparabola]

in light of recent events I'd like to nominate nancy for Posed
but in all seriousness do you think it's worth discussing a title for nancy for the noteworthy FWAN trend she started, despite titles trending pretty strongly away from singular incidents of note

[Firebringer]

Probably not

[Alisae]

Antinom
Way more to nancy then that trend

[Killthestory]

i think posed can be phrased to be artistic, remember the trend she set, but also remember her personality, too.

it's not a bad start as far as titles go. i mean, posed in itself is pretty cool because it also reminds me of confidence. nancy is pretty confident and great.

[Errantparabola]

the title nom was a joke
Im sorry

[Killthestory]

angry

[Killthestory]

I ACTUALLY LIKED IT EP I THOUGHT IT WAS COOL

[fferyllt]

desoP Poised

[mastina]

I ACTUALLY LIKED IT EP I THOUGHT IT WAS COOL

[Thestatusquo]

Animorph is dead to me now.

It's almost like you delight in talking about things you know nothing about.

[Firebringer]

Animorph is dead to me now.

It's almost like you delight in talking about things you know nothing about.

No, but you certainly do.
The "rule" basically started because of shotty. Before then it was basically just assumed to be in bad form.
You brought in a lot of tangeant stuff to support your argument when it didn't.

[Thestatusquo]

Literally codified in every rule set before shotty. All the way back to Thok.

[mastina]

Literally codified in every rule set before shotty. All the way back to Thok.

Shea knows his site history quite well and I can confirm. The rule did not start because of shotty. It was there long, long, LONG before shotty.

[animorpherv1]

I'm also pretty sure Firebringer is just trying to get reactions.

[SleepyKrew]

The active campaign rule only existed to shut down shottys title.
I think many people forget that

You're wrong.

doot sucks

[Firebringer]

TSQ has reframed this whole argument into something it wasn't to begin with.

I didn't say self noms were ever fine. That is what he is doing with showing rules. Their has never been a rule against campaigning for a nom when someone else nommed you for it until Shotty was pushing very heavily for it and then from then on everyone was like "Ohh i guess we can't talk about things we got nommed for"

Hell, TSQ campaigned for his own title in thread and then basically guilt tripped Chèvre into giving it to him when Chèvre disagreed with the title.

[Cheetory6]

the dream is over

[Firebringer]

good

[SleepyKrew]

Their has never been a rule against campaigning for a nom when someone else nommed you for it until Shotty was pushing very heavily for it and then from then on everyone was like "Ohh i guess we can't talk about things we got nommed for"

You're wrong.

[Firebringer]

i guess so, if everyone keeps shouting it, it must be true!

[mastina]

i guess so, if everyone keeps shouting it, it must be true!

When all of those people have joindates pedating yours and were around with an active involvement in the site culture prior to you even playing mafia here...yes.

[Raskolnikov]

what do you know anyways mastina youre here less than a year /s

[Shaziro]

Firebringer, even if the rule -was- made to deal with Shotty, do you not understand that A: The title is bad, B: It is a good rule to have, and C: It is applicable to this situation?

And yes, I think Shea's title is arguably something he campaigned for. I've said that lots of times. I mentioned it (Somewhat passive-agressively, apologies) just a bit ago. That doesn't change that it's not a thing to do for future titles. In either case, Psyche has said it's dead, and I'm not thinking he was being sarcastic. Let it go.

[Not_Mafia]

doot will live forever in our hearts