Mini Normal 1950 [Engame: Mafia Victory!]

[Vanderscamp]

I'd also like to head necro's reasoning for his UC read but ATM he's my only townread for his refusal to share it.

[UC Voyager]

is he new??????
you dont make reads unless you have something to back it up with.....
and you have townie below your name......probably should have started with a newbie game

those dont mean anything, but townie is one of the first. it is recommended you play a newbie game first.........do you have past mafia experience on other sites?

His join date is right there - August 5. No need to infer anything from title. And yours is September 21, even newer. If this isan example of your detective skills, it's going to be a long game...

Ok......I do have experience off site as well....so all together I have a solid number of days, but it is true that title has nothing to do with experience. In only on the third level of title or so. Watcher, townie, goon....I just find it odd that he makes the most noobie move of making a read without reasoning. As much as I know the read is true....it has nothing to back it up.....

[Vanderscamp]

Vote:Chaos

[UC Voyager]

Solid number of months more or less

[UC Voyager]

Not days...lol

[Rhah]

I'd also like to head necro's reasoning for his UC read but ATM he's my only townread for his refusal to share it.

You consider withholding a read to be indicative? Because that's an easy move for mafia to make, as well. And it is not uncommon.

[Rhah]

Oh yeah. Found it interesting how Chaos opens up with just talking about peeks.

[UC Voyager]

Rhah. Reading without reason is just as indicative as voting without reason. Voting and reading based on gut dealing doesn't work...I have seen to many people die that way, or not die that way.

[UC Voyager]

*gut feeling*.....sorry

[Vanderscamp]

I'd also like to head necro's reasoning for his UC read but ATM he's my only townread for his refusal to share it.

You consider withholding a read to be indicative? Because that's an easy move for mafia to make, as well. And it is not uncommon.

I don't think it's impossible for him to do it but I gave him a mild +

[Rhah]

Rhah. Reading without reason is just as indicative as voting without reason. Voting and reading based on gut dealing doesn't work...I have seen to many people die that way, or not die that way.

You are implying necro has no reason for his read, when it is implied he has one and did not state it... one could infer he is mafia, but they shouldn't for the reasons you seem to be suspecting him for. Simply because a read can be faked. It is easy to create things. It's easy to act aloof. This is a game of pretenses and motivations, after all. I do think you're deliberately choosing to view things a certain way at the moment.

[Rhah]

Hmm... Apologies if I apply pronouns incorrectly. I will try not to going further.

[UC Voyager]

Rhah. Reading without reason is just as indicative as voting without reason. Voting and reading based on gut dealing doesn't work...I have seen to many people die that way, or not die that way.

You are implying necro has no reason for his read, when it is implied he has one and did not state it... one could infer he is mafia, but they shouldn't for the reasons you seem to be suspecting him for. Simply because a read can be faked. It is easy to create things. It's easy to act aloof. This is a game of pretenses and motivations, after all. I do think you're deliberately choosing to view things a certain way at the moment.

Not saying he is scum. Just saying reading for no reason makes no since.

[wavemode]

Don't make reads you're not gonna explain.

Why not

[wavemode]

VOTE: CheekyTeeky

What are everyone's thoughts on hypo-vanilla cop claiming?

Spoiler: For those not knowing what hypo-cop is

On day 2 and onwards (until the vanilla cop role is claimed or killed), every player posts a result as if they were the vanilla cop; the actual vanilla cop tells the truth and everyone else makes up a result. It does possibly give scum more info on who isn't the vanilla cop (if someone claims an incorrect result on one of them, for example), but it guarantees that we have all of the investigations as public knowledge while allowing them not to claim and draw a NK.

Isn't this better in open setups

Do we even know there's a cop

[wavemode]

imagine we did lynch her right off the bat like that and she flipped scum. that would be super lucky

I've seen it happen

It's always hilarious

And town always goes on to lose the game, believe it or not

[wavemode]

is he new??????
you dont make reads unless you have something to back it up with.....
and you have townie below your name......probably should have started with a newbie game

VOTE: UC Voyager

[Morality]

Don't make reads you're not gonna explain.

Why would someone be able to explain it right now? Looks like you’re saying stuff for the sake of saying it.

VOTE: Zulfy

[Morality]

I tend to use that Vanilla Cop strategy when the situation calls for it. Doesn’t necessarily have to be vanilla cop, though.

[necro]

Oh yeah. Found it interesting how Chaos opens up with just talking about peeks.

Chaos is probably town.

[necro]

VOTE: CheekyTeeky

What are everyone's thoughts on hypo-vanilla cop claiming?

Spoiler: For those not knowing what hypo-cop is

On day 2 and onwards (until the vanilla cop role is claimed or killed), every player posts a result as if they were the vanilla cop; the actual vanilla cop tells the truth and everyone else makes up a result. It does possibly give scum more info on who isn't the vanilla cop (if someone claims an incorrect result on one of them, for example), but it guarantees that we have all of the investigations as public knowledge while allowing them not to claim and draw a NK.

Isn't this better in open setups

Do we even know there's a cop

Good thing this is an open setup then.

[UC Voyager]

i feel like necro is town

reasoning: ????????????????

[UC Voyager]

meh...could just be me. i really like to see reasoning. it makes me feel safer than just voting or reading based on feeling. you know.....

[UC Voyager]

ima be honest. here is what im feeling

town
me (duh.)
Necro
CheekyTeeky
Zulph
Morality
Wave Mode

mafia
Rhah
??????'
????? (possibly. idk. might be 3)
???????? (probably not 4 lol)

[Chip Butty]

VOTE: CheekyTeeky

What are everyone's thoughts on hypo-vanilla cop claiming?

Spoiler: For those not knowing what hypo-cop is

On day 2 and onwards (until the vanilla cop role is claimed or killed), every player posts a result as if they were the vanilla cop; the actual vanilla cop tells the truth and everyone else makes up a result. It does possibly give scum more info on who isn't the vanilla cop (if someone claims an incorrect result on one of them, for example), but it guarantees that we have all of the investigations as public knowledge while allowing them not to claim and draw a NK.

Isn't this better in open setups

Do we even know there's a cop

ima be honest. here is what im feeling

town
me (duh.)
Necro
CheekyTeeky
Zulph
Morality
Wave Mode

mafia
Rhah
??????'
????? (possibly. idk. might be 3)
???????? (probably not 4 lol)

People, the setup is in the OP ffs.