Mini Normal 1950 [Engame: Mafia Victory!]

[Zulfy]

On day 2 and onwards (until the vanilla cop role is claimed or killed), every player posts a result as if they were the vanilla cop; the actual vanilla cop tells the truth and everyone else makes up a result. It does possibly give scum more info on who isn't the vanilla cop (if someone claims an incorrect result on one of them, for example), but it guarantees that we have all of the investigations as public knowledge while allowing them not to claim and draw a NK.

I've never done this. Have no qualms with it.

[CheekyTeeky]

VOTE: Everyone rabid OMGUS

[necro]

Yeah hypoclaim is good.

[Zulfy]

I think UC Voyager is likely town.

yea why

[necro]

Tfw someone asks you to explain a page1 townread.

[Flairs]

Vote Count 1.1

CheekyTeeky (4): ChaosOmega, Zulfy, wavemode, acidphoenix
Luca Blight (1): necro
UC Voyager (1): Rhah
Rhah (1): UC Voyager
Zulfy (1): Chip Butty

Not voting (5):

Morality, Luca Blight, UnaBombaH, CheekyTeeky, Vanderscamp

With 13 alive, it will take 7 to lynch.

Day 1's deadline is Tuesday, October 17, @ 3 PM EST (expired on 2017-10-17 15:00:00)

[Zulfy]

Don't make reads you're not gonna explain.

[necro]

I'll do whatever I want, thanks.

[UC Voyager]

is he new??????
you dont make reads unless you have something to back it up with.....
and you have townie below your name......probably should have started with a newbie game

[UC Voyager]

those dont mean anything, but townie is one of the first. it is recommended you play a newbie game first.........do you have past mafia experience on other sites?

[necro]

I've never played mafia before in my life, send help.

[Rhah]

UC Voyager... you appear to be acting coy. It does not bode well.

[Chip Butty]

is he new??????
you dont make reads unless you have something to back it up with.....
and you have townie below your name......probably should have started with a newbie game

those dont mean anything, but townie is one of the first. it is recommended you play a newbie game first.........do you have past mafia experience on other sites?

His join date is right there - August 5. No need to infer anything from title. And yours is September 21, even newer. If this isan example of your detective skills, it's going to be a long game...

[necro]

I think we could just move on from how good or bad people are based on these arbitrary numbers, and move onto assessing what alignment people are in this game instead (:

[Zulfy]

VOTE: UC Voyager

[necro]

So Voyager, what do you mean by not 'making reads unless you have something to back it up with'?

What about a huge subset of players (some very competent) who play by feel and instinct, and who don't always have words to explain a read? Should they just not share their reads?

I'd rather share my reads as they are, some will be detailed explanations, some will be short and some might just be based on feeling and difficult to put into words.

[acidphoenix]

VOTE: rhar

you all suck for no l-1

lgi

[Chip Butty]

I think we could just move on from how good or bad people are based on these arbitrary numbers, and move onto assessing what alignment people are in this game instead (:

I'll do whatever I want, thanks.

[necro]

Spicy.

[Chip Butty]

Spicy.

I'll do whatever I want, thanks.

Ditto.

[Vanderscamp]

FIRST

[Vanderscamp]

VOTE: CheekyTeeky

What are everyone's thoughts on hypo-vanilla cop claiming?

Spoiler: For those not knowing what hypo-cop is

On day 2 and onwards (until the vanilla cop role is claimed or killed), every player posts a result as if they were the vanilla cop; the actual vanilla cop tells the truth and everyone else makes up a result. It does possibly give scum more info on who isn't the vanilla cop (if someone claims an incorrect result on one of them, for example), but it guarantees that we have all of the investigations as public knowledge while allowing them not to claim and draw a NK.

I'm fine with this

[Luca Blight]

VOTE: Zulfy

[insert joke here]

[Vanderscamp]

is he new??????
you dont make reads unless you have something to back it up with.....
and you have townie below your name......probably should have started with a newbie game

those dont mean anything, but townie is one of the first. it is recommended you play a newbie game first.........do you have past mafia experience on other sites?

His join date is right there - August 5. No need to infer anything from title. And yours is September 21, even newer. If this isan example of your detective skills, it's going to be a long game...

Wrecked

[Vanderscamp]

I think we could just move on from how good or bad people are based on these arbitrary numbers, and move onto assessing what alignment people are in this game instead (:

A good way to assess alignments is to hear the reasoning behind people's reads, which isn't possible if they don't get explained. How experienced someone is is also definitely not arbitrary because it will help us know how much credit we should be giving people.