Open 698: Stack the Deck (GAME OVER)

[Realeo]

I kinda do not understand anybody's read. Everybody read is something like X is scum because he townread or scumread Y.

Like, pretty much

anybody

is scummy for doing that.

I never get analysis like "well it is scummy, but the reason at the end of the day it is scum is..."

The linearity of the logic is annoying.

[Realeo]

I kinda like Mulch's read and Luca's read, but the problem with Mulch' read is that the progression of confidence is unnatural. Mulch can be hyper-aggressive, but not sure if it warrants such hyper-aggressiveness.

[Realeo]

I don't know why people care about vig pool. For all its worth, I could be a vig and don't give a fuck about it.

[Realeo]

I don't understand why Una has to scumread Alchemist's question. It's pretty much just a interrogative question. You can't accuse someone not giving a honest evaluation if you don't shut up and allow him to respond to your clarification.

[Realeo]

I like 974.

[Realeo]

If you guys allow me, I am going to shut up again. Me not talking in D2 seems to be a wise choice.

[Realeo]

I have a made a lot of stand on a lot of shit.

I am the first guy who made a stand on why you are unlikely to be non-traitor.
I am the first guy who made a stand why Assembrelowts is scum.
I am the first guy who made a stand on IceGuy telling why he is unlikely to be non-traitor.

Don't you tell me how to make a stand, especially since you're in D1 decided not to make a stand.

[Realeo]

Talking to 971. I understand your frustration but I do not understand the read progression.

[Realeo]

There is a moment in mafia that when you feel you're dominating the game, you must shut up and allow others to speak up...

...which is why I am excited for ironstove.

[Realeo]

The problem of this game is that the justification of "Your argument is too generic or copying" is being used too often. (Remember nIceGuy?) which hint to a dynamic problem in this game.

Just because someone is too generic or copying, does not mean scum flailing. It can mean great towns think alike, but one bitch consistently talk about it earlier.

So I shut up. So we can actually know if it is the former or the latter.

#inb4PhilosophyWallAccusation

[Realeo]

How is this is not my position on his lynch?

I am the first guy who made a stand on why you are unlikely to be non-traitor.

I'm going to return back to my verbose mode.

[Realeo]

I don't understand how Assembrelowts have 4 game commitments.

[Realeo]

Ho. Ho. I like Assembrelowts just changed his sig.

[Realeo]

As a protest for being scumread for "being verbose", I'm using a picture because..it's zero word?



The more left you are, the townier I read you.
The wider the bar, the more uncertain I am.

Not to be read in an absolute scale (conf town to conf scum) but as a relative scale (the townies of all to the scummies of all)

Move Alchemist to the left and make the wide of the bar smaller.
Grapes stays there but increase the wide a bit.
Move Mulch to the left but make the wide of the bar

way

even bigger.
Move Luca to the right.
Make ChipButty wide even bigger.
Move Unah to the right but increase the wide.
Ironstove is somewhere between ChipButty and Unah.
Make Assembrelowts ???

[Realeo]

I know, but isn't out priority is to hit the other two mafia because those are where the mafia power role?

[Realeo]

So, your CURRENT position is still that UnaH Is scum but not the traitor?

I did not say that.

[Realeo]

I am going to avoid this semantic battle.

[Realeo]

The awful ms paint picture is meant to demonstrate how scummy I scumread someone but how uncertain I am. That was done in such way because in D1, I felt ChipButty was scummier but I was more certain that IceGuy is scum ("How do you answer who is your strongest scumread question in such trade off?") so when CB asked for my read list D1, I just do it that way to avoid semantic debate (You do want use to avoid that right?)

And I find it effective because CB didn't ask for follow up question.

At this point, I am happy with ironstove, Assembrelowts (maybe?), UNAH (as I foreshadowed, I do not like how he reacted to Alchemist so I move him to the right [ie.scummier], but his 971 seems town so I widen the bar [ie.uncertainty]), and CB.

Who is my strongest scum read? I'm not even sure how to communicate it correctly since the way you intepret who is my strongest scumread may be different on your priority, so let the picture speaks for itself.

[Realeo]

For the record, Assembre was the clear scummiest until the signature change. That signature change throws me off.

[Realeo]

Take example of the current situation. If you take the center point, UNAH would be the scummiest, but if you take the right edge, you would take ironstove as the scummiest. However, my uncertainty at ironstove is so big that I he can be the towniest of {UNAH,CB,is} and the scummiest of {UNAH,CB,is} at the same time. What a dilemma!

[Realeo]

I have addressed it in page 41. Please help yourself.

[Realeo]

So, your CURRENT position is still that UnaH Is scum but not the traitor?

I did not say that.

I have addressed it in page 41. Please help yourself.

No you didn't. Why are you squirming?

Yes I did.

You are self proclaimed genius. Go look for it again.

I know, but isn't out priority is to hit the other two mafia because those are where the mafia power role?

Are...are you actually saying 'yeah UnaH is scum but let's not lynch him because the non-traitors have higher priority'?

I mean, first, it's either 7-3 or 7-2 (+1). We don't have much wriggle room.

Second, why so sure there was no recruitment?

Third, wow.

No response to this, either.

I did not imply that I am sure there is no recruitment.

[Realeo]

Hey LucaBlight. We don't really talk to each other but we mysteriously townlean each other. That needs to be fixed or people would figure it out when one of us flipped!

@LucaBlight

Truth to be told, I don't really understand your reasoning of null-scum Alchemist and town-lean Commknight. Like, you scumread Alchemist for not really scumhunting except in the beginning but then he made a weird stand at the end. Isn't it the case with CoammKnight as well?

[Realeo]

I just noticed that my lynch pool resembles CommKnight's lynch pool.

@LucaBlight

So Una didn't trigger you in his recent giant green text?

[Realeo]

Do people feel that Realeo has adequately clarified his current position on a UnaH lynch?

I endorse this question.

[Realeo]

CommKnight is a little bit too far for me to compromise.

1 day remaining.

[Realeo]

Like CommKnight is so far to the center, I would lynch Unah in a heart beat.

[Realeo]

Like CommKnight is so far to the center, I would lynch Unah in a heart beat.

I may as well move to Unah

VOTE: Unah

[Realeo]

VOTE: Assembrelowts

[Realeo]

What just happened?

[Realeo]

I am satisfied with my play here.

But yeah, I acknowledge there is a correlation between my reading accuracy and the amount of content created by other players. I'm still working with how to make reads with minimal content, so if anybody would like to share tips--please