Large Normal 207: Theatre Mafia

[Boonskiies]

Sheeting was sheeping. Yes.

[Mulch]

Firstly, this is not Burden of Proof. I'm not asking you to prove that you are not scummy, I'm pointing out reasons you could be scummy! Big difference there.
And the scummy stems from:
A: Lots of one-sentence, vague answers (None of which that I just pointed out you will explain.)
B: Obvious panic and self-defense
C: Wanting to kill other players just because they don't agree with you and/or scumread you. Yeah, that especially isn't scummy at all.

Why are one sentence words scummy? Why is self defense scummy?

How do you know I’m panicking? I was not.

I only want to kill bad wrong players, like you and NK15. People I disagree with that are good like rask and boon can live

[James Brafin]

Well, I have a feeling that Mulch may be bussing Xand for something. But so far, I've read 18 and found no answers. SO I'm starting to lose faith in him.
You're absolutle right. It makes NO sense to keep on Xand's bandwagon when the evidence is low.
Unfortunately, it may make little difference. With L-4, It looks bad for Xand.

[Boonskiies]

Nah. If he was scum, you look more like the busses than Mulch. Why would Mulch push him so hard right now if thye were buddies, when he easily could push elsewhere and stop his buddies lynch?

[James Brafin]

Firstly, this is not Burden of Proof. I'm not asking you to prove that you are not scummy, I'm pointing out reasons you could be scummy! Big difference there.
And the scummy stems from:
A: Lots of one-sentence, vague answers (None of which that I just pointed out you will explain.)
B: Obvious panic and self-defense
C: Wanting to kill other players just because they don't agree with you and/or scumread you. Yeah, that especially isn't scummy at all.

Why are one sentence words scummy? Why is self defense scummy?

One sentence allows you to make accusation without really giving a reason. Self Defense is only scummy when it is panicked.

How do you know I’m panicking? I was not.

Sure looked like panic to me. Maybe it wasn't but that doesn't seem to be the case.

I only want to kill bad wrong players, like you and NK15. People I disagree with that are good like rask and boon can live

In other words, players that don't agree with you most of the time should be killed, while players that do agree with you most of the time should not. THAT makes a lot of sense.

[James Brafin]

Nah. If he was scum, you look more like the busses than Mulch. Why would Mulch push him so hard right now if thye were buddies, when he easily could push elsewhere and stop his buddies lynch?

Because that's what bussing is: pushing to get a scum that the town knows about lynched so that you look like town.

[Boonskiies]

But I feel like Mulch is the one who caused the Jordan wagon.

[Boonskiies]

That’s why it doesn’t add up to me.

[Boonskiies]

I don’t see their reactions as SvS at all, and if they are both scum, it’s kind of poor play, because people will realize it’s true in the late game when they forget about their interactions, so getting rid of one another this early and in this way is poor play. I don’t feel either of them are poor scum players.

[James Brafin]

Not if one guy is dead. Then Mulch will look really town.
But I may be using the wrong terminology here. If Mulch is scum and Xand is not, then he's trying for a mislynch, not a bus.
But if they are both scum, then Mulch is trying for a bus.
Either way, this only makes sense if Mulch is scum.
Of course, then again, Mulch could also be getting a misread, but I don't think that's what is going on right now.

[Boonskiies]

Why can’t mulch be town pushing a towns person?

[Boonskiies]

That’s exactly what I think is happening.

[Not Known 15]

That’s exactly what I think is happening.

I think what should happen is that we all jump on the XnadrojX wagon before time runs out and we get a nolynch.
Also, what should happen is that some investigative person looks at Mulch(because Mulch is currently scum for some, and town for others)
Also, what should not happen is that Mulch(not everyone, just mulch) vigs me or james(because that would make them look like a Serial Killer)

[Boonskiies]

That’s exactly what I think is happening.

I think what should happen is that we all jump on the XnadrojX wagon before time runs out and we get a nolynch.
Also, what should happen is that some investigative person looks at Mulch(because Mulch is currently scum for some, and town for others)
Also, what should not happen is that Mulch(not everyone, just mulch) vigs me or james(because that would make them look like a Serial Killer)

I disagree. I think what should happen is we all go on someone other than him before time runs out.

[Boonskiies]

Mulch is a fine investigative target. In fact. He is the answer. Okay, guys? If only 1, then it’s Mulch.

[James Brafin]

I’ve unfortunately seen him tunnel town before, and seen him hit scum on my null reads that I’ve protected before. I don’t believe that he’s ever hit scum on someone I town read, though, unless he was scum.

I think for this reason, Mulch was scum. He seems to be pushing a town read for no reason except he can. And that seems SO fishy to me. He's so completely tunneling it's not even funny, and isn't looking at the possibility that Xand might not be scum.

That’s exactly what I think is happening.

I think what should happen is that we all jump on the XnadrojX wagon before time runs out and we get a nolynch.

Either you mean we all jump off and we get a no-lynch, or we all jump on and get a potential mislynch. Right?

Also, what should happen is that some investigative person looks at Mulch(because Mulch is currently scum for some, and town for others)

Definitely needs to happen.

Also, what should not happen is that Mulch(not everyone, just mulch) vigs me or james(because that would make them look like a Serial Killer)

My guess is that Mulch IS an SK, and he's going to try and blow it off as vig kills.

[Boonskiies]

Mulch

was

scum?

[Not Known 15]

We have less than 1 day left, Xnad has much more votes than everyone else, no big amount of players has moved, and Xnad might be scum, after all. Time is running out, we might get a D1 Nolynch if not everyone who comes to this thread votes for Xnad, and that before time runs out. A great amount of players is not that active. A D1 mislynch is actually better than a D1 nolynch, and it might not be a mislynch after all.

[James Brafin]

Mulch

was

scum?

Excuse me. Wrong tense. Mulch

IS

scum

[wavemode]

VOTE: XnadrojX

[James Brafin]

Here's what we are looking at, folks:

Official Vote Count

XnadrojX

(7): Fykus, Mulch, massive, mozamis, Not Known 15, texcat, wavemode

massive

(3): UnaBombaH, acidphoenix, XnadrojX

Mulch

(2): Raskolnikov, James Brafin

James Brafin

(2): pisskop, Boonskiies

mozamis

(1): Dunkerdoodles

Fykus

(1): Kaminaseigaku

Boonskiies

(1): Carcalilly

Not Voting

(1): Assemblerotws

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch.

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-10-14 15:00:00)

[massive]

Boon, why does James replace scum-Meow and swing for the fences? There are players I can see doing that but let's take James at face value. Does newbscum-James really attack this hard?

[Dunkerdoodles]

i don't like xan wagon at all
VOTE: mulch
looks like this is more likely then moz

[Mulch]

i don't like xan wagon at all
VOTE: mulch
looks like this is more likely then moz

Why are you hell bent on ruining this game?

[Dunkerdoodles]

sorry i just really think you're scum

i'll hammer xan if he gets to L-1